acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

What Motion Compensation Removes from Accumulated Radar and When It Still Helps

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Accumulating radar sweeps requires choosing where to place past returns before spatial rendering. Doppler-based motion compensation can concentrate returns around moving objects, but it also alters spatial trails that may support velocity estimation. We examine this trade-off through geometric measurements, linear probes of frozen encoders, and controlled detector comparisons on nuScenes and TruckScenes. On nuScenes, compensation reduces the correlation between normalised trail extent and object speed from 0.764 to 0.297 over ten sweeps, while increasing in-box return counts for fast-moving objects by 54%. A displacement-matched permutation reproduces neither effect. Object speed is more linearly accessible from raw-placement features, with an advantage of 0.019 to 0.032 across eight frozen encoders. In detector comparisons differing only in placement, raw placement yields lower velocity error in eight of nine paired comparisons across three systems and three training seeds, whereas compensation provides less consistent detection benefits. On TruckScenes, compensation reduces aggregate in-box concentration across moving objects at every evaluated accumulation window. Near-radial objects are the exception and the locus of both effects: there concentration instead improves and the trail-speed correlation is removed, an association with radial motion fraction that we do not explain. We further decompose the end-to-end gain of a detector retaining both placements. Along the evaluated sequence of controlled comparisons, correcting a Doppler coordinate-frame inconsistency in the reference pipeline evaluated here accounts for 69% and 81% of the mAP gain at two seeds; a displacement-matched, correspondence-breaking control recovers part of the remaining gain. These findings show that spatial concentration and access to motion cues can favour different placements, and that attributing downstream gains to placement requires controlling for changes in input features and architecture.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
radar perception, 3D object detection, motion compensation, representation analysis

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_CshCOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how Doppler-based motion compensation changes the information carried by accumulated radar points. It argues that compensation makes moving-object returns more spatially concentrated, but also removes trail patterns that are useful for velocity estimation. The authors evaluate this effect with geometric analysis, frozen-feature probes, and radar detectors on nuScenes and TruckScenes. They further decompose an end-to-end improvement and find that a large part of the gain comes from correcting a Doppler coordinate-frame issue rather than from motion compensation itself.

Critical strengths
  • The paper asks a clear and concrete question. Instead of only reporting detection gains from motion compensation, it separately studies what information is gained and lost by changing the placement of historical radar returns.

  • The controlled comparisons are careful. The raw/compensated comparison, displacement-matched permutation, frozen-encoder probes, and cross-dataset evaluation make the empirical observations relatively easy to interpret.

Critical weaknesses
  • The novelty is limited. Motion compensation concentrating moving-object returns, while uncompensated temporal accumulation leaves motion-dependent trails, is fairly intuitive. Prior works [1][2][3] have already studied motion compensation for accumulated radar.

  • The paper studies a rather narrow form of motion compensation. The displacement uses only radial Doppler and a constant-velocity extrapolation. This cannot recover tangential motion and is exactly where the behavior changes substantially on TruckScenes, so it is unclear whether the conclusions extend to object-level, learned, or full-velocity motion compensation methods.

  • The claim that compensation “removes velocity information” is somewhat overstated. Both representations still retain per-point radial Doppler, and the paper itself acknowledges that object velocity remains recoverable from Doppler and contextual cues. The experiments mainly show reduced accessibility of one trail-based cue, rather than a fundamental loss of velocity information.

  • The second contribution relies heavily on a pipeline-specific implementation issue. The reported 69%/81% decomposition of the mAP gain is dominated by correcting a Doppler coordinate-frame inconsistency in the reference pipeline. This is useful debugging, but it is unclear how much scientific insight this provides about motion compensation itself or how broadly the observation transfers to other implementations.

  • The causal decomposition is not sufficiently robust. It is performed only on CenterPoint, with two seeds, using one sequential ordering of factors; alternative orderings and factor interactions are not evaluated. Therefore, interpreting individual percentages such as “69%” or “81%” as attribution to specific causes is quite fragile.

  • The downstream evidence is inconsistent across models and datasets. Compensation improves detection reliably on only part of the nuScenes experiments and reverses on TruckScenes; the both-placement result transfers mainly in NDS, while velocity does not consistently improve. This makes it difficult to draw a general recommendation about which representation is preferable.

  • A crucial causal control is missing: full-velocity motion compensation. The paper only evaluates radial Doppler-based constant-velocity placement, so it is unclear whether the observed trade-off is caused by motion compensation itself or simply by using an incomplete radial motion estimate. An oracle experiment using ground-truth object velocity, or at least a learned full-velocity compensator, is needed before making broader claims about motion compensation.

