- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SEED, a teacher-student framework for unsupervised camouflaged object detection (UCOD), which decouples the task into two stages: “subject localization + distillation” and “detail exploration,” aiming to simultaneously address the trade-off between suppressing noise from false labels and preserving edge and structural details.
Critical strengths
The model designed by the author performs very well and has achieved excellent results on multiple datasets.
Critical weaknesses
The research motivation and technical novelty of this work are relatively limited. The paper attributes the main challenge to the trade-off between “suppressing noise in pseudo-labels” and “preserving fine-grained details.” However, this is not a problem unique to unsupervised camouflaged object detection (UCOD), but rather a common challenge in unsupervised learning involving pseudo-labels, self-training, and teacher-student models. Therefore, the research motivation itself does not reveal a sufficiently novel or insightful problem definition. More importantly, the proposed framework appears to consist primarily of existing, commonly used techniques. The teacher-student paradigm, exponential moving average (EMA)-based pseudo-label optimization, confidence-based region segmentation, consistency distillation, skeletonization, and temperature-based sharpening are all well-established technical components. The main contribution of this paper appears to lie in combining these existing modules into a coarse-to-fine training workflow, rather than introducing some fundamentally new learning mechanism or technical formulation. Although the experimental results indicate that this specific combination is effective, the paper fails to adequately justify why this combination constitutes a substantial methodological advancement over prior work. Furthermore, I have concerns regarding the fairness and completeness of the experimental comparisons. The paper does not explicitly report the input resolution used in its main experimental setup, making it difficult to determine whether the reported performance improvements were achieved under comparable computational conditions. This is particularly critical because segmentation performance is often highly sensitive to image resolution. Furthermore, the comparison with the newer UCOD method is insufficiently comprehensive, making it difficult to establish the method’s position relative to the latest state-of-the-art (SOTA). Overall, this paper presents a well-engineered system that achieves competitive empirical performance; however, its core methodology consists primarily of a combination of existing components, offering limited conceptual novelty. In its current form, I believe its technical contribution is not strong enough and lacks sufficient distinctiveness to meet the level of novelty typically expected at ICLR.
Questions for authors
- The central motivation of this paper—the trade-off between pseudo-label noise suppression and detail preservation—is a very common problem in unsupervised learning and self-training. Could the authors further explain what new technical challenges this problem poses in UCOD that have received little attention in previous research?
- SEED primarily consists of existing techniques, such as the teacher-student architecture, EMA pseudo-label refinement, confidence segmentation, consistency distillation, soft skeletalization, and temperature sharpening. Could the authors clearly articulate its core technical innovations, rather than merely describing the combination of these existing modules and the reorganization of the training process?
- The model size and computational cost of the full SEED (student model) are significantly higher than those of major baseline models (such as UCOD-DPL), and the paper does not explicitly report the input resolutions for all methods in the main experiments. Could the authors conduct a fair comparison under the same architecture, input resolution, and computational budget?
- The “Related Work” section of the paper mentions newer UCOD methods such as EReCu and Self-Anchored, but the main experiments do not include direct comparisons with these state-of-the-art methods. In the absence of these strong baseline models, how do the authors support their conclusion that their method is state-of-the-art and offers advantages?
2 comments
The authors adopt a 518×518 input resolution that is consistent only with UCOD-DPL but not with the other compared methods, which raises a serious concern about experimental fairness, as it remains unclear whether the reported gains stem from the higher resolution rather than from the effectiveness of the proposed method; I would suggest repeating the comparisons under a unified resolution or providing an ablation study to isolate the effect of resolution. Furthermore, the novelty of this work still appears limited, since the proposed approach shares substantial technical similarities with UCOD-DPL and reads more as a technical extension of it without introducing a genuinely new theory or algorithm. In light of these concerns, I maintain my original score.
Our paper received positive feedback for its clear motivation and strong performance gains. We thank all reviewers for their valuable and encouraging comments, including “an important issue in UCOD,” “The problem statement matches the results,” and “excellent results on multiple datasets.” We address all concerns point by point below.
Q1: Task-Specific Motivation and Challenge
In generic unsupervised segmentation, the trade-off between denoising and detail preservation mainly stems from pseudo-labels’ limited ability to represent semantic and instance structure; in UCOD, it stems from the high foreground–background feature similarity caused by camouflage. This confusion makes denoising more likely to erode genuine object structures or even retain a non-camouflaged object as the target, making the problem more severe in UCOD. Existing methods complete camouflaged object structures through feature-response-based pseudo-label purification and reliable-region selection. Biased feature responses in camouflage scenes leave genuine structures with weak responses without effective supervision, while non-camouflaged objects with strong responses are incorrectly retained. To address the lack of supervision for genuine details, we construct reliable subject constraints and detail supervision separately. Under reliable subject constraints, we use structural continuity and local relative responses to explore potential details, reducing the dependence of detail recovery on the completeness of teacher masks.
Q2: Design Rationale and Core Contribution of SEED
Existing UCOD methods rely on high-level semantic features from self-supervised visual models but lack fine-grained detail. To recover details, we directly introduced multi-level features into these methods but observed severe performance degradation. These results indicate that noisy pseudo-labels limit the effective use of fine-grained information across feature layers. This observation points to a mismatch between fine-grained representational capacity and the reliability of pseudo-label supervision.
SEED addresses this mismatch by decoupling subject localization from detail exploration. The teacher uses high-level semantic features to establish reliable subject-level constraints. Guided by these constraints, the student actively explores potential details using spatial information across feature layers. This organization is designed to reduce the interference of noisy supervision with fine-grained feature learning and to make detail recovery less dependent on complete teacher masks.
SEED’s innovation lies not in a specific architecture, but in reorganizing learning objectives and training around the pseudo-label reliability requirements of different features. SEED is therefore not a simple assembly of existing components into a coarse-to-fine training pipeline.
Q3: Controlled Comparison under Matched Model Capacity
We thank the reviewer for raising the question of experimental fairness. We added a controlled comparison in which SEED (DBA+LT) and UCOD-DPL use the same model architecture, input features, Look-Twice (LT) strategy, and 518×518 input resolution. The first SEED round consists of 20 epochs of STI and 5 epochs of SCD+ADE, matching UCOD-DPL's total of 25 training epochs. We also evaluated a single 1×1 convolutional decoder under the same experimental settings to examine the role of decoder capacity.
With the matched DBA+LT configuration, first-round SEED improves all five reported metrics over UCOD-DPL. The lower-capacity 1×1+LT configuration also improves Sm, Fw, meanFm, and MAE, although its meanEm is lower than that of UCOD-DPL. These results support the effectiveness of the proposed training strategy under matched or lower decoder capacity, without requiring a second round.
More generally, decoder complexity does not guarantee better performance in an unsupervised setting. Greater expressiveness can also increase the risk of fitting pseudo-label noise. The heterogeneous decoder design is motivated by the distinct requirements of subject localization and detail exploration.
Q4: Comparisons with Recent UCOD Methods
SEED outperforms these methods. Please see our response to Reviewer kZAH Q3 due to the character limit.