- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents a one-step generator framework, which combines the flow map method and equilibrium matching theorem. The authors defines the infinite-horizon interpolant of autonomous generative transport and developed a stabilized CFG for the autonomous field. Experiment results on CIFAR-10 and ImageNet shows that the proposed method can achieve decent FID with very few inference steps.
Critical strengths
The motivation for the proposed method is natural. Autonomous flows depend only on duration, therefore flow maps carry over directly once equilibrium matching's built-in clock compactifies the infinite horizon.
Critical weaknesses
The current experiments are not enough. The ImageNet experiment only have one training run. And the training budget for MeanFlow and Equilibrium Flow Map are not controlled to be the same, as the authors use a third party checkpoint for MeanFlow. Some important baselines like improved MeanFlow are missing.
Questions for authors
Theorem 3.3 and training only handles \sigma \in [0,1), but the inference uses \sigma=1. Any special treatment or discussion for this?
On ImageNet 256, why not choose Improved MeanFlow instead of MeanFlow as a baseline? Improved MeanFlow achieved 1.72 FID with one step.
2 comments
Thank the authors for explaining the treatment for and the additional experiments on CIFAR 10. I will raise my score by 1 point.
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and for recognizing the motivation for autonomous flow-map learning. We address the endpoint treatment, improved MeanFlow comparison, and provide new experiments compute-matched with the literature on CIFAR-10.
W1 Training and inference at σ = 1
Thank you for highlighting this point. Theorem 3.3 characterizes finite-duration maps for σ < 1, while the terminal map at σ = 1 is defined by the infinite-time limit established under our transport assumptions in Theorem 3.1. Φ_1 is therefore defined as the continuous extension of the map defined in Theorem 3.3.
In practice, we use a numerically stabilized objective that permits training at σ = 1, and include this terminal duration during training. Inference therefore evaluates an endpoint that is covered by training. The network predicts the terminal displacement directly, without converting σ = 1 into infinite autonomous time or numerically integrating to infinity. We will explicitly describe this endpoint treatment and distinguish the ideal theoretical objective from its stabilized implementation. Additional details have been added in Appendix C
Q1 Comparison with improved MeanFlow
We appreciate the suggestion to include improved MeanFlow 1 and have added its published results to Figure 2. We acknowledge its stronger one-step result of FID 1.72, compared with our 2.90.
Our implementation does not adopt the full set of architectural, objective, and training refinements used by improved MeanFlow, and our training budget is substantially smaller. Our EqFM training stage uses 400k updates, approximately 80 epochs, whereas the reported improved MeanFlow-XL model is trained for 800 epochs. EqFM also is instantiated from an autonomous-field checkpoint, which we report separately. Consequently, these results should be interpreted with the substantial differences in training recipe and budget made explicit. We emphasize however, our benefits over iMF in our monotonically improving results at larger inference compute budgets.
We selected MeanFlow 2 as the primary reference to keep the comparison focused on the autonomous flow-map construction. Improved MeanFlow remains an important broader baseline, and its results are now included on that basis.
Q2 Training budgets, inference budgets, and additional experiments
We agree that the ImageNet comparison is not fully matched in training compute. Figure 2 compares several methods at matched inference budgets, including EqFM and the evaluated MeanFlow checkpoint up to 128 NFE. This separates the question of sample quality at a given inference budget from the cost of training each model.
We also run improved MeanFlow 1 on CIFAR-10 under the same controlled training budget to establish a fair comparison with the results published in Boffi et al. We choose Boffi et al. 3 as a baseline to provide the most direct comparison, because EqFM extends their flow-map learning framework to autonomous, infinite-horizon dynamics.
Our new CIFAR-10 experiments demonstrate our improvements over baselines with the same architecture and training compute budget, and we include an improved MeanFlow baseline trained with a similar budget, although this uses a slightly different architecture. Our results show our inference time scaling abilities given larger inference budgets despite having weaker few NFE performance than Improved MeanFlow.
We distinguish the new controlled CIFAR-10 comparisons from the broader ImageNet comparisons and clearly report the training and inference budgets for each.
References
[1] Geng et al., “Improved Mean Flows: On the Challenges of Fastforward Generative Models”, 2025.
[2] Geng et al., “Mean Flows for One-step Generative Modeling”, 2025.
[3] Boffi et al., “How to build a consistency model: Learning flow maps via self-distillation”, 2025.