- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
- Unified Prediction and Generation: Jointly training models for molecular descriptor prediction and structural reconstruction enables a single latent representation to serve both property prediction and molecular generation tasks.
- Flow-Projected Latent Space Search: Leveraging Rectified Flow to learn the distribution of molecular representations, while employing projection techniques to enhance the decodability of candidate latent vectors during the optimization process.
- Incorporating Synthesizability into Optimization: By applying penalties based on synthesizability predictions or utilizing projections onto synthesizable analogs with explicit synthetic routes, the framework generates candidate molecules that balance novelty, predicted activity, and synthetic feasibility.
Critical strengths
- Unified design for prediction and generation: By jointly training descriptor prediction and molecular reconstruction, a single latent representation is enabled to simultaneously support property prediction, molecular generation, and optimization, with only a marginal decline in property prediction performance.
- Effective mechanism to address latent space mismatch: Rectified Flow is employed to handle both prior sampling and search projection, mitigating the issue where high-dimensional latent vectors deviate from the decodable region.
Critical weaknesses
- Lack of ablation studies on gradient guidance: The search process is influenced by gradient guidance, stochastic noise from Langevin updates, and the noise-addition/denoising operations within the flow projection. However, the paper does not verify the independent contribution of gradient guidance to the generated results through controlled comparisons.
Questions for authors
It is recommended to include an ablation study comparing the use and non-use of gradient guidance, while keeping other settings and the search budget constant, to verify the independent contribution of gradient guidance to the generated results.
We thank the Reviewer for the positive comments about our work and we agree that an ablation study on the gradient guidance could further strengthen our claim.
The ablation study was conducted across the 30 MoleculeACE assays at fixed budget (30 generations with population of 300 molecules). The Table 10 in Appendix F sums up the results. The search with guidance on achieves better performances in the following metrics: best predicted potency throughout the 30 assays; margin over the potency value corresponding to the 90th quantile of the training set for each assay; the percentage of the generated molecules that satisfy the potency constraint (higher than q90); the overall success rate (molecules satisfying all criteria for valid demonstrations); distinct scaffolds. While the percentage of molecules clearing the q90 threshold is similar, it can be inferred that guidance helps the search going towards higher potent molecules, as evidenced from the best.\
The analysis carried out for Reviewer y1YN helped also in clarifying the role of guidance. In the “Reliability of the predictor” paragraph of Section 3.5, guidance is shown to be a key asset in driving the search towards molecules similar to unseen test-set molecules known experimentally to have higher activity.