acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Embodied Task Agents Can Perform Fine Manipulation through Tactile In-Context Learning

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

16 views

Abstract

Can embodied task agents use tactile experience to perform fine manipulation without task-specific model training? We investigate this capability through Tactile-ETA, a system that incorporates tactile experience into an embodied task agent through in-context learning. Successful expert demonstrations show how contact changes during manipulation. We pair each recorded robot movement with its camera views and bilateral tactile observations. We keep tactile observations at the start and end of each movement and add two neighboring time points when the tactile images change markedly in between. The agent combines these demonstrations with current vision, tactile observations, and proprioception to select actions through general-purpose robot tools, without updating model parameters. Across four simulated manipulation tasks, adding tactile observations to the same two expert demonstrations increases average success from 15.75% to 24.00%, with current sensing and execution interfaces held fixed. Further experiments show that performance depends on the sensory content and representation of demonstrations, while comparing agent models on Lift Bottle reveals substantial differences under the same system configuration. On the real-robot tasks, demonstrations with aligned visual and tactile observations increase the task success rate from 0% to 60%. These findings demonstrate the feasibility of using tactile experience in context for fine manipulation and suggest a path toward extending embodied task agents to additional sensory inputs.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
In-Context Learning, Embodied Agents, Tactile Perception, Contact-Rich Manipulation, Multimodal Large Language Models

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_45uDOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This method proposes putting raw tactile images into the demonstration context of a frozen, tool-using agent, plus a controlled comparison that holds current sensing fixed. The main claim is that tactile content in demonstrations helps, beyond current tactile sensing.

Critical strengths

The research question is well scoped and clear. The main comparison between Visual–motion and Tactile-ETA that use the same expert episodes, segmentation, sensing, controller, and budgets seems reasonable. Only the tactile content in the demos differs, which is the right comparison to make. I also like that the negative results are reported honestly. The authors have also done a good job with reproducibility by giving all the details in the appendix.

Critical weaknesses

While sensible, this work doesn’t seem to be a contribution on its own that is well established in the paper. Here are some of my main concerns with the paper: There seems to be limited novelty. Each component described in the pipeline like, frozen-LLM in-context imitation, VLM agents using demos plus closed-loop feedback, tactile reasoning in VLMs, etc., already exists.

The experiments also seem sparse and low in number. There's one demonstration pair, one run per condition, and no confidence intervals which make the results anecdotal and not high in confidence.

The results also seem a bit fragile. In one of the applications, success goes from 36% to 2% with four demos instead of two; from 36% to 2% with all frames instead of Selected; from 36% to 0% with a different model. This sensitivity makes it hard to tell real tactile in-context learning apart from a prompt configuration tuned to these conditions.

The real-robot experiment doesn't test the central claim. It compares no demo against one tactile demo, with no visual–motion arm, and runs only five trials. It shows that demonstrations help, not that tactile content helps.

The results also rely on a model at a specific reasoning setting, and model versions keep changing. Naming is also inconsistent: "GPT-6" in the main text, "GPT-6 Astra" in the appendices.

Questions for authors

These are my main questions:

  1. How does performance change if the demonstration tactile strips are shuffled across segments or swapped with strips from a different episode?
  2. Can you report results over multiple demonstration pairs and multiple seeds, with confidence intervals?
  3. Why were the representation and model ablations run only on Lift Bottle? Can you report the others too?
  4. On the real robot, what is the success rate with a visual–motion demonstration and no tactile content?
  5. What explains Lift Bottle dropping to 2% with four demos and with all frames? Is it context length, image count, or contradictory demonstrations? Do episode traces show a characteristic failure mode?
Reviewer_qLcdOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies whether a frozen embodied task agent can use tactile experience provided in context to perform contact-sensitive fine manipulation, without any task-specific training. The proposed pipeline, Tactile-ETA, segments expert demonstrations at action boundaries and aligns, per segment, before/after camera views, numerical motion records, and bilateral tactile sequences compacted to segment endpoints plus one peak-change pair (at most four frames per fingertip). A frozen VLM selects tool calls conditioned on this demonstration context together with current observations and execution feedback. The evaluation covers four UniVTAC simulation tasks with 100 paired initial conditions per cell (15.75% → 24.00% average success when tactile frames are added to identical visual–motion demonstrations), representation and demonstration-count ablations, a four-model comparison, behavioral-trace analyses, and a two-task real-robot study (0/5 → 3/5 with one multimodal demonstration).

