- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ZymPro for transition-aware modeling of enzymatic reactions. The method first constructs approximate transition states and reaction paths using computational methods, and then trains a process-corrected diffusion model to generate transition-state geometries conditioned on enzymes and reactants. The learned information is further used for product generation and enzyme compatibility ranking. Experiments show improvements over several baselines on both downstream tasks, and ablation studies suggest that transition-state supervision and the proposed Corrector are useful.
Critical strengths
-
The problem is interesting and meaningful. Incorporating reaction process information into enzyme-conditioned prediction is a reasonable direction, and could be useful for understanding enzyme-specific reactions.
-
The proposed method has some interesting designs, especially the process-corrected diffusion with return and advance corrections. The idea of using computational reaction paths to provide additional supervision is also reasonable.
-
The experimental results are good, with clear improvements on enzyme compatibility ranking and product generation. The paper also includes quite extensive experiments, with different baselines, ablations, and generalization settings.
Critical weaknesses
-
I am not fully convinced by the main claim of modeling enzymatic reaction processes through transition-state generation. The TS targets are approximated from computational reaction paths constructed using known reactants and products. The paper evaluates how well the model reproduces these computed structures, but does not really validate whether they correspond to physically meaningful transition states or reaction mechanisms. I think the current results mainly show that computationally derived process supervision can improve downstream prediction, which is somewhat different from the stronger motivation of modeling enzyme-catalyzed reaction processes. The claim should be better clarified.
-
It is unclear whether the improvement really comes from transition-state modeling, or simply from additional reaction supervision. The TS targets are constructed using product information, and the training also includes direct supervision on bond changes. Such information is already useful for reaction prediction, even without explicitly modeling transition states. Although the ablation results show that TS-related features are useful, they do not clearly distinguish the contribution of TS-specific information from other reaction information. For example, ZymPro\T changes both the prediction target and the process supervision, making it difficult to isolate the effect of TS geometry. I think a simpler reaction-center or bond-change supervised baseline would be important here.
-
The connection between the generated transition states and the downstream tasks is not fully demonstrated. In particular, enzyme compatibility ranking does not use the complete generated TS, but only extracts features from one denoising and correction step. Therefore, the improvement in this task may mainly come from a better pretrained representation, rather than explicit TS generation. It would be useful to better explain what information is actually transferred to the downstream tasks, and whether accurate TS geometry is necessary for the improvements.
-
The enzyme-specific catalytic information is not sufficiently validated. The method emphasizes modeling enzyme-dependent reaction processes, but the model does not use explicit enzyme-reactant relative geometry during inference. Also, the enzyme-free ablation changes both the enzyme conditioning and the computational supervision, so it does not fully isolate the contribution of enzyme-specific information. I would like to see more direct analysis of whether changing the enzyme leads to meaningful differences in the predicted TS, and whether these differences agree with known enzyme-specific reaction behavior.
Questions for authors
-
Can the authors clarify whether the main contribution is learning physically meaningful transition-state processes, or using computationally derived TS supervision to improve downstream prediction? What evidence supports the former interpretation?
-
Have the authors considered a reaction-center or bond-change supervised baseline, without explicitly generating TS geometry? Since the current training already includes bond-change supervision, I think this comparison would help clarify the necessity of TS modeling.
-
For enzyme compatibility ranking, why is only one denoising step used instead of the complete TS generation? Would using the full generated TS improve the results? Also, is there any relationship between TS prediction accuracy and downstream performance?
-
Can the authors provide more evidence that the generated TS captures enzyme-specific catalytic effects? For example, how does the predicted TS change when different enzymes are provided for the same reactants?
Dear Reviewer Wwju,
I hope this message finds you well. As the discussion period is nearing its end, I wanted to ensure we have addressed all your concerns satisfactorily. If there are any additional points or feedback you'd like us to consider, please let us know. Your insights are invaluable to us, and we're eager to address any remaining issues to improve our work.
Thank you for your time and effort in reviewing our paper.