- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes MolReAct, a framework for molecule-conditioned optimization. It reformulates molecular optimization as a search over compact reaction spaces proposed by a tool-augmented large language model. It proposes potential molecules based on chemical knowledge with cheminformatics tools, and also applies GRPO to optimize the generation process.
Critical strengths
-
Comprehensive Empirical Evaluation: The results span 14 objectives and outperform several relevant baselines. Furthermore, the paper includes comparisons against random, greedy, and MCTS selection, alongside model-scale ablations. This provides strong evidence isolating the contributions of the proposer and policy.
-
Tool-based Integration. Incorporating external chemical tools in LLMs is a good idea to improve the proposal of better potential molecules.
Critical weaknesses
-
Novelty. The paper mainly integrates a standard LLM proposer and evaluator to establish the initial framework and then uses GROP to perform optimization. But all the methods have appeared in the existing literature, and I do not see much novelty here.
-
Overstated Practical Synthesizability: The evidence supports template-grounded accessibility rather than true practical synthesizability. Compatible templates, purchasable reagents, and valid products are useful constraints. However, they do not guarantee reaction selectivity or experimental yields.
Questions for authors
-
What is the novelty here? Could you please list some methodological novelties compared with existing similar work?
-
This paper [1] also do molecule optimization; I am wondering about the performance comparison with it. [1] POLO: Preference-Guided Multi-Turn Reinforcement Learning for Lead Optimization, KDD 2026
-
What fraction of successful trajectories require an intermediate decrease in the task-oracle score, and how does performance scale with maximum reaction depth?