- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces PeriTS, a flow-matching framework for generating transition states (TSs) in periodic systems. The authors analyze difficulties specific to periodic structures, such as the minimum image convention, and address them with a periodic reaction prior, periodic reaction conditioning, and a training objective focused on mobile atoms only. The method is benchmarked on one newly curated and two publicly available datasets and compared against state-of-the-art models developed for TS generation of small organic molecules. The paper further compares multi-step and single-step inference, as well as the generation of multiple TS candidates per reaction. Evaluation is based on RMSD over all atoms and over mobile atoms only, complemented by a DFT-based energetic evaluation on a subset of 13 structures. While these insights are valuable, the paper in its current form has substantial issues in rigor and completeness, including missing citations, missing promised results, and inconsistencies in the text.
Critical strengths
- The paper adapts established techniques for periodic systems, such as the minimum image convention, to the task of TS generation.
- The method is compared against state-of-the-art baselines across multiple datasets.
- The paper contributes a newly curated dataset for periodic TS generation.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited novelty. Core components such as the minimum image convention and periodic neighbor lists are well-established techniques, but they are presented as novel contributions. The paper should more clearly distinguish what is new from what is standard practice.
-
Low task difficulty and limited improvement. The midpoint RMSD on the benchmark datasets is already very low, so the mapping from the prior to the TS is comparatively easy, and the model improves only modestly over this starting point. On LiTraj in particular, the midpoint RMSD is so low that the models appear to learn mostly noise, which may also explain why the one-shot variant outperforms the multi-step baseline.
-
Insufficient energetic evaluation. A DFT evaluation on 13 structures does not support statistically meaningful conclusions and should be expanded substantially.
-
Missing methodological details. It is never explained how is obtained during training. The hyperparameters introduced in Appendix C3 are neither explained nor connected to the loss function, and no pseudo-algorithm is provided. Dataset sizes for the external benchmarks are also not reported. Together, these omissions limit reproducibility.
-
Missing promised results. The comparison to SaddleFlow announced in Appendix D1 is missing.
-
Presentation and referencing. The manuscript contains clear signs of unfinished or unreviewed text. Appendix E5 includes unfilled template placeholders in place of the actual computational settings (e.g., “[DFT code and version] with [exchange–correlation functional], [pseudopotential], an energy cutoff of [XX] eV”), so the DFT setup underlying the energetic evaluation is never specified. Several passages are also duplicated verbatim (e.g., Appendix C2 and C3; Tables 2 and 8). Such artifacts suggest the text was generated or assembled from templates without careful review. Moreover, the paper cites only 16 works, which suggests an incomplete treatment of related work. For example, AEFM is introduced in Appendix D2 without a citation.
-
Multi-candidate ablation. No information is given on how the additional heads are trained. If they are trained like the original head on a frozen shared backbone, they would be expected to collapse to nearly identical predictions rather than provide a meaningful set of TS candidates.
Questions for authors
- How is obtained during training, and how do the hyperparameters in Appendix C3 enter the loss function?
- Why does TS-DFM produce predictions that are worse than the starting midpoint? An analysis of this behavior would be informative.
- Which starting point does React-OT use? If it uses the standard Cartesian midpoint, could you report results with the periodic midpoint for a fair comparison?
- How were the additional heads in the multi-candidate ablation trained? Could you report the pairwise RMSD between candidates to verify whether they collapse? Have you considered independent deep ensembles or inference from slightly noised midpoints as alternatives for generating diverse candidates?