- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents BambooSR, a physics-aware implicit neural representation framework for super-resolving sparse and heterogeneous detector readouts in the PandaX-4T experiment. The method reconstructs a continuous signal field from 169 physical PMT measurements and integrates it over a denser virtual layout of 1261 PMTs. The paper also introduces a new paired simulation benchmark for this task and evaluates the method on both simulated data and real PandaX-4T wall events.
Critical strengths
1.The paper studies a relatively novel application and provides a dedicated benchmark. It formulates super-resolution for sparse and heterogeneous PandaX-4T detector readouts and introduces a paired LR-HR simulation dataset with real detector data for downstream evaluation.
2.The method uses physical priors as soft guidance and validates their contribution with controlled experiments. Physics-derived features are injected through a learnable adapter, while the neural control suggests that the gains are not simply due to increased model capacity.
Critical weaknesses
1.Although the application setting is new, the underlying task remains fundamentally a super-resolution problem. The main difference is the sparse and heterogeneous sensor layout, while existing INR methods such as FFN, SIREN, WIRE, and SASNet can still be adapted to this setting. Thus, the novelty lies mainly in the application, sensing geometry, and physics-aware design rather than a fundamentally new learning paradigm.
2.The quantitative improvements are clear, but the qualitative differences are relatively subtle. Even in the enlarged regions, BambooSR looks similar to the stronger INR baselines, making the practical significance of some numerical gains less visually evident. More challenging examples could better demonstrate the advantage of the proposed method.
3.Paper does not report inference efficiency. Although BambooSR performs feed-forward inference, each HR PMT requires multiple quadrature-point evaluations for finite-area integration. Reporting inference time, memory usage, or computational cost relative to the main INR baselines would better clarify its practicality for detector reconstruction.
Questions for authors
1.Since existing INR methods can already be adapted to this signal super-resolution setting, could the authors clarify more explicitly what aspects of the task fundamentally require the proposed formulation beyond adapting standard continuous SR methods to irregular sensor geometry?
2.The numerical improvements over the strongest baselines are measurable, but the qualitative differences appear relatively small in the provided visualizations. Could the authors provide additional examples, particularly difficult cases near the detector boundary or inactive sensors, where the advantage of BambooSR is visually more evident?
6 comments
W3.2-Q3.2
Response to W2 / Q2
We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion. We agree that the qualitative visualizations in our original submission did not make the differences among reconstruction methods sufficiently clear, particularly in challenging boundary cases. We have therefore improved the visualization by adding a side-by-side comparison of the reconstructed two-dimensional fields and a corresponding one-dimensional profile, providing a more detailed view of the differences among methods.
For our scientific task, the primary objective is to improve quantitative reconstruction accuracy rather than visual appearance alone. In detector reconstruction, spatial fields that appear visually similar may still produce different channel-integrated signals and downstream position estimates. Therefore, quantitative reconstruction errors and position-resolution metrics remain our primary evaluation criteria, while qualitative visualizations serve as complementary checks of spatial morphology and physical plausibility.
The practical relevance of these numerical improvements can be illustrated using the PandaX-4T detector. In our main seed-42 results, BambooSR combined with COG reduces the calibrated wall-event spread () from 11.01 mm (original LR COG) to 6.65 mm, corresponding to a 39.6% reduction. The resulting and MAE are 4.19 mm and 3.57 mm, respectively. As an illustrative estimate, if the 4.36 mm reduction in radial spread could translate into an equivalent reduction in the radial fiducial-boundary margin, the corresponding cylindrical side-wall shell would contain approximately 18.9 L, or 54 kg, of liquid xenon. At an indicative semiconductor-grade xenon benchmark of approximately USD 2,650/kg, this represents a material-equivalent value of approximately USD 143,000. This is a conditional geometric illustration rather than a demonstrated fiducial-volume gain or actual procurement-cost saving, as the achievable improvement depends on the background distribution and physics-selection requirements.
Following the reviewer's suggestion, we have expanded Appendix E.4 (Representative Reconstructions Under Challenging Conditions) with two additional qualitative visualizations:
- Local continuous-field comparison: We compare the reconstructed fields of BambooSR, FFN, WIRE, SIREN, and SASNet for the same representative boundary event, together with the corresponding LR observation. All reconstructed fields share a common spatial window, color scale, and contour levels, making differences in peak morphology and local spatial variations easier to inspect.
- One-dimensional field profile: We further compare the reconstructed fields along a common section passing through the detector origin and the observed LR charge centroid. The profiles are obtained by interpolating the cached field grids, allowing peak shapes and local variations to be examined along a shared spatial coordinate.
These visualizations provide qualitative complements to the quantitative evaluation. Since pointwise ground truth for the continuous fields is unavailable, we do not interpret visual similarity as direct evidence of reconstruction accuracy or claim that any particular method is closest to the true underlying field.
The two additional figures and their accompanying descriptions have been incorporated into Appendix E.4 (Figures 15 and 16).
W3.3
Response to W3.3
We thank the reviewer for encouraging us to characterize the computational efficiency of the proposed method. We first clarify that the position-reconstruction task considered in this work is intended for offline detector-data analysis rather than online triggering. Therefore, strict real-time latency constraints are not a requirement of the current application. Nevertheless, inference efficiency is important for assessing the practical computational cost of the proposed finite-area integration.
