- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper propose PPDIFF, a generation framework for controllable peptide geenration. The framework adopts a lightweight random forest to predict in silico mutagenesis to estimate residue importance and uncertainty. The leveraging the uniqueness of discrete diffusion model, the framework remasks the generated sequences for improving certain characteristics with guidance. This framwork is flexible on backbones and guidance. Experimental result demonstrate the effectiveness of PPDIFF.
Critical strengths
-
The idea of priority-gating sampling using a shared prior is an interesting idea and mathmatically sound. The result also demonstrate effectiveness of such method.
-
The experiments are comprehensive and complete. The paper not only demonstratre the effectiveness of the model but also illustrate the random forest performance.
Critical weaknesses
-
The motivation of controllable peptide generation is unclear to me. From my perspective, it is still considered as a broader view of conditioned generation or guided generation. So how to distinguish this work and existing work such as [1] and [2]? Except the technical difference, what is the advantage of the proposed solution?
-
The presentation of this paper needs a significant polish, especially the method section. I noted several symbols are not defined well. For instance, delta in Eq. 1. And typos such as Eq. 5 x_{\i}. Furthermore, the flow and illustration of this section is not clear to me. I found it is very hard to understand the logic and mechanism of each components.
-
This is not technically a weakness. Since ISM is adopted in inference stage, it is interesting to see the extra computational overhead of the RF model.
-
From table 28, It looks like PPDIFF lowers the validity, uniqueness and diversity comparing with baselines. I think this might because the bias introduced by the RF model. The author should acknowledge or conduct further analysis.
[1] Tang, Sophia, Yinuo Zhang, and Pranam Chatterjee. "Peptune: De novo generation of therapeutic peptides with multi-objective-guided discrete diffusion." ArXiv (2025): arXiv-2412.
[2]Chen, Leo Tianlai, Zachary Quinn, Madeleine Dumas, Christina Peng, Lauren Hong, Moises Lopez-Gonzalez, Alexander Mestre et al. "Target sequence-conditioned design of peptide binders using masked language modeling." Nature Biotechnology 44, no. 6 (2026): 1002-1010.
Questions for authors
-
What is the motivation of controllable peptide geenration? And the difference between existing guided generation model?
-
How much computational overhead introduced by the RF model? Especially in the inference stage.
-
Does the RF model introduce bias that eventually lowering the validity, uniqueness and diversity?
I put a weak rejection as a placeholder as of right now. But I am willing to increase my rating if the author address my concerns.