- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes DES-UCOD for unsupervised camouflaged object detection, combining pseudo-label generation, preference optimisation, and a mixture-of-experts decoder, with experiments on four datasets.
Critical strengths
The method achieves promising results on multiple datasets and includes ablation studies to support its effectiveness
Critical weaknesses
- Unclear experimental fairness. The paper does not clearly explain whether the compared methods use consistent experimental settings, which may affect the reliability of the comparisons.
- Unclear hyperparameter selection. Table 7 reports hyperparameter experiments on COD10K, but it is unclear whether an independent validation set was used to select the final parameters.
Questions for authors
Q1. Were the baseline methods evaluated under consistent experimental settings, or were their results taken from the original papers? Q2. Were the final hyperparameters selected using an independent validation set rather than the test set?
2 comments
Dear Reviewer, As the discussion period is drawing to a close, we would like to gently follow up to see if our previous responses and additional experiments have addressed your concerns.
We are more than happy to provide any further clarifications if you have any remaining questions. Thank you again for your time and constructive feedback.
Author Responses
We sincerely thank the reviewer for raising this important concern. We would like to clarify that our experiments strictly follow the experimental protocol of DualUCOD, ensuring consistency across key experimental settings.
Firstly, we maintain consistent experimental configurations, including but not limited to input image resolution (476 × 476), dataset configurations, training and testing splits, data preprocessing, and evaluation protocols. These settings help minimize the influence of unrelated experimental factors and ensure a fair assessment of our proposed method.
Secondly, for competing methods, we prioritize the results officially reported in their original publications when the experimental settings and evaluation protocols are consistent with ours. When discrepancies exist in experimental configurations, we re-run the corresponding methods under unified experimental settings, including a standardized input resolution of 476 × 476, to ensure fair and controlled comparisons. All methods are evaluated on the same benchmark datasets using consistent evaluation metrics. Furthermore, as shown in Table 1, we separately organize comparisons based on DINO and DINOv2 backbones to account for architectural differences and enable more meaningful comparisons.
Overall, our experiments follow consistent benchmark and evaluation protocols. By prioritizing officially published results under comparable settings and conducting controlled re-evaluations when necessary, we aim to ensure the fairness, consistency, and reliability of our experimental comparisons.
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer's constructive suggestion.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for this valuable comment. We would like to clarify that an independent validation subset was randomly selected from the COD10K-Train and CAMO-Train datasets for hyperparameter tuning, following a validation strategy similar to previous work [1].
Firstly, all hyperparameters reported in Table 7 were empirically determined based on this validation subset to balance performance and computational efficiency.
Secondly, once the hyperparameters were selected, the same configuration was consistently applied across all experiments, ensuring fairness, consistency, and reproducibility.
Overall, our hyperparameter selection follows an independent validation-subset protocol. We acknowledge that this procedure was not sufficiently clarified in the original manuscript and will explicitly describe the validation strategy in the revised version to improve transparency and reproducibility.
We sincerely appreciate the reviewer's constructive suggestion.
Reference
[1] Y. Yang, J. Tian, S. Zhang, and L. Cao, "Discover, Segment, and Select: A Progressive Mechanism for Zero-shot Camouflaged Object Segmentation," Proceedings of the IEEE/CVF Conference on Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition (CVPR), pp. 34745–34754, 2026.