- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript points out that in IMVC, existing imputation-based methods mostly recover missing views, and estimate cluster assignments in separate steps. Therefore, the authors propose to use the same reference samples and relation weights for both view recovery and direct soft assignment throughout the whole procedure. The proposed method, ReSA, first derives the nearest neighbors as reference samples, and uses them for two purposes: (1) recovering missing views and aggregating all views to obtain a global assignment; (2) getting directly soft-assignments. All results are ultimately integrated through consensus clustering. Extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of this method.
Critical strengths
1.The authors have proposed a well-designed method which achieves strong performance on a wide range of datasets.
2.The manuscript is clearly written and technically sound. The authors identify an under-explored design choice and propose a novel approach based on shared references and relation weights.
Critical weaknesses
Despite my appreciation of the writing and reasoning, the significance of this manuscript is not sufficiently established. The authors do not sufficiently justify the benefits of sharing references and relation weights over using separate relations for the two estimation tasks. It seems also natural to obtain missing views from one set of references and cluster with another. Moreover, some methods adopt different approaches for view recovery and clustering, making it unclear whether sharing the same references would be appropriate or beneficial in these settings.
Questions for authors
1.Why is not sharing references a problem? I would like to see further clarifications on this.
2.A key design of ReSA is to integrate assignments from both global assignment and view-specific assignments. I wonder if this framework would work even without shared references and weights. Have the authors considered using different reference sets or relation weights for representation recovery and direct soft-assignment estimation, while retaining the same global–view consensus clustering procedure?
3.In the global assignment branch, representation recovery and global assignment estimation do not directly share the same references and weights. Therefore, this branch alone still follows a paradigm similar to the one criticized in the motivation. Why does ReSA introduce sharing between two parallel branches rather than between the two sequential stages of representation recovery and assignment estimation?
4.As a minor reminder, the AI use disclosure appears incomplete. The ICLR 2027 AI Policy for Authors provides an example that also explicitly states which tasks requiring disclosure did not involve AI use. I encourage the authors to revise this section in accordance with the ICLR 2027 AI Policy for Authors.