- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes BAPNet, an interactive camouflaged object segmentation framework designed to improve segmentation accuracy and reduce annotation effort. To address ambiguous object boundaries and foreground–background confusion, BAPNet introduces two key components: a Grassmann Boundary Guidance Module (GBGM) that captures structural boundary information through local subspace comparisons, and an Ambiguity-Prior Refinement Module (APRM) that identifies potentially erroneous regions and refines features using ambiguity-guided attention. Experiments on four camouflaged object datasets (CAMO, CHAMELEON, COD10K, and NC4K) demonstrate that BAPNet consistently outperforms existing interactive segmentation methods in terms of the number of clicks required to achieve target IoU thresholds. Ablation studies further support the effectiveness of the proposed modules.
Critical strengths
1. The paper addresses a practical and challenging task of interactive camouflaged object segmentation with clear motivation.
2. Extensive experiments on four benchmarks demonstrate consistent improvements over existing methods, supported by ablation studies.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited Novelty: Boundary guidance and uncertainty-aware refinement have been widely explored in previous studies. The proposed modules appear to be incremental extensions of existing techniques.
-
Insufficient Efficiency Analysis: The Grassmann-based eigendecomposition and multi-scale attention introduce additional computational overhead, but inference time, FLOPs, and memory consumption are not reported, despite the emphasis on interaction efficiency.
-
Marginal Performance Improvements: The improvements over strong baselines such as MST are relatively small in several settings, and no statistical significance analysis is provided.
-
Insufficient Validation of Key Modules: The paper lacks direct evaluations of boundary prediction quality and ambiguity estimation accuracy, making it difficult to verify the effectiveness of the proposed mechanisms.
-
Limited Ablation Studies: The complementary benefits of GBGM and APRM are not always evident. Sensitivity analyses of key hyperparameters and comparisons with simpler feature refinement strategies are also missing.
-
Incomplete Experimental Comparisons: Comparisons with representative prompt-based segmentation models such as SAM and SAM2 are missing. The evaluation also lacks real-world user studies to validate the claimed annotation time savings.
-
Writing and Formatting Issues: The manuscript contains several typos and grammatical errors (e.g., “In Eq. equation 2”), inconsistent notation, and duplicate references (e.g., Fan et al., 2020a/2020b; Liu et al., 2022a/2022b).
Questions for authors
-
Computational Efficiency: Could the authors provide inference time, FLOPs, and GPU memory comparisons with existing methods? How does the additional computational overhead of GBGM and APRM affect real-time interactive segmentation?
-
Effectiveness of the Proposed Priors: Could the authors provide quantitative evaluations of boundary prediction accuracy and ambiguity estimation quality? How can we verify that the performance improvements actually result from the proposed boundary and ambiguity priors?