- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper tackles one-to-many solution maps in symmetry-breaking bifurcations--buckling beams, buckling mechanical metamaterials, and Allen-Cahn phase separation-- where a single condition admits multiple equally valid solutions organized as symmetry orbits.Reported scale reaches 260,000 spatial degrees of freedom, with wall-clock times far below graph-based baselines.
Critical strengths
-
This is a under-explored and well-posed problem.
-
MCon-MAE with nearest-orbit matching, per-input JSD, coverage, and rejection rate, plus FFT-descriptor alignment and factorized JSDs for Allen–Cahn, are more appropriate than pointwise CRPS/rank histograms, and the paper explains why.
-
Full hyperparameter tables, dataset splits with leakage control, and detailed evaluation pipelines.
Critical weaknesses
-
The closest prior work is neither compared nor adequately differentiated. Hendriks et al. ("Equivariant flow matching for symmetry-breaking bifurcation problems") is the direct predecessor. But the paper never run or compared against.
-
Particle guidance explicitly optimizes the joint K-sample set for spread. Coverage and per-condition JSD are then computed on exactly that jointly optimized K-sample set. This means the metrics partly measure the objective the sampler was designed to optimize, not the fidelity of the marginal per-sample distribution. I suggest to report marginal metrics computed from independent samples alongside the joint-batch metrics.
3 No analysis of what the latent space preserves. A central, unchecked assumption is that the autoencoder preserves mode identity ("branch identity dominates trajectory variance").
Questions for authors
Please see the weaknesses above.
[W1] Model comparison
Thank you for bringing this up. This is a valid point, so we decided to adapt the EGNN-based model by Hendriks et al.[1] for the 2D beams to the 3D beams setting and compare it. The results are the following:
bold symbols best performing; italic second best performance
The EGNN performs better than Bi-FORK, both in JSD and MCon-MAE. This is mostly likely due to the fact that their model exploits the symmetry, with both equivariance that guarantees an even spread over possible solutions, and the optimal transport approach, which essentially reduces the problem to a 2D problem after all. Just as GeoTDM and STFlow, their model uses graph-based message-passing. By default they all rely on a fully-connected graph, but even when using a different non-fully-connected graph representation, message-passing based models do not scale easily to larger systems (the beams are 3-11 nodes, the metamaterials have up to 36000 nodes). This is also evident from their follow-up work [2] where they apply their framework to the metamaterials dataset. Due to the computational cost, they restrict the model to only use the boundary nodes, and the resulting model is limited in accuracy and speed.
Our intent with Bi-FORK was to go beyond the small test systems in [1] and efficiently scale to larger systems. The difficulty of scaling message-passing approaches is why with Bi-FORK we chose a different approach which effectively uses a latent space. Since we think that the comparison is an overall important addition, we have added the new results to the updated paper and included the motivation for our different approach compared to [1] in Section 3.1. Beam - Results section, page 7.
[W2] JSD metric
We agree that coverage and JSD computed within a jointly guided batch do not alone establish marginal distributional fidelity. We therefore evaluated three settings for the metamaterials, using K=16 per condition: (i) independent unguided sampling, (ii) one jointly guided batch, and (iii) one randomly selected trajectory from each of 16 independently generated guided batches.
Setting (iii) also improves branch-frequency JSD over (i), showing that the gain is not solely due to within-batch coordination. Setting (ii) provides an additional set-coverage benefit. These results are drawn using five sampling seeds.
[W3] Branch separability in latent space
Thank you for the question, we agree that reconstruction training alone does not guarantee preservation of branch identity. We therefore additionally evaluated the pretrained autoencoder independently of the generative model on all 445 two- and four-mode metamaterial test conditions. Encode–decode reconstruction retained the original branch in 99.9% of two-mode and 98.6% of four-mode cases. The mismatches only occur when branches are still nearly indistinguishable shortly after bifurcation. These results show that the autoencoder preserves branch identity using the metamaterials benchmark. Thank you for pointing that out, we have added a section to the appendix where we show the results and additional latent space analysis, in Figures 13 and 14, starting from page 27: E.2. Branch separability in latent space. We additionally referenced the section in the introduction: "We evaluate branch preservation through reconstruction in Section E.2."
[1] Hendriks et al., Equivariant flow matching for symmetry-breaking bifurcation problems. arXiv preprint arXiv:2509.03340 (2025b)
[2] Hendriks, F., Equivariant Generative Modeling of Buckling in Mechanical Metamaterials: https://pure.tue.nl/ws/portalfiles/portal/423163048/20261013_Hendriks_hf.pdf (2026)