- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper deals with the problem of target recovery using auxiliary calibration data. Concretely, the goal is to estimate a target from an observed channel , using a second channel without target, , where is a "shared nuisance parameter". To do so, the authors rely on, using their terms, a paired nuisance geometry and efficient information, and show that, for an unrestricted nuisance, the problem is equivalent in minimax risk to the efficient Gaussian shift. They then derive two-resource minimax rates depending on the number of target-bearing data and of auxiliary data . They then study the case where auxiliary calibration is collected at different times. Finally, they ask, for a fixed auxiliary calibration budget, where it should be spent.
Critical strengths
First, the overall problem studied, i.e., when auxiliary calibration improves target recovery, is relevant; and the derivations seem correct to me. Second, the theoretical study is exhaustive, from the problem formulation to the minimax analysis and the budget allocation.
Critical weaknesses
The main problem is the formalism: the paper is very hard to read and contains too many undefined notations. The introduction relies on undefined terms from the start ("target-bearing data", "nuisance directions", "closed linear relation"...). This continues in the rest of the paper. Notations are often undefined: the spaces in the very first line of theory! A striking example is appearing as a dummy variable in eq (2.2), but appears in fact to be the "target direction" which seems to be a key notion to the paper (and this quantity is properly introduced in (Trabs 2015) where the equation comes from). Others : after eq (2.5), the list is not exhaustive.
This problem leads to the second weakness being the clarity of the contribution. The model described in (1.1) is not explained or linked to a concrete application; it is only related to several references listed at line 54 with little explanation. The related-work paragraph begins by citing only papers on the tools used, the first positioning of the work appears with the comparison to "de Hoop et al 2023", and the rest of the paragraph ((attia et al. 2018) and others) is ambiguous about the novelty of the present work. In my view, the contribution is unclear and is poorly put into perspective with the state of the art, even though it seems to be cited.
Questions for authors
Could you state precisely what your results bring compared to the cited works? In particular, the "two-resources rates" seem close to those obtained for deconvolution with an auxiliary sample (Comte & Lacour, 2011) and, the main stated difference with (de Hoop et al., 2023) is the "noncommuting transfer operators". What does your formulation allow that these works do not, and is there a concrete application where the difference matters?