- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes a data augmentation method called Non-Tryptic Terminus Simulation (NTS), which generates simulated MS/MS spectra with non-tryptic C termini from existing tryptic PSMs. The data augmentation represents an alternative for generating a diverse set of non-tryptic C-termini PSMs without requiring the need for generative models or lab experiments. Experiments conducted on three models and 11 test datasets show that data augmented with NTS substantially improves amino-acid precision, amino-acid recall, and peptide recall across both trypsin and non-trypsin digested-peptide chains. Additionally, the data augmentation broadens the frequency distribution of amino acids beyond lysine (K) and arginine (R).
Critical strengths
-
S1. The paper introduces NTS, which generates simulated MS/MS spectra corresponding to peptides with non-tryptic C termini from existing tryptic PSMs. The paper takes b, a, and y fragment ions into consideration and either retains peaks if they remain unaffected by residue removal or shifts/deletes peaks if they are affected by the removal process. The relative peak-intensities are retained in the process.
-
S2. Experiments on three models and 11 test datasets show that data augmented with NTS improves metrics for both trypsin-digested and non-tryptic peptides. Additionally, NTS augmentation increases the C-terminal amino-acid distribution beyond lysine and arginine.
Critical weaknesses
-
W1. My main concern is that the augmented data is never cross-referenced with actual data from a non-tryptic counterpart of an original tryptic PSM. Given the relative complexities involved in data generation, whether the new peaks actually match a genuinely removed version could provide evidence for the effectiveness of the method.
-
W2. In Section 3.3 the b_(n-1) ion was removed from the simulated spectrum without an explanation. Suppose the original sequence contained ‘NHGMHFR’, the b_(n-1) fragment sequence is ‘NHGMHF’ which does not contain the arginine.
Questions for authors
-
Q1. Could the authors clarify why the b_(n-1) ion was removed from the simulated spectrum, given that this fragment does not contain the C-terminal residue being removed?
-
Q2. Could the authors provide evidence that the NTS- augmented data match experimentally observed spectra of the corresponding non-tryptic peptides?
2 comments
I thank the authors for their effort. The rebuttal addressed my concern. I maintain my original positive score.
Response to Reviewer 84Uq
Thank you for your comments and raising the constructive questions.
Reply to Q1:
Although the original bn−1 ion does not contain the removed C-terminal residue, it no longer represents a valid b-type fragment after truncation. For example, in the original peptide NHGMHFR, the b6 ion (NHGMHF) is generated by cleavage of the peptide bond between F and R. After removing R, NHGMHF becomes the complete truncated peptide, and there is no longer a peptide bond after F that can be cleaved to generate this b ion. Therefore, NTS retains b1 through bn−2, while removing bn−1.
Reply to Q2:
To evaluate how well the augmented spectra approximate real non-tryptic spectra, we directly compared the NTS-augmented spectra with experimental non-tryptic peptide spectra from MSV000094014. In total, 382 peptide sequences were shared between the two datasets, of which 226 had matching modifications and precursor charge states, yielding 16,848 experimental–simulated spectrum pairs. Using one-to-one assignments, we computed the square-root-intensity cosine similarity across all theoretical b/y-ion channels, with unobserved ions assigned zero intensity. With equal weighting across peptides, the b/y-ion similarity was 0.710±0.171. As a control, we randomly reassigned the intensities of the ions in the NTS-augmented spectra among the theoretical b/y-ion channels, which reduced the similarity to 0.211±0.053.
We further compared full-spectrum similarity, including non-b/y peaks, between simulated spectra and their corresponding experimental spectra versus randomly paired spectra. Specifically, each simulated spectrum was paired with 20 randomly selected experimental peptides of the same precursor charge (precursor m/z within ±5 Da) that did not overlap with the corresponding peptide. Using the same simulated spectra, the full-spectrum similarity was 0.382±0.129 for corresponding peptides versus 0.063±0.039 for randomly paired peptides. Mirror plots of representative examples, annotated with detected b/y ions and similarity scores, are shown in Figure 4.
Together, these results indicate that NTS-augmented spectra reasonably approximate real non-tryptic spectra (4.5 Comparing NTS-augmented spectra with experimental non-tryptic spectra).