Critical strengths
  1. Clean within-system identification of the tactile contribution (Sec. 4.1–4.3, Tables 1–3, App. C). Holding initial conditions, expert episodes, current sensing, and execution interfaces fixed while varying only the presence of demonstration tactile images makes the central comparison credible. The All-frames collapse (2%) is a thoughtful control against the "longer context" confound, and the behavioral counts (48/100 vs 13/100 advancing-into-failure episodes) corroborate the mechanism behind the Insert Tube improvement.
  2. Exceptionally transparent and auditable protocol (App. A–F). The paper documents hyperparameters, trial accounting (1,086 + 114 supplemented rollouts), script-computed counts from locked records with all-episode denominators, verbatim agent messages paired with measured displacements, and negative results openly. This level of care makes the reported feasibility signal trustworthy and sets a good example for agent-system evaluation.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The method's standing relative to existing approaches is not established (Sec. 4, Table 1). All comparisons are internal ablations of the same system; no trained policy or prior method from the same benchmark is ever referenced. As a result, readers cannot tell whether 24% average success approaches what trained policies achieve on these tasks or falls well short of it — which feels central for an empirical paper whose contribution is a capability claim. Combined with the sensitivity evidence (Lift Can regression 3→2; 4-shot degradation; 0–36% model spread), the conditions under which the method helps remain somewhat unclear. Citing published numbers alone may not fully resolve this, but even such reference points would substantially clarify the contribution's scale, and a direct comparison would resolve it.
  2. The real-robot result does not yet isolate the tactile contribution (Sec. 4.5, App. E; Abstract). With only two configurations and no visual–motion-only control, the 0/5 → 3/5 improvement shows that providing a demonstration helps, but not specifically that tactile experience helps. The abstract's "0% to 60%" framing reads as evidence for tactile in-context learning, which is stronger than what the five human-judged trials currently support; a visual–motion control condition, or a more conservative framing, would bring the claim and evidence into alignment.
Questions for authors
  1. [Clarification] What success rates do UniVTAC's trained baselines (ACT, VITaL, ACT+UniVTAC encoder) report on these four tasks? Even as published reference points rather than new runs, these would help readers situate the 24% average.
  2. [Clarification] Could you report paired significance tests (e.g., McNemar over the shared initial conditions) or bootstrap confidence intervals for Table 1, particularly for Lift Bottle and Pull Out Key? This appears to be a reanalysis of existing rollout data.
  3. [Clarification] Was a visual–motion-only demonstration condition ever run on the real robot? If so, reporting it would be very helpful; if not, some discussion of why this control was omitted on hardware would clarify how the real-robot result should be interpreted.
  4. [Future Work] Broader model × task coverage, more real-robot trials, and coupling segment-level tactile guidance with fast tactile feedback control would strengthen the story, though these are not required for my score.
Reviewer_RQXhOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
3
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The paper asks whether a frozen embodied task agent (GPT-6 controlling a robot through OpenETA's move/observe tools) can perform contact-sensitive manipulation when expert tactile experience is given in context. Tactile-ETA splits each successful expert episode at action boundaries; each segment carries the motion record, before/after camera views and left/right tactile image strips, keeping the endpoint tactile frames plus one adjacent pair around the largest tactile change (Sec. 3.2, Eq. 2). The agent also receives current vision, tactile images, proprioception and execution feedback; no parameters are updated. On four UniVTAC simulation tasks with 100 trials per condition, adding tactile observations to the same two visual–motion demonstrations raises average success from 15.75% to 24.00% (Table 1). Content and representation ablations (Tables 2–3), a demonstration-count study (Table 8), a comparison of four agent models (Fig. 5) and two real-robot tasks (0/5 → 3/5 with one demonstration) are reported, together with scripted behavioural counts and case studies.

