- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This work proposes CovaTide, a receptor-conditioned all-atom flow model that jointly generates peptide sequences and structures under a prescribed covalent topology. CovaTide uses a deep topology adapter to repeatedly integrate residue-level connectivity and atom-level bond information, coupling global peptide conformations with local closure geometry throughout generation. The main idea is to directly incorporate the prescribed covalent topology as a generation condition, rather than first generating linear peptides and then obtaining cyclic peptides through filtering, endpoint mutation, or post-processing.
Critical strengths
- A single model can generate linear peptides as well as head-to-tail, disulfide, and isopeptide cyclic peptides. This unified treatment of different peptide topologies is practically meaningful.
- The experimental design is relatively reasonable, and the proposed method is evaluated from multiple aspects.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper repeatedly emphasizes joint sequence–structure generation, but in practice, only the coordinates follow the flow trajectory, while the sequence is predicted by a readout after generation.
- For each target, 100 peptides are generated, and the best candidate is selected separately for AAR, C-RMSD, L-RMSD, energy, and other metrics, which may exaggerate the apparent performance advantage.
- The main result tables do not seem to demonstrate that the proposed method is broadly competitive across the evaluated metrics.
Questions for authors
The authors should clarify the main advantage of the proposed method. Although performance is not the only consideration for a method with clear methodological novelty, it is still important. CovaTide underperforms existing methods on several metrics, and even the ablation results do not consistently support the superiority of the full model. Could the authors provide a clear explanation? If only the coordinates follow the flow trajectory, the sequence is predicted at the end, and the sequence loss cannot affect the coordinate trunk due to stop-gradient, in what sense are sequence and structure “jointly generated” or “co-designed”? Why does the linear peptide evaluation use an independent best-of-100 selection for each metric?
Thank you for the clarifications and additional experiments. After considering the responses, I am maintaining my rating of 2.