- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents CycPepFlow, an all-atom Cartesian flow-matching framework for cyclic peptide conformer ensemble generation. The method combines SO(3)-equivariant local message passing, gated global attention, Attention Residuals, and stereochemical supervision. An optional all-pair graph-geodesic attention bias is also introduced to incorporate molecular topology. Experiments on the CREMP benchmark demonstrate improvements in ensemble generation quality and stereochemical accuracy compared with several existing conformer generation approaches.
Critical strengths
-
Important research problem. Cyclic peptide conformer generation is an important and challenging problem with potential applications in molecular modeling and drug discovery.
-
Clear motivation, and the paper is easy to follow in general. The paper clearly explains the challenges associated with cyclic peptide generation, particularly the coupling between local geometry and global ring conformation, the diversity of noncanonical amino acids, and the importance of preserving stereochemistry.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty. My main concern is the lack of a clearly identifiable technical contribution. Most components of CycPepFlow, including Cartesian flow matching, graph-harmonic priors, SO(3)-equivariant message passing, gated attention, Attention Residuals, graph-geodesic attention biases, and chirality supervision, are adapted from existing methods. The paper primarily combines these techniques without introducing a fundamentally new modeling mechanism or providing substantial new insights into cyclic peptide generation. While combining existing approaches can be valuable, I would expect stronger methodological insights or more compelling empirical evidence to justify the contribution at a top-tier machine learning conference.
-
Insufficient experimental results. The proposed method achieves improvements over existing baselines, but the overall gains in ensemble coverage are relatively modest. It remains unclear whether the method generalizes to larger macrocycles or more diverse chemical structures. Furthermore, the paper lacks sufficient analysis of computational efficiency and physical validity.
-
Ablation studies do not fully justify the component choices. The authors provide several component-removal ablations, which are appreciated. However, these experiments do not sufficiently explain why the selected techniques are preferable to reasonable alternatives. For example, the paper does not isolate the benefit of gated attention over standard attention, and removing Attention Residuals does not reduce the overall coverage F1 score.
-
The presentation could be more focused. The manuscript devotes too much space to background, related work, and figures, particularly the extensive discussion of existing protein-derived and molecular conformer generation methods.
Questions for authors
See weakness
Author Response to Reviewer 21ui
Weakness 1.
Response: We thank the reviewer for this comment. Similar to recent advances in molecular modeling such as DiTMC and RFpeptides, CycPepFlow builds on established generative foundations while introducing targeted architectural innovations to jointly resolve local geometry, global ring closure, and stereochemical fidelity. Specifically, we introduce two key designs tailored to macrocycles: (i) atomic chirality conditioning with signed-volume supervision, which achieves 99.71% conformer-level tetrahedral accuracy on 6-mer macrocycles without post-hoc corrections; and (ii) an all-pair graph-geodesic attention bias that embeds cyclic topology directly into global attention to capture long-range ring constraints. Crucially, our experiments demonstrate that CycPepFlow outperforms the strongest baselines on the evaluated 7-mer and NCAA-containing 6-mer panels, underscoring the practical value of this unified design for cyclic peptide drug discovery.
Weakness 2.
Response: We thank the reviewer for these constructive suggestions. Improvements on established in-distribution benchmarks are often modest given strong baselines (e.g., on GEOM-DRUGS, ETFlow improves by ~2% over MCF and DiTMC by ~1% over ETFlow). However, our method demonstrates substantial gains in out-of-distribution generalization. In our new experiments (Figure 5), CycPepFlow APG-L achieves a COV-F1 of 56.13% on larger 7-mer macrocycles (vs. 40.09% for DiTMC rPE-L), and CycPepFlow-L achieves 34.38% on chemically diverse NCAA-containing 6-mers (vs. 18.93% for LoQI), outperforming the strongest external baseline on each subset. Furthermore, our newly added discussion in Section 5.2 demonstrates both strong physical validity and competitive computational efficiency.
Weakness 3.
Response: We thank the reviewer for this insightful comment. To isolate the effect of gated attention over standard attention, we added an ablation in Figure 10 confirming that gated attention outperforms standard attention. Regarding Attention Residuals, while removing them leaves overall coverage F1 unchanged, it reduces COV-F1 on the more challenging 6-mer subset by 1.46 percentage points—suggesting that Attention Residuals benefit performance on this subset and may improve generalization to larger macrocycles. We also highlighted this trend in the caption of Figure 10 to make it clearer to readers.
Weakness 4.
Response: We thank the reviewer for this helpful suggestion. In the revised manuscript, we condensed Section 2 to four short paragraphs (p. 2) and moved the detailed discussion of protein-derived and small-molecule conformer generators to Appendix G (pp. 39–40). The recovered space was used for the new generalization experiments on 7-mers and NCAA-containing 6-mers and for the physical-validity and efficiency analyses, so the main text is now weighted toward results rather than background.