- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PepDiT, a diffusion model for antimicrobial peptide generation. PepDiT features a Target-Spot-Driven Hotspot Conditioning mechanism to enable the target-aware generation process. The paper also proposes a DPO-based post-training optimization to further improve the model performance. Critically, to train the PepDiT model, the paper curated PepDB-1.2M, a large scale peptide dataset containing MD conformational data, cyclic macrocycles, and AlphaFoldMultimer target complexes.
Critical strengths
- The PepDB-1.2M is a large scale peptide dataset. This dataset merge several existing dataset with additional labels. This dataset could benefit the research community and further attract future researchers.
Critical weaknesses
-
I did not found a significant technical novelty in this paper. The paper claim PepDiT is a "a multi-track Diffusion Transformer that co-models discrete 3D structural tokens and continuous sequence latents with target-spot cross-attention." (lines 122, 123). However, such multi-modal generation is widely studied in existing works [1,2,3]. Similar argument is applied on Pep-DPO. It is basically an application of well-established DPO algorithm.
-
The paper claims the PepBench as a major contribution which includes 12 comprehensive tasks. However, 1) it is very unclear to me what are the 12 comprehensive tasks? Many tasks in section 4.1 are just evaluation metrics, such as RMSD, MIC, and MAE. These are not tasks. 2) It is not clear how the paper obtain certain values, for instance MIC and HC50 and Human Serum Stability half-life. Usually those values need to have wet-lab verification.
[1] Didi, Kieran, Zuobai Zhang, Guoqing Zhou, Danny Reidenbach, Zhonglin Cao, Sooyoung Cha, Tomas Geffner et al. "Scaling atomistic protein binder design with generative pretraining and test-time compute." In International Conference on Learning Representations, vol. 2026, pp. 61056-61109. 2026.
[2] Wang, Yongkang, Xuan Liu, Feng Huang, Zhankun Xiong, and Wen Zhang. "A multi-modal contrastive diffusion model for therapeutic peptide generation." In Proceedings of the AAAI Conference on Artificial Intelligence, vol. 38, no. 1, pp. 3-11. 2024.
[3] Campbell, Andrew, Jason Yim, Regina Barzilay, Tom Rainforth, and Tommi Jaakkola. "Generative flows on discrete state-spaces: Enabling multimodal flows with applications to protein co-design." arXiv preprint arXiv:2402.04997 (2024).
Questions for authors
-
How is MIC and HC are obtained both in DPO stage (line 336 to 338) and evaluation stage for generated candidates.
-
Can the author propose more ablation study on the tokenizer to verify the effectiveness. The tokenizer is one of the major contribution in this paper. But I did not see any ablation study. It would be helpful to understand this component by removing certain part and varying the codebook size and dimension.