[1] Gao, P., Zhang, S., Wang, W., and Lu, C. X. “DC-Loc: Accurate Automotive Radar Based Metric Localization with Explicit Doppler Compensation.” ICRA 2022.

[2] Palmer, P., Krueger, M., Altendorfer, R., and Bertram, T. “Ego-Motion Estimation and Dynamic Motion Separation from 3D Point Clouds for Accumulating Data and Improving 3D Object Detection.” AmE 2023.

[3] Haitman, Y., and Bialer, O. “DoppDrive: Doppler-Driven Temporal Aggregation for Improved Radar Object Detection.” ICCV 2025.

Questions for authors
  1. How do the main conclusions change if motion compensation uses full object velocity rather than radial Doppler only? Could you provide an oracle result using ground-truth velocity to separate the effect of compensation from the limitation of radial-only motion estimation?
  2. The paper argues that compensation removes velocity-related information, but both representations still retain per-point radial Doppler. Can you clarify what information is fundamentally lost, versus what simply becomes less accessible to the current encoder?
  3. The 69%/81% attribution is based on one sequential decomposition on CenterPoint. How sensitive are these numbers to the ordering of factors, and have interactions between feature correction, architecture, support change, and placement been tested?
  4. Is the Doppler coordinate-frame inconsistency specific to the evaluated reference pipeline, or does it also occur in other commonly used radar implementations? This directly affects how broadly the second contribution applies.
  5. Why are the decomposition and placebo controls only evaluated on CenterPoint, given that the raw-vs-compensated results already vary across CenterPoint, PillarNet-radar, RadarDistill, and TruckScenes?
Reviewer_oVSQOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies a preprocessing choice in multi-sweep radar detectors: whether past returns are kept where they were measured or shifted along their ray by their own Doppler (motion compensation). It measures the effect at three levels: the geometry of the accumulated point cloud, linear probes of frozen encoders, and controlled detector comparisons on three nuScenes systems and two TruckScenes systems. Compensation weakens the trail whose length tracks object speed and concentrates returns on fast, radially moving objects. Raw placement gives lower velocity error more consistently than compensation improves detection. The paper also decomposes the end-to-end gain of a detector that uses both placements, and finds that most of it comes from correcting a Doppler coordinate-frame error in the reference pipeline. The analysis is careful and well controlled, but the effects are small, the detectors are weak, and the scope is narrow.

Critical strengths
  1. The experimental design is unusually careful. Arms within a system differ in one factor, and on the PillarNet-radar student they are parameter-identical. The displacement-matched permutation preserves the displacement distribution exactly while breaking correspondence, and it reproduces neither effect (Table 6). The identity duplicate and the width-matched arm separate architecture and capacity from new information (Table 3, Appendix J). Per-seed results are reported (Table 22), and the limitations section is candid about what is and is not shown.

  2. The attribution result is useful beyond radar. Correcting a Doppler coordinate-frame error accounts for 69% and 81% of the end-to-end mAP gain at the two seeds. The speed-stratified velocity improvement that seemed to confirm the placement account is reproduced by that correction alone (Table 10). This is a concrete example of an end-to-end comparison crediting the wrong component.

  3. The cross-dataset analysis adds real information. On TruckScenes the localisation gain is negative at every accumulation window (Table 16), and stratifying by radial fraction shows that compensation only consolidates returns for near-radial motion (Table 17). This clarifies when the standard practice can be expected to help.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The detector-level effects are small relative to the evidence behind them. Absolute performance is low on every system: on nuScenes, the best arm of each detector reaches only 4.5 mAP (PillarNet-radar student), 10.1 (CenterPoint) and 14.7 (RadarDistill, which starts from a LiDAR teacher), out of 100. The differences between placements are much smaller, at most about 0.7 mAP within any nuScenes system (Table 1): on CenterPoint, compensated versus raw is 9.83 versus 9.67 mAP. Most arms have only two or three seeds, and a margin is judged against the range across those seeds, which is a weak criterion with two seeds. The clearest single-factor result, the student's velocity error (39.19 versus 44.35 mAVE), comes from the weakest detector (about 4.5 mAP). Confidence intervals or paired tests over more seeds would make the conclusions more secure.

  2. The geometric headline numbers depend on a membership rule that uses ground-truth velocity. Returns are assigned to an object using its box propagated back by its ground-truth velocity, and the velocity code uses the ground-truth heading. Under any of the tested spatial margins (1 to 15 m), the raw velocity code never exceeds 0.239 instead of 0.764, and the raw-minus-compensated gap falls to 0.014 at 8 m and -0.005 at 15 m (Table 4). Appendices A and G acknowledge this, but the abstract reports the drop from 0.764 to 0.297 without the caveat. These numbers describe what the point cloud contains given the true motion, not what a detector without labels could separate from neighbouring returns and clutter. The frozen-encoder probe in Section 3.4 does not use these labels, but the advantage it finds for raw placement is small (0.019 to 0.032 R2).