To provide a controlled comparison, we benchmark BambooSR and four INR baselines on the same NVIDIA V100 32GB GPU. All methods use the same input pool, 1,261 HR output channels, and 128 integration points per channel, corresponding to 161,408 spatial evaluation points per event. The reported inference time includes conditioning, continuous-field evaluation, and weighted integration and reduction, thereby accounting for the computational cost of evaluating the field at multiple integration points.
| Method | Single-event median (ms) ↓ | Single-event P95 (ms) ↓ | Batch-8 latency (ms) ↓ | Batch-8 throughput (events/s) ↑ | Peak tensor memory (MiB) ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BambooSR | 36.24 | 36.86 | 56.19 | 143.5 | 115.8 |
| FFN | 12.57 | 13.31 | 35.21 | 228.9 | 122.3 |
| WIRE | 16.38 | 16.77 | 80.22 | 97.3 | 271.6 |
| SIREN | 11.98 | 12.60 | 36.85 | 218.6 | 115.1 |
| SASNet | 116.74 | 118.22 | 117.75 | 68.3 | 121.0 |
BambooSR achieves a single-event median latency of 36.24 ms and a batch-8 throughput of 143.5 events/s, with a peak PyTorch tensor allocation of 115.8 MiB. Its batch throughput is lower than those of FFN and SIREN, but higher than those of WIRE and SASNet. Its memory requirement remains comparable to the other methods and substantially lower than that of WIRE.
At this measured throughput, inference for the complete set of 5,583 real wall events would take approximately 39 seconds. This estimate covers model inference only and excludes data transfer, file I/O, and subsequent position reconstruction and calibration. Overall, these measurements indicate that the finite-area integration used by BambooSR introduces a measurable computational cost, while remaining practical for offline reconstruction at the scale considered in this study.
We sincerely appreciate your time and thoughtful feedback, which have helped us further strengthen this work.
W3.1-Q3.1
We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing the novelty of the detector-specific super-resolution task, the contribution of our paired LR–HR benchmark, and the role of physics-informed features supported by controlled experiments. We also appreciate the thoughtful questions regarding the positioning of our methodological contributions, the qualitative presentation of challenging reconstructions, and the computational efficiency of our approach. These constructive comments have helped us improve the presentation and provide additional evidence for the proposed framework. All modifications to the manuscript are highlighted in Bamboo Green for ease of your review.
Response to W1 / Q1
We thank the reviewer for this thoughtful assessment of the novelty of our work. We agree that BambooSR does not introduce a fundamentally new learning paradigm, and that existing INR architectures such as FFN, SIREN, WIRE, and SASNet can be adapted to the detector super-resolution task. We therefore position our contribution not as a new general-purpose INR architecture, but as a physics-aware continuous super-resolution framework tailored to the sparse and heterogeneous sensing conditions of particle detectors.
Importantly, the physics-aware design is not merely an architectural addition; its contribution is supported by controlled ablation experiments. We evaluate two complementary variants. First, Direct-only removes the explicit boundary-response feature while retaining the other geometric and propagation-related features. Restoring the boundary-response feature reduces RMSE from 2.576 to 2.185 PE/channel, edge RMSE from 2.707 to 2.311 PE/channel, and PMT3-region RMSE from 2.965 to 2.745 PE/channel. Second, Neural control preserves the same head and adapter dimensions but replaces the six physics-derived features with generic event- and coordinate-dependent features. The full BambooSR model improves all eight reported metrics over this control, reducing RMSE from 2.421 to 2.185 PE/channel. These comparisons demonstrate that the explicit boundary-response feature and the physics-informed feature content contribute beyond the use of an auxiliary adaptation branch alone.
We further examine physical reliability beyond aggregate channel-level errors. Appendix E.3 (Figure 10) presents event-level HR total-PE calibration, comparing predicted and ground-truth event totals across the test set. BambooSR maintains a compact, nearly diagonal calibration relation across the signal range, with a global signed total bias of approximately +0.05%. Importantly, the two-dimensional distributions also expose additional low-PE failure populations in several competing methods that can be obscured by aggregate signed bias through cancellation between over- and under-predicted events. This provides a complementary assessment of event-level signal preservation, particularly in the weak-signal regime.
Spatial plausibility is examined through representative challenging cases in Appendix E.4. These examples cover weak and strong signals near the masked physical PMT and detector boundary. In response to the reviewer's suggestion in W3.2, we have further added a common-scale two-dimensional continuous-field comparison and a corresponding one-dimensional profile, making differences in spatial localization, peak morphology, and local variations easier to inspect. These visualizations complement the quantitative results by providing qualitative checks of the reconstructed spatial structures, without treating visual similarity as pointwise ground-truth evidence.
Finally, the relevance of this detector-specific formulation is supported by our real-data downstream evaluation. Using the same 5,583 PandaX-4T Run 2 wall events and a common COG estimator, BambooSR reduces the calibrated wall-event spread from 11.01 to 6.65 mm, corresponding to a 39.6% improvement in position resolution. This demonstrates that the proposed signal reconstruction framework provides benefits beyond the simulated super-resolution benchmark and can improve a practically relevant downstream detector-reconstruction task.
The corresponding real-data evaluation is presented in Section 5.2 (Figure 5 and Table 3), with the common downstream reconstruction and cross-calibration protocol detailed in Appendix F.2.
Taken together, we appreciate the reviewer's characterization of the contribution. We do not claim a fundamentally new INR learning paradigm. Rather, our contribution lies in formulating detector-specific continuous super-resolution under sparse and heterogeneous sensing, introducing physics-informed features that provide measurable improvements over generic learned adaptation, and establishing their relevance through both event-level signal diagnostics and real-detector evaluation.