- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose an efficient Discriminative Evidence Mining and Reconstruction Network (DMRNet) that integrates a Discriminative Evidence Mining (DEM) strategy and a Discriminative Evidence Reconstruction (DER) strategy. Specifically, DEM captures cross-layer feature discrepancies and exploits foreground–background competition to guide evidence selection while suppressing background interference, thereby attenuating misleading responses and yielding more reliable discriminative evidence.
Critical strengths
-
The paper addresses the degradation of discriminative evidence caused by feature compression in lightweight camouflaged object detection (COD). The research problem is clearly defined. To address this issue, the proposed DMRNet introduces effective and innovative modules, achieving the best performance among the compared methods while maintaining computational efficiency. Therefore, the work has practical significance.
-
The paper conducts extensive comparisons with a large number of competing methods on four benchmark datasets and achieves state of the art performance. In addition, the hierarchical feature visualizations and component-wise efficiency analyses provide more comprehensive evidence than numerical metrics alone, making the final results more convincing.
Critical weaknesses
-
In the ablation study, introducing CDEM leads to a substantial performance improvement. However, it remains unclear whether this gain is mainly attributable to the decoder structure itself or to the proposed foreground-background competition mechanism. Moreover, removing MFC results in only a marginal performance drop. More detailed and carefully controlled ablation studies are therefore required to verify these points.
-
The experimental setup should provide additional implementation details, including the validation set partition, to ensure the reproducibility of the reported results.
-
Figure 2 does not clearly demonstrate the advantages of the proposed method; the authors should revise it to better highlight these advantages.
Questions for authors
The authors are asked to address the weaknesses I have raised and provide as many reasonable explanations as possible.
3 comments
Response to Weakness (2) and Weakness (3) from Reviewer YL7C
Response to the Experimental Settings and the Method Architecture Figure
Thank you for pointing out the insufficient experimental details and the lack of clarity in the method architecture figure. We have made corresponding revisions based on your suggestions.
(1) Regarding the experimental details. We clarify that no separate validation set is used in our experiments. Following the checkpoint selection setting adopted by most methods in Table 1 (e.g., PRNet, KCNet, UTNet, and CHNet), we evaluate the checkpoint from each epoch on the CAMO test set and select the one with the lowest MAE. We have added these details to Section 4.1 (Implementation Details) of the revised manuscript to clarify the model selection procedure and improve reproducibility.
(2) Regarding the presentation of Fig. 2. Following your suggestion, we have redrawn Fig. 2 to provide a clearer illustration of the overall architecture of DMRNet. We have also further elaborated on the internal operations and feature interactions of the three components in CDEM, i.e., FP, MFC, and CEF, making the design rationale and overall workflow of the proposed method more intuitive and easier to understand.
Request Feedback from Reviewer YL7C
Dear Reviewer YL7C,
Thank you again for your thoughtful comments on our submission. As the discussion period is coming to a close, we would like to ask whether our responses have addressed your concerns. If any points remain unclear or if you have additional questions, we would greatly appreciate your guidance and will be happy to clarify further. If you feel that our revisions and explanations have resolved the issues you raised, we would be grateful if you could consider updating your evaluation accordingly.
We sincerely look forward to your feedback, and thank you for your time and effort throughout this process.
Best regards,
Authors of submission36108
Response to Weakness (1) from Reviewer YL7C
Response to the Only Backbone Setting and the Ablation Results of MFC
Thank you for pointing out the issues regarding the performance improvement and the MFC ablation study. We provide our explanations below.
First, the substantial performance improvement after introducing CDEM is attributable to the differences in feature processing between the two settings. Only Backbone directly feeds the four hierarchical feature maps output by SMT-T into 1×1 convolutions for prediction, without performing any COD-specific feature learning. Moreover, SMT-T itself is not specifically designed for COD, resulting in limited detection performance. This setting is designed to demonstrate that the performance of our model stems from the proposed architectural design rather than relying solely on the backbone.
Second, regarding the relatively limited performance degradation after removing MFC, we believe this should be understood in the context of MFC's role in the overall architecture. MFC is not designed to independently undertake the COD task. Instead, it further enhances the discriminative capability of features based on existing hierarchical feature representations through prediction-guided foreground-background prototype competition and uncertainty modeling. Therefore, removing MFC does not deprive the model of its basic feature representation and detection capabilities, but weakens its explicit modeling of foreground-background differences and adaptive feature modulation, consequently affecting the final detection performance. Furthermore, DMRNet targets lightweight COD, where the computational budget is strictly limited. Under such limited computational resources, every performance improvement is challenging to achieve.
To further verify the individual contributions of the mechanisms within MFC, we conducted three additional ablation experiments by removing foreground-background prototype competition (w/o F/B C), confidence weighting (w/o CW), and uncertainty-guided weighting (w/o UG), respectively, while keeping the other network structures and experimental settings unchanged. The experimental results are presented in the following table.
As shown in the table, removing any of the three mechanisms degrades performance, confirming their respective contributions. Among them, CW contributes most by improving prototype reliability, which supports subsequent foreground-background competition and discriminative evidence mining. F/B C provides discriminative cues through competition between foreground and background prototypes, while UG adjusts spatial routing weights according to prediction uncertainty. These mechanisms therefore serve complementary roles in prototype construction, foreground-background discrimination, and adaptive feature routing. Their individual contributions are further validated by the ablation results.
Following your suggestion, we have added the above three ablation experiments, complete experimental results, and corresponding analyses to the Appendix 10 to further validate the roles of the individual mechanisms within MFC.