  3. The compensation studied is radial-only. Section 2.1 says the compensated placement is the DoppDrive construction, which also gives each return its own aggregation duration to limit tangential scatter. However, Equation 1 and Appendix G implement only the shift of each return along its own ray. The TruckScenes reversal is concentrated in objects whose motion is not radial (Table 17), which is the case that mechanism targets. The conclusions therefore apply to the radial shift rather than to motion compensation in general. The paper should either evaluate the full construction or narrow its claims.

  4. The scope of the contributions is narrow for ICLR. The setting is one preprocessing choice in radar-only bird's-eye-view detectors, with no radar-camera fusion system, where velocity can also come from images. The frame error behind the main attribution result is established only for the pipeline evaluated here, and there is no check of whether it affects published compensation results. The decomposition and both placebos are also measured on CenterPoint alone (Appendix L), so the attribution lesson rests on one configuration.

Questions for authors

I have some questions for the authors for the rebuttal. The questions are stated below for their reference:

  1. Does the compensated placement include DoppDrive's per-return aggregation duration? If not, how do the TruckScenes results change when it is added?
  2. Which codebase contains the Doppler frame error, and does it affect the published results of DoppDrive, RadarDistill or other compensation methods?
  3. Can the velocity code and localisation gain be measured with a membership rule that does not use ground-truth velocity, for example detected or tracked boxes?
  4. Could you report confidence intervals or paired tests for the main single-factor contrasts, with more seeds at least on the student?
  5. Do the conclusions hold for a radar-camera fusion detector, where velocity can also be estimated from the camera?
Reviewer_k1S7OpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper reports a comparative analysis of raw placement, which leaves accumulated radar points at their original positions, and Doppler-based motion-compensated placement. The authors conducted geometric measurements, linear probes of frozen encoders, and detector experiments on nuScenes and TruckScenes. They showed that compensation weakens cues for velocity estimation, while its benefits for point concentration and detection depend on the conditions. Through ablation experiments, they also report that much of the apparent improvement in a detector that retains both placements comes from correcting a Doppler coordinate-frame inconsistency in the reference implementation.

Critical strengths
  • The paper connects geometric measurements, probes using the same frozen encoder, and detector comparisons that change only the placement. It distinguishes between the presence, readout, and use of information. The consistent differences across eight encoders provide evidence of the cost of compensation without relying on a single metric.
Critical weaknesses
  • The geometric metrics depend on a membership rule that uses ground-truth velocity to extrapolate boxes backward in time under a constant-velocity assumption. Table 4 shows that the correlation gap changes substantially across membership rules. No validation against the annotated positions and orientations at each timestamp is reported, so it is unclear how sensitive the reported effect sizes for correlation reduction and localisation gain are to approximation errors.

  • For PillarNet-radar, raw placement improves mAVE but reduces mAP. The authors acknowledge that the results depend on which objects are detected, but it is unclear whether the comparisons use the same set of objects. Thus, improvements in velocity estimation itself cannot be separated from changes in which objects are detected.

  • The finding that coordinate-frame correction accounts for 69% and 81% of the mAP gain appears to reflect the incremental gain obtained when the correction is applied first. Although the limitations are stated, interactions between the correction and changes in placement or architecture have not been evaluated. It remains unclear whether the interpretation that the correction is the main contributor is robust to the order of these changes.

  • The paper’s claims are not clearly organized. The text needs substantial revision to clarify what the authors propose, why they propose it, and what they did.

Questions for authors
  • Do the reduction in correlation and the localisation gain remain if point-to-object membership is reassigned by interpolating the positions and orientations along the annotated trajectories to each return’s timestamp? Please keep the set of evaluated objects as consistent as possible and report the effect sizes corresponding to Table 5, together with their sensitivity to the degree of acceleration and turning.
  • In a 2 x 2 comparison of raw versus both placements, with and without Doppler feature correction, does the effect of correction depend on the placement? Please keep the compensated coordinates fixed in the correct coordinate frame under both correction conditions and change only the Doppler feature columns. Please show whether the correction still accounts for most of the gain when it is applied after the placement change.
  • In Appendix E, does “matched detections” refer to the same set of ground-truth objects across placements? If not, please evaluate the common set of objects detected under both placements and report the detection counts and paired differences in velocity error by speed bin and class. Please confirm whether the advantage of raw placement in Table 9 remains.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.