- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
As it is hard to read the paper it maybe reflected in the following summary. The goal is learning representation in presenece of nuisance parameter that affect the task performance. The paper starts with general problem definition and several theoretical results in general setting. The paper demonstrates the of array ambiguity where the direction of arrival (the label) is interpreted by phase (nuisance parameter). Then the paper discusses the prediction of uncertainty with confidence interval.
Critical strengths
As it is hard to read the paper maybe there are additional strengths. This work address an interesting example of array ambiguity and representation learning, can provide an interesting challenge to machine learning community.
Critical weaknesses
(1) Novelty: Array ambiguity has a long line of works in the signal processing community [R.1, R.2, R.3] and it unclear what is the contribution of Theorem 3 and ULA corollary as they are study widely. Moreover, it is unclear how the authors suggest to address this and what is the underline method and relation to representation learning. In addition Theorem 2 is trivial and a direct results of the assumptions. Finally, it is unclear from the text what are the main contributions.
(2) Clarity of presentation: it is very hard to read the paper and try to have a flow of understanding of the paper. Here are few critical points why this paper is unclear:
1.1 Figures are not referenced in the text and the reader needs to relate the figure to the part of the text is relevant .
1.2 There is a lack of related work or list of contributions that would specify what is the contribution of this works.
1.3 There is a mix of notation in the text and it unclear how to relate example to the notation at the beginning for example the y label and h nuisance parameter. (e.g. equation 3-5 what is nuisance and what is label? )
1.4 There is no clear statement of what are the contributions of this work.
1.5 There is not reference from the main text to proofs, and the reader need to search for them in the appendix.
1.6 Figure legends are not specified or unclear (e.g. Figure 4 black dashed line)
The notations are hard to follow, for example:
1.1 In equation 3 and 4 is x is the same as x_{a}
1.2 In equation 3, A is not defined (I assumed it is the number of sensors)
1.3 Mismatch in indexing between equations (3) and (5)
1.4 Several acronyms are not defined such as CQR, ADC, ULA, etc.
(3) Experiment Results: There is no baseline compression and it hard to understand if there is any new observation from the results the enable better understanding of the problem.
[R.1] A. J. Weiss and B. Friedlander, "Eigenstructure methods for direction finding with sensor gain and phase uncertainties," Circuits Syst. Signal Process., vol. 9, no. 3, pp. 271–300, 1990
[R.2] E. K. L. Hung, "A critical study of a self-calibrating direction-finding method for arrays," IEEE Trans. Signal Process., vol. 42, no. 2, pp. 471–474, Feb. 1994.
[R.3] Liu, Zhexian, et al. "Ambiguity-Free DOA Estimation for Linear Arrays via Sparse Bayesian Phase Error Self-Calibration." 2025 9th International Conference on Vision, Image and Signal Processing (ICVISP). IEEE, 2025.
Questions for authors
(1) What the authors see as the main contributions of this work?
(2) As array ambiguity has a long line of works in signal processing community, can the authors state what is the novelty or new in Theorem 3 and ULA corollary?
(3) How are the different experiment related ?
(4) In Array model equations 3-5 what are the labels Y usually is the direction of arrival but it unclear from the text?
(5) What is the spatial dimension? p=3? or p=2?
(6) In line "Our posterior, oracle, and anchor are matched nonlearned references;" where is this compression shown?
2 comments
Thanks the authors for the detailed response. However, following the authors acknowledgment three is limited theoretical novelty (gauge theorem) and the other reviewers comments, I will keep the current score.
Thank you for the detailed list. We are sorry the submitted version was hard to read. Most of your points are addressed in the revision.
Q1. Main contributions. The introduction now lists three: (i) known limits, restated as a precision requirement for a requested interval width; (ii) a map from each kind of calibration information to the coverage claim it supports, with learned evidence; (iii) a test of reference transfer, in simulation and on real recordings.
Q2. Novelty of the gauge theorem and the ULA corollary. None. They are the classical ambiguity of array self-calibration, written for general geometry. The revision labels the theorem "classical", cites Weiss and Friedlander (1990), Wylie et al. (1994) and Hung (1994) next to it, and makes no novelty claim. The result you describe as a direct consequence of the assumptions is now stated as an elementary proposition.
Q3. How the experiments relate. Section 3 follows the rows of Table 1 in order: input alone, a law, average versus fixed-drift coverage, a bound, a labelled panel. Section 4 treats the last row, a shared reference.
Q4. Labels and nuisance in the array model. The text after Eq. (3) now states that the label is the wavevector coordinate k (the direction, for a line), the nuisance is the sensor phase calibration, and the forward operator maps both to the observation.
Q5. Spatial dimension. p = 1 for a line and p = 2 for a plane. All learned experiments use p = 1. This is stated where the array model is introduced.
Q6. The sentence on matched non-learned references. That sentence has been removed. The comparison it referred to is Table 12 (Appendix C2), which lists every method with the information it uses, its coverage and its width.
Notation and presentation.
Baselines. Narrow training, wide augmentation, a supplied law, a conservative set, a labelled panel with direct and orbit heads, and an oracle are compared in Tables 2 and 12 (an excerpt of Table 12 is in our general comment above); label-only conformal calibration with the same labels as the anchors is compared in Appendix B3. We agree the submitted version did not make this easy to find.
How we address the ambiguity. We do not propose a representation-learning method that removes it; the results show that none can from the input alone. The paper states which additional information supports which coverage claim.