- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper is concerned with characterizing different types of error rates in the context of de novo sequencing from proteomics tandem mass spectrometry data. However, I could not figure out exactly what problem the paper aims to address.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
This paper is quite difficult to follow. I have worked with proteomics MS/MS data for a long time, have thought a lot about database search and de novo sequencing, and have worked on methods for error estimation in this domain. Yet I still had trouble following the reasoning through the Introduction of your paper. I feel quite sure that a typical ICLR reader would not be able to follow it at all. The remainder of the paper is, if anything, more dense and difficult to follow. Paragraphs do seem to be organized around a leading topic sentence, but transitions between paragraphs are often unclear, and many concepts are never introduced. E.g., "For mixed spectra, the identity claim must specify the designated precursor or any co-isolated component." Or the sudden appearance of "the E. coli source" (line 112), which has not been introduced or described.
Questions for authors
I cannot boil this down to a few questions that would materially affect my assessment. I found so many parts of the exposition difficult to understand that enumerating them would not be a useful endeavor.