- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes an approach to efficiently search large regions of molecular spaces for molecules with desired properties. The pruning of the large spaces is done with the lab in the loop approach. Specifically, Bayesian analysis is employed to successively refine the posterior over these spaces when prior for the t+1 step is updated by wet lab experiments on the set of posterior samples at t.
Critical strengths
- The paper is very well written. The problem, the solution as well the limitations are all well described. Heartfelt thanks to the authors for writing something which is understandable and does not use convoluted vocabulary.
- The approach makes sense and the limitations are well thought of.
- The problem is very important, so an approach which may help in the efficiency aspect of it would have very large impact and can open new directions.
Critical weaknesses
The overall idea of trying to prune the search space for such a problem seems very intuitive. I wonder why prior work has not considered this. As a disclaimer I am not an expert in the problem domain so I might be wrong here. But with a bit of search I could find these works : https://pubs.rsc.org/dd/article/4/10/2910/889087/Adaptive-subspace-Bayesian-optimization-over and https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34985908/ which atleast at a very high level seems to build methodologies to prune the search space. the first one even uses Bayesian optimisation techniques.
I then wonder about novelty of the contribution. Does it come from lab in the loop proposal or a methodology which has yet not been applied to the current setting?
Questions for authors
What is the novelty of your approach? Does it come from lab in the loop proposal or a methodology which has yet not been applied to the current setting? Are there no prior works which apply efficient search for the current setting?
3 comments
References
Matthew Aldridge, Oliver Johnson, and Jonathan Scarlett. Group Testing: An Information Theory Perspective. Foundations and Trends® in Communications and Information Theory, 23(1-2): 1–221, May 2026. ISSN 1567-2190, 1567-2328. doi: 10.1108/FTCIT-11-2025-0150. URL http://arxiv.org/abs/1902.06002. arXiv:1902.06002 [cs.IT].
Nathan C. Frey, Isidro H¨otzel, Samuel D. Stanton, Ryan Kelly, Robert G. Alberstein, Emily K. Makowski, Karolis Martinkus, Daniel Berenberg, Jack Bevers, Tyler Bryson, Pamela Chan, Yongmei Chen, Alicja Czubaty, Tamica D’Souza, Henri Dwyer, Anna Dziewulska, James W. Fairman, Allen Goodman, Jennifer Hofmann, Henry Isaacson, Aya Ismail, Samantha James, Taylor Joren, Simon Kelow, James R. Kiefer, Matthieu Kirchmeyer, Joseph Kleinhenz, James T. Koerber, Julien Lafrance-Vanasse, Andrew Leaver-Fay, Jae Hyeon Lee, Edith Lee, Donald Lee, Wei Ching Liang, Joshua Yao-Yu Lin, Sidney Lisanza, Andreas Loukas, Jan Ludwiczak, Sai Pooja Mahajan, Omar Mahmood, Homa Mohammadi-Peyhani, Santrupti Nerli, Ji Won Park, Jaewoo Park, Stephen Ra, Sarah Robinson, Saeed Saremi, Franziska Seeger, Imee Sinha, Anna M. Sokol, Natasa Tagasovska, Hao To, Edward Wagstaff, Amy Wang, Andrew M. Watkins, Blair Wilson, Shuang Wu, Karina Zadorozhny, John Marioni, Aviv Regev, Yan Wu, Kyunghyun Cho, Richard Bonneau, and Vladimir Gligorijevi´c. Lab-in-the-loop therapeutic antibody design with deep learning, February 2025. URL http://biorxiv.org/lookup/doi/10.1101/2025.02.19.639050.
Bjarke Hastrup, Francois Cornet, Tejs Vegge, and Arghya Bhowmik. AtomComposer: Discovering Chemical Space from First Principles with Reinforcement Learning, May 2026. URL http://arxiv.org/abs/2605.28287. arXiv:2605.28287 [cs.LG].
Nuo Liu, Walaa E. Kattan, Benjamin E. Mead, Conner Kummerlowe, Thomas Cheng, Sarah Ingabire, Jaime H. Cheah, Christian K. Soule, Anita Vrcic, Jane K. McIninch, Sergio Triana, Manuel Guzman, Tyler T. Dao, Joshua M. Peters, Kristen E. Lowder, Lorin Crawford, Ava P. Amini, Paul C. Blainey, William C. Hahn, Brian Cleary, Bryan Bryson, Peter S. Winter, Srivatsan Raghavan, and Alex K. Shalek. Scalable, compressed phenotypic screening using pooled perturbations. Nature Biotechnology, 43(8):1324–1336, August 2025a. ISSN 1546-1696. doi: 10.1038/s41587-024-02403-z. URL https://www.nature.com/articles/s41587-024-02403-z.
