- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes an approach for generating small molecule antibiotics. The paper highlights the limitations of antibacterial design objective, limited applicability of property targets for the new antibiotic design, issues with local property optimisation competing with global structural requirements of the molecule. To overcome these, three contributions are made using agents for integrating biological evidence, molecular semantic fields for property directed design and integration of property guidance with structural and compositional constraints.
Critical strengths
- The problem itself is very important.
- the paper highlights the issues with current approaches quite well.
Critical weaknesses
- the paper is hard to follow from exactly when the paper starts to introduce its own approach
- It is not clear how the paper is resolving the three key challenges it discusses in lines 068-079
Questions for authors
-
Please explain how exactly your approach is overcoming the three challenges that you mentioned.
-
How do you argue the necessity of each module? Can one do ablation studies?
-
What exactly are molecular semantic fields? I understand a ten dimensional property vector is created but I guess that is the target for property prediction. what is the input ? Is that composed of the chemical words in context of the actual molecule? It is presently unclear from the description.
4 comments
Q3 – Clarification of the definition, representation, and construction of molecular semantic fields
We thank the reviewer for identifying this lack of clarity. Molecular semantic fields (MSFs) are not simply ten-dimensional molecular property vectors; rather, they represent how local chemical substructures and their combinations contribute to a molecule's overall chemical meaning.
The concept draws on two analogies: in a physical field, local disturbances collectively produce an overall response, while in language, words acquire meaning through their neighbouring words and combinations within a sentence. Similarly, chemical words represent local structural units, the complete molecule forms a "chemical sentence," and semantic windows capture local combinations of chemical words within their molecular context. We define an MSF as a representation of how these co-occurring semantic-window combinations jointly shape the integrated chemical meaning of a molecule.
The ten semantic axes provide measurable coordinates for this whole-molecule meaning, covering physicochemical properties related to lipophilicity, polarity, hydrogen bonding, flexibility, and ionization. Importantly, this ten-dimensional vector is the target representing the global semantic state or change, not the sole model input.
The model input comprises the source SMILES, its ordered chemical-word sequence, its initial semantic state, and the set of paired semantic windows describing local structural changes. Each window retains its source–target chemical words and contextual positions. The complete window set is associated with a single ten-dimensional target representing the resulting global semantic change. This enables the model to learn how combinations of local structural changes, within the context of the complete molecule, influence overall molecular properties.
During generation, the Semantic Field Agent uses these learned relationships, alongside the objectives, reference molecules, and previous feedback, to select target-window combinations, which HDiff realizes through complete-molecule generation. We have clarified these definitions and the input–target distinction in Section 3.1.1 and Appendix D.
Dear Reviewer M5gf, Thank you for your thoughtful feedback. With the ICLR author–reviewer discussion closing today (November 18, AoE), we wanted to let you know that we have posted our response. We have addressed each of your comments and included the results of all the analyses you requested.
We appreciate your time, especially on short notice, and would be grateful if you could consider the new results as you finalize your assessment. If any questions remain, we would be happy to respond before the discussion closes.
Best, The Authors
Thank you very much for your response. I believe that with large amounts of changes and the poor readability of the paper in the original submission the paper would need a full review. therefore, I keep my score.
Dear Reviewer M5gf,
Thank you for your thoughtful and constructive feedback. To address your concerns and questions, we have conducted additional experiments evaluating the contributions of individual mechanisms within the HDiff module through targeted ablation studies, including comparisons with a validity/C/F rejection-filter control. We have also investigated the effectiveness of semantic-window selection by comparing learned selection against random selection of executable semantic windows on held-out task. In addition to these experiments, we have revised the Introduction to more explicitly articulate how our approach addresses the three key challenges identified in the manuscript and clarified the proposed methodology and molecular semantic fields. We hope that these additional experiments and clarifications adequately address your concerns and improve the clarity of the manuscript.
W1 – Lack of clarity in the presentation of the proposed methodology
We have revised the Proposed Approach section to improve its clarity and organization, making it easier for readers to follow the transition from the background and motivation to the introduction of our proposed method. We have also clarified the descriptions of the key components and their respective roles to provide a more coherent explanation of our approach.
W2/Q1 – Unclear mapping between the three identified challenges and the proposed solutions
We have clarified how the proposed framework addresses the three challenges outlined in the Introduction below: The first main challenge is translating biological antibacterial objectives into actionable molecular design strategies, as biological objectives do not directly specify the molecular structures required to achieve them. To address this, we developed a closed-loop multi-agent framework that integrates biological evidence and computational feedback to guide molecular generation, coordinating global design objectives with the exploration and refinement of local structural features.
The second main challenge is understanding how combinations of local chemical features influence whole-molecule properties, as desired property targets do not specify which combinations of chemical features will produce the intended improvements. To address this, we introduced molecular semantic fields, learned from 228,539 molecular-pair records spanning ten physicochemical properties, to capture relationships between combinations of local structural features and changes in whole-molecule properties. These learned relationships enable the identification of structural modifications likely to achieve desired molecular property profiles.
The third main challenge is balancing local property optimization with broader structural and compositional requirements to ensure that generated molecules satisfy multiple design objectives simultaneously. To address this, we developed a hierarchical diffusion framework with feasibility control that integrates semantic-field-based property guidance with structural and compositional constraints during molecular generation, balancing desired property improvements with the generation of chemically feasible molecules. We have incorporated these clarifications into the revised Introduction to ensure it is clear how our novel model addresses these three challenges.
Q2 – Justification for individual modules and the need for component-wise ablation studies
To systematically evaluate the necessity and individual contributions of the proposed modules, we conducted comprehensive ablation studies at four levels: (i) Overall framework ablation, comparing MSF-HDiff against GPT-based and standard diffusion-based alternatives; (ii) Multi-agent planning ablation, independently removing the Librarian, Discovery, and Semantic Field agents; (iii) Hierarchical conditioning ablation, independently removing individual global and structural conditions, as well as their complete condition sets; and (iv) Hierarchical diffusion and feasibility-control ablation, comparing ON-only and OFF-only configurations, independently removing the Reference Value Network (RVN) and minimum-KL adjustment, and evaluating alternative constraint-enforcement strategies, including Hard Rejection Mode and post-generation filtering.
The ablation studies demonstrate that each component contributes complementary benefits to molecular generation. Removing planning agents or hierarchical conditions reduced predicted activity and molecular quality, with the Discovery Agent having the greatest impact on activity. Additionally, RVN and minimum-KL independently improved molecular quality, while MSF-HDiff outperformed Hard Rejection Mode and post-generation filtering in ranking score, independent composite score, and diversity. Overall, these results highlight the contributions of the proposed planning, conditioning, and reference-based feasibility mechanisms. We have detailed this all in Appendix K.