- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a new few-step method for PDE solving, which enforces self-consistency across trajectory. Across three challenging scientific benchmarks, it achieves excellent predictive accuracy while reduces inference time.
Critical strengths
- The paper is well written and easy to follow.
- The experiments are thorough, including various evaluations, runtime comparisons, and ablation studies.
Critical weaknesses
- I have concerns about the novelty, as it appears to be primarily an application of consistency models to PDE solving.
- The paper also seems to overstate its contributions. To my knowledge, it is not the first work to propose a few-step or one-step generative approach to solving PDEs, and comparisons with these prior methods should be included.
Questions for authors
- Line 22 "scalable", what does “scalable” mean in this context?
- How does it perform compared to other few-step generative methods? For example,
[1] Physics-informed distillation of diffusion models for pde-constrained generation.
[2] Rectified flows for fast multiscale fluid flow modeling.
- I have some doubts about the need for few-step generative methods, since operator-based methods, such as neural operators, already provide fast, one-step predictions. How does your method compare with neural operators in inference time, and what advantages does it offer over them?
I would consider raising my score if my concerns are addressed.
3 comments
Thank you for your rebuttal, which addressed part of my concerns. I decided to raise my score to 3. I suggest the author removing claims such as "the first work to propose a few-step or one-step generative method".
Thank you for your feedback and for reconsidering your score. We will revise the manuscript accordingly.
Response to Reviewer Em6H
We thank the reviewer for the clear and constructive feedback, and address each point below.
We appreciate the concern, but RecFM uses a different mechanism from consistency models (General Response §1). Consistency models learn a map from xt to the trajectory endpoint and enforce the semigroup property. This requires evaluating the network at different points along the trajectory, usually against a teacher or EMA target. RecFM learns a velocity field, supervises it on time-rescaled copies of each trajectory, and ties them together with a chain-rule constraint at a single point, without a teacher, EMA target or JVP. The paper also compares against two consistency-style methods on the same backbone, Shortcut (Table 1) and MeanFlow (Appendix J, originally Appendix I during initial submission), and RecFM outperforms both in the one-step setting.
We thank the reviewer for the pointers, and agree that few-step generative PDE methods exist. Our claim refers to a narrower setting: one- and few-step autoregressive spatiotemporal rollouts without a teacher model or PDE residuals. [1] requires a teacher and PDE residuals, [2] learns a single input-to-output map with several ODE steps, and PBFM (Baldan et al., 2026) relies on PDE residuals. We have added these works to related work, and comparisons are given below and in General Response §3.
We meant two things. Each forecast window costs only 1 to 2 network evaluations, so rollout cost grows linearly with the horizon. And the method needs no architectural changes, so it carries over to large backbones (a 116M-parameter HV-DiT here, and a 675M-parameter model on ImageNet in Appendix K (originally Appendix J)). These are the two senses we intended.
[2] (Armegioiu et al.) trains a conditional rectified flow, a linear interpolant from noise to target conditioned on the input, and samples it in a few steps. This is the same objective as our Vanilla FM baseline. As we could not find a public implementation of [2], we also implemented the stronger two-stage reflow variant on our backbone for all three datasets (now in Table 1; see General Response §3). One-step RecFM achieves lower MSE on every dataset: 0.162 vs. 0.225 (SST), 0.0064 vs. 0.0072 (Navier-Stokes) and 4.2e-5 vs. 4.6e-5 (Helmholtz). Reflow also uses twice the training compute.
[1] (PIDDM) distills a pretrained diffusion teacher into a one-step student using an explicit PDE-residual loss, and generates full solution fields in one shot (e.g., Darcy, Poisson, Burgers) rather than autoregressive rollouts. Because it requires both a teacher and a closed-form residual, it cannot be applied to SST. The closest method we could evaluate is PBFM, which also trains with PDE residuals (Appendix G, originally Appendix F). RecFM is more accurate than PBFM on both PDE datasets while using 1 to 2 sampling steps instead of 20. We have added a discussion of PIDDM to related work.
Thank you for raising this. We added FNO, PINO and DeepONet; the table below is also a new appendix section (Appendix D) in the revised PDF.
Inference time is comparable, and RecFM is clearly more accurate on SST and Navier-Stokes. On Helmholtz, FNO and PINO are slightly more accurate than one-step RecFM, and two-step RecFM is the most accurate overall. Beyond accuracy, RecFM produces calibrated ensembles (CRPS, SSR) where neural operators give a single point estimate. It also needs no governing equation, which is why PINO has no SST entry.
We hope our responses have addressed the reviewer’s concerns. If there are any remaining questions, we would be happy to provide further clarification during the discussion period. We would sincerely appreciate reconsideration of the overall rating.