- The stopping rule uses reference barrier errors (Section 4.2), while the proposed workflow is described as starting from endpoints. Those reference errors would not be available for a new reaction with an unknown transition state. Section 5.1 also refers to a best-round checkpoint without clearly stating how it is selected. This makes the reported label efficiency difficult to interpret. The smaller fixed-budget comparison helps, but does not resolve the issue for the main campaign.
- The advantage over NEB is not firmly established by the main comparison. Section 5.2 reports a lower error for the scan on every tested reaction, but most differences are small and comparable to the replicate spread reported for the one reaction with repeated runs. The clearest separation comes from a single case. The main campaign also uses only one seed per reaction. The results suggest that the scan can be useful, but support a narrower claim than a general improvement in robustness and data efficiency. Comparing the existing learning curves at smaller label budgets and reporting path-generation times would help assess the efficiency claim.
UMA was pretrained on configurations derived from MOBH35, as the paper acknowledges. The results therefore demonstrate adaptation on systems represented in pretraining; they do not establish the same benefit for unfamiliar systems. This does not make the improvements unimportant, but the scope should be clear.
The reactive-bond detection rule also needs a precise description. Section 3 says pairs are close enough to form a covalent bond and change separation between endpoints, but does not give the distance criteria. This matters for ambiguous metal–ligand bonds, especially since the paper itself suggests that a missed reactive coordinate may explain a failure.
The Hessian and connectivity checks operate on the learned potential. Please distinguish those checks from DFT confirmation of a saddle, and explain the omitted MOBH35 reactions. The related-work discussion should also include earlier active surrogate-assisted searches, such as GP-NEB and AL-NEB. The NEB comparison does not isolate what the curved schedule adds over an otherwise matched linear scan.
I lean toward rejection because reference-independent label efficiency remains unclear and the evidence for a general advantage over NEB is limited.