- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Influence-guided Molecular Query Synthesis (iMQS), which generates molecules for their expected value as training data under a limited labeling budget. Experiments cover 9 endpoints and 2 screening tasks. iMQS generally outperforms generation baselines, but its advantages over pool-based methods are less consistent.
Critical strengths
The method turns influence estimates into a tractable generation objective. Each acquisition cycle requires one linear solve involving the prediction-head Hessian. So candidate representations can be optimized without repeatedly retraining the predictor.
Critical weaknesses
- The main benchmarks in table 2 measure teacher agreement. Both training and test labels are from TxGemma. However, it cannot show that being closer to the teacher's answer leads to more accurate predictions of molecular properties. This limits the significance of the main results.
- The improvements over strong simple baselines, such as random-pool, are often small or statistically inconclusive.
Questions for authors
- Can the authors evaluate the models against the experimental labels of the test molecules to determine whether the improvements extend beyond agreement with TxGemma?
- The theoretical guarantee concerns head-only refitting with the predictor body fixed, whereas the implemented algorithm retrains the full MLP after each cycle. How would performance change if the implementation followed this head-only refitting procedure?