Critical strengths
  1. The central comparison is well controlled: the visual–motion and Tactile-ETA conditions use the same two expert episodes, the same current sensing and the same tools, differing only in whether the demonstrations carry tactile strips (Sec. 4.1, Appendix Table 4); success is judged by the environment, not the agent (Appendix A.4); prompts, tool schemas and trial accounting are documented. The question itself, whether a frozen agent can exploit a new sensing modality purely through context, is timely.
  2. Negative and fragile results are reported rather than hidden (All frames 2%, 4-shot Lift Bottle 2%, Lift Can near zero, model dependence in Fig. 5).
Critical weaknesses
  1. The task set is too small and does not test what the paper claims, and the absolute performance is below a trained baseline the paper does not mention. Four of UniVTAC's eight tasks are used, with no reason given. In UniVTAC's own taxonomy, two of them (Lift Bottle, Lift Can) are "pose reasoning" tasks that rely primarily on perceiving object position, while the tasks the benchmark designates as tactile-dependent (Grasp Classify, which requires distinguishing shapes by touch) and the two hardest contact tasks (Insert Hole, Insert HDMI) are omitted. The paper's own data confirm that these tasks do not require touch: current tactile sensing without demonstrations changes average success only from 3.00% to 6.25% and lowers Lift Bottle from 7 to 3 (Table 1). On the real robot there are two tasks with five trials each. This is not enough to support "embodied task agents can perform fine manipulation". Moreover, UniVTAC's Table I reports a vision-only ACT trained on 50 demonstrations at 45 / 20 / 42 / 28 on Insert Tube / Lift Can / Lift Bottle / Pull Out Key (ACT with the UniVTAC tactile encoder: 56 / 29 / 71 / 46), against Tactile-ETA's 32 / 2 / 36 / 26 under the same native criteria. The method is below a vision-only trained policy on every task and ten times lower on Lift Can. The paper does not cite these numbers or any trained policy. A few-shot, no-training setting can be a legitimate contribution, but then the paper must state this reference point and argue what the agent offers that the trained policy does not; as written, the title and abstract claim fine manipulation without the comparison that would let a reader judge it.

  2. The main result does not separate tactile information from the amount of image content in context, and it rests on a single pass. On Lift Bottle (Table 3) endpoint tactile frames give 27, identical to no demonstrated tactile at all (27); the selected frames give 36; all frames give 2. Table 8 shows the same shape with demonstration count: two demonstrations 36, four demonstrations 2. A little more image content helps and a lot collapses performance, which is equally consistent with the model being sensitive to the number and placement of images in context as with tactile content guiding contact adjustment. The control needed to tell these apart, the same number of extra images without tactile information (e.g. duplicated endpoint frames), is absent, and the selection rule and its thresholds (Appendix B.2) are validated on one task. The statistics are also thin: every condition is a single run of 100 trials with no repetition or confidence interval; per task, only Insert Tube (15 → 32) is a clear improvement, while Lift Bottle (27 → 36) and Pull Out Key (18 → 26) are within sampling noise at n = 100 (two-proportion z ≈ 1.4) and Lift Can is at floor. Appendix D further states that 44 of the 400 Tactile-ETA episodes in Table 1 (31 of 100 on Lift Can) were produced by a supplementary run with a different initialisation policy; whether the control conditions were supplemented is not reported.

  3. The real-robot experiment answers a different question. It compares no demonstration (0/5) with one visual–motion–tactile demonstration (3/5) on two tasks, judged by a human (Fig. 6, Appendix E). The condition the paper's claim depends on, a visual–motion demonstration without tactile frames, is missing, and in simulation that condition accounts for most of the gain (Lift Bottle 7 → 27, Pull Out Key 2 → 18). The real-world result therefore shows that one in-context demonstration helps, not that tactile experience helps, and with five trials per condition it does not support the abstract's "from 0% to 60%" as a general statement.

Questions for authors
  1. Why were Insert Hole, Insert HDMI, Grasp Classify and Put Bottle in Shelf excluded? Please report Tactile-ETA on the tactile-dependent tasks of UniVTAC.
  2. Please position the results against UniVTAC's Table I (vision-only ACT and ACT with the tactile encoder, 50 demonstrations, same native criteria) and explain what the frozen agent offers given that it is below the vision-only trained policy on all four tasks.
  3. Please add a control with the same number of extra images as "Selected" but without tactile information, on Insert Tube and Lift Bottle, and report the image/token count per configuration. Why does "All frames" fail?
  4. Please report repeated passes (or confidence intervals) for Tables 1 and 3, and state whether the control conditions in Table 1 received the same supplementary runs as Tactile-ETA (44/400, Lift Can 31/100).
  5. Please add the visual–motion-only demonstration condition on the real robot with more trials per condition.
  6. Unify "GPT-6" (main text) and "GPT-6 Astra" (Appendices D, E); state the task-specific strategy text in the prompts (e.g. the Pull Out Key goal "rotate until mechanical resistance is sensed, then pull") when claiming no task-specific engineering; the title would be more accurate as a feasibility claim.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.