Yuanbin Liu, Ata Madanchi, Andy S. Anker, Lena Simine, and Volker L. Deringer. The amorphous state as a frontier in computational materials design. Nature Reviews Materials, 10(3):228–241, March 2025b. ISSN 2058-8437. doi: 10.1038/s41578-024-00754-2. URL https://www.nature.com/articles/s41578-024-00754-2.
Vladislav A. Mints, Jack K. Pedersen, Alexander Bagger, Jonathan Quinson, Andy S. Anker, Kirsten M. Ø. Jensen, Jan Rossmeisl, and Matthias Arenz. Exploring the Composition Space of High-Entropy Alloy Nanoparticles for the Electrocatalytic H2 /CO Oxidation with Bayesian Optimization. ACS Catalysis, 12(18):11263–11271, September 2022. ISSN 2155-5435, 2155-5435. doi: 10.1021/acscatal.2c02563. URL https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acscatal.2c02563.
Jacob T. Rapp, Bennett J. Bremer, and Philip A. Romero. Self-driving laboratories to autonomously navigate the protein fitness landscape. Nature Chemical Engineering, 1(1):97–107, January 2024. ISSN 2948-1198. doi: 10.1038/s44286-023-00002-4. URL https://www.nature.com/articles/s44286-023-00002-4
Philip A. Romero and Frances H. Arnold. Exploring protein fitness landscapes by directed evolution. Nature Reviews Molecular Cell Biology, 10(12):866–876, December 2009. ISSN 1471-0080. doi: 10.1038/nrm2805. URL https://www.nature.com/articles/nrm2805.
Philip A. Romero, Andreas Krause, and Frances H. Arnold. Navigating the protein fitness landscape with Gaussian processes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 110(3), January 2013. ISSN 0027-8424, 1091-6490. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1215251110. URL https://pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.1215251110.
Thanks for the response
Dear Authors,
Thank you for your reponse. I have no further questions. I will update my score based on the reviewer discussion.
Thank you for your time and careful reading. We greatly appreciate your thorough and clear review, questions, and comments.
Questions:
What is the novelty of your approach? Does it come from lab in the loop proposal or a methodology which has yet not been applied to the current setting?
Thank you for the question. The core novelty stems from designing and synthesizing mixtures of molecules, rather than individual molecules. Achieving this new lab-in-the-loop strategy required new methodology. Previous methods for Bayesian optimization, for instance, do not consider designing and testing mixtures, since computationally it is not as fast to test a mixture as a single point.
Are there no prior works which apply efficient search for the current setting?
Thank you for the important question. We do not know of prior work which applies the EIG to optimize molecular mixtures. Prior work focuses almost entirely on individual synthesis (e.g. Romero & Arnold, 2009; Romero et al., 2013; Frey et al., 2025; Rapp et al., 2024; Liu et al., 2025b; Mints et al., 2022; Hastrup et al., 2026). Recent work has considered mixtures, but they do not optimize them, rather choosing the mixtures at random, and running just one experiment rather than an iterative optimization campaign (e.g. Liu et al., 2025a, Aldridge et al., 2026). We have updated our related work section (Sec 4) to clarify this point.
Concerns:
The overall idea of trying to prune the search space for such a problem seems very intuitive. I wonder why prior work has not considered this. As a disclaimer I am not an expert in the problem domain so I might be wrong here. But with a bit of search I could find these works : https://pubs.rsc.org/dd/article/4/10/2910/889087/Adaptive-subspace-Bayesian-optimization-over and https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34985908/ which atleast at a very high level seems to build methodologies to prune the search space. the first one even uses Bayesian optimisation techniques.
Thank you for the comment, and for the useful pointers. Both MolDAIS and the second article you cite are individual synthesis methods, like our baselines. MolDAIS is a GP based method, and it uses the EI acquisition function. It is very similar to the LOCK EI, and Hamming EI baseline, described on l. 364-366 of the main text. The second article focuses not on laboratory experiments but on simulations. In these simulations, it evaluates one molecular design at a time.
In short, while prior work has put considerable effort into pruning the search space, it has paid less attention to what can be accomplished physically in the lab versus in silico. Our approach starts from the observation that it is possible, and just as efficient, to make mixtures rather than individual molecules, and this leads us to new and effective methodology. We have updated the related work section to further clarify where our approach sits in the literature (Sec. 4).
References (in next comment)