- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces dIon, a self-supervised framework for representation learning from tandem mass spectra. dIon employs two complementary latent prediction tasks, both aiming to recover a clean teacher representation: a precursor-conditioned mixture task that encourages the model to associate precursor information with relevant fragment-ion evidence, and a precursor-withheld partial-view task that prevents the model from relying solely on precursor information. Experiments demonstrate that dIon improves peptide sequencing performance over training from scratch and achieves better results against existing supervised methods.
Critical strengths
Domain-specific self-supervised learning objectives. The paper introduces two complementary latent prediction tasks tailored to the physical properties of tandem mass spectra, providing a well-motivated approach to learning representations without peptide sequence labels.
Critical weaknesses
-
Comparison with InstaNovo-FM under different pretraining data. dIon and InstaNovo-FM are pretrained on different datasets, making it difficult to determine whether dIon's superior performance stems from the proposed objectives or differences in pretraining data.
-
Limited comparisons with recent sequencing methods. The paper only compares against Casanovo and InstaNovo, omitting other recent methods such as π-HelixNovo, LIPNovo and ReNovo.
Questions for authors
-
Comparison with InstaNovo-FM's self-supervised objective. Could the authors replace dIon's proposed objective with InstaNovo-FM's masked spectrum reconstruction objective under the same training settings? This would help establish the advantages of the proposed objectives.
-
Comparison with recent sequencing methods. Could the authors provide comparisons with more recent methods mentioned in Weakness 2.
3 comments
2. Comparison with recent sequencing methods. Could the authors provide comparisons with more recent methods mentioned in Weakness 2.
Thank you for suggesting these additional comparisons. Our main contribution is a self-supervised pretraining method and the demonstration that it improves de novo sequencing over matched training from scratch. To our knowledge, this benefit from self-supervised spectrum pretraining had not previously been clearly demonstrated. Our central comparison therefore holds the architecture, supervised data and training protocol fixed, and varies the encoder initialization. The external supervised models provide context for the resulting performance; an exhaustive comparison of supervised sequencing methods is beyond the scope of this study.
We selected InstaNovo based on its strong performance in a public de novo sequencing benchmark covering 83 datasets. The cross-dataset ranking plot places InstaNovo 1.2.2 first by median rank for peptide precision-coverage AUC, ahead of π-HelixNovo, one of the methods named in the review. We used InstaNovo 1.2.2, the latest available release for our experiments.
We included Casanovo as a well-established method that pioneered transformer-based de novo peptide sequencing. We evaluated its latest available release, 5.2.1, incorporating updates since the original publications.
We did not have time to complete additional comparisons with π-HelixNovo, LIPNovo or ReNovo during the review period.
We hope our explanations of the InstaNovo-FM comparison and the choice of supervised baselines address the questions you raised. Our responses to the other reviewers also include new mechanistic controls, an unseen-peptide analysis and repeated-seed results. If these additions and clarifications increase your confidence in the paper sufficiently, we would appreciate your considering an increase in your rating from 2 to 3.
Thank for the authors' detailed responses. I appreciate the clarifications regarding the baseline selection and the scope of the paper. Given the overall contribution and experimental evidence, I have decided to increase my rating from 2 to 3.
Thank you for the review and for recognizing the motivation of the self-supervised objectives. Your feedback has helped us present the contribution and the scope of the comparisons more clearly.
1. Comparison with InstaNovo-FM's self-supervised objective. Could the authors replace dIon's proposed objective with InstaNovo-FM's masked spectrum reconstruction objective under the same training settings? This would help establish the advantages of the proposed objectives.
Thank you for highlighting this distinction. We agree that our comparison with InstaNovo-FM cannot isolate the contribution of the pretraining objective, because both the architecture and pretraining data differ. Our comparison with its released encoder is intended as an external reference for native representation quality, not as a controlled demonstration that our objective is superior to masked reconstruction.
We would also like to highlight that InstaNovo-FM appeared as a concurrent preprint on September 7, 2026, only 11 days before the ICLR abstract deadline. Given this very short window, incorporating its released model into our representation benchmarks was already a substantial additional effort before submission.
A matched comparison would require substantial pretraining and hyperparameter tuning to find suitable settings for InstaNovo-FM's objective within our architecture. Those runs were not feasible within the time and compute available during the review period.
Our appendix already reports an iBOT-style masking experiment, where the student predicts the clean teacher's latent targets at masked peak positions. We added this loss with weight 0.5 to the dual objective. At the last shared evaluation step, 96,000, strict pair AUROC is 0.6323 versus 0.6758 for dual alone, while broad mAP is higher, 0.4556 versus 0.4077. This experiment uses learned teacher targets rather than reconstructing the spectrum inputs, and adds to dual rather than replacing it.
We will also clarify in the Discussion that InstaNovo-FM's reported lack of a measurable de novo gain was obtained under its own dataset and experimental protocol, which differ from ours. It does not establish that masked reconstruction is generally a poorer pretraining objective.