- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This manuscript proposes Multistate Gibbs Sampling (MUGS) for the design of protein seqs that can support multiple states of an enzyme's catalytic cycle. The method alternates between predicting structures for different catalytic sttes using a new motif-conditioned structure model and updating a shared protein seq using LigandMPNN. MUGS can both refine existing designs and do the de novo design. The authors evaluate MUGS on the single-state AME benchmark, and introduce a new multistate benchmark, and show a case study on a 5-state serine hydrolase system. The paper also explores inference-time scaling using beam search and sequence Monte Carlo, and applies the motif-conditioned structure model (MCFOLD) to approximate reaction free-energy profiles with reduced QM/MM sampling.
Critical strengths
- MUGS combines motif-conditioned structure prediction with multi-state seq design in a straightforward iterative procedure, which is flexible for different design settings.
- Promising experimental results on computational benchmarks. The method shows consistent improvements over the RFD2 baseline on AME and MAME. These results provide encouraging evidence that multistate conditioning is useful.
- MCFOLD provides atomic motif conditioning for sequence-based structure prediction. The ablations show improvements over standard structure prediction and template conditioning. The MAME benchmark also provides a useful starting point for evaluating multistate enzyme design methods.
Critical weaknesses
-
The sequence update does not clearly optimize compatibility across all states. A central goal of MUGS is to find one sequence that is compatible with every catalytic state. However, in Section 2.3, the authors use tied LigandMPNN by averaging the amino acid probabilities predicted for each state. I am not convinced that this is the best way to combine information from different states. For example, an amino acid that is strongly preferred in one state but poorly supported in another may still receive a high average probability. As a result, the sequence update does not explicitly require agreement across all states. This is important because the evaluation uses the worst-performing state. There seems to be a gap between how the sequence is generated and how success is measured.
-
MUGS independently predicts a structure for each catalytic state, conditioned on the same sequence. However, this does not ensure that the protein can physically move between these structures or that the different states have suitable relative energies. More importantly, successful catalysis requires more than structural compatibility. An enzyme must stabilize the relevant transition states while allowing substrate binding, product release, and turnover. A design that strongly stabilizes every state could even reduce catalytic efficiency by over-stabilizing the substrate or product. The current evaluation focuses on motif RMSD, which does not capture these effects. Therefore, the results demonstrate improved multistate structural compatibility, but provide weaker evidence for improved catalytic function.
-
The main comparisons are between RFD2 and MUGS with different numbers of conditioning states. However, MUGS introduces several changes at once: a new motif-conditioned structure predictor, repeated structure-sequence updates, and additional structural information from multiple states. It is therefore difficult to determine which component is responsible for the improvement. For example, MUGS with K=3 requires three structure predictions per iteration, while K = 1 requires only one. The improvement from increasing K may partly come from the additional compute rather than the multistate information itself.
-
The serine hydrolase experiment is directly related to the paper's motivation. However, its conditioning motifs are derived from a previously validated enzyme. I think it does not fullly establish that MUGS can design enzymes for new reactions where suitable catalytic geometries are unknown or uncertain.
Questions for authors
- Is structural compatibility enough for the good enzyme design? Does better multistate motif RMSD lead to more favorable catalytic properties?
- Why is averaging amino acid probabilities the right choice for multistate sequence design?
- How do the authors verify that the designed sequences support the different states without relying on motif constraints? Are the final structures evaluated using an independent predictor without motif conditioning? Have the authors tested the designs using alternative structure predictors or physical relaxation? Also, can the authors report the similarity of the generated structures to native enzymes and to structures used in model training?
- How accurate are the predicted reaction free-energy barriers? The paper mainly reports agreement in terms of Pearson correlation. Could the authors also report errors in activation barriers and reactant-product free-energy differences?
We thank the reviewer for their overall positive review and address their concerns below!
While structural compatibility cannot guarantee activity, the two are meaningfully linked as demonstrated by Lauko et al. (2025). They have wet lab validated new serine hydrolases across 5 distinct folds, and show that screening for active site preorganization across the reaction cycle substantially improved experimental success. MuGS builds directly on this by moving multistate compatibility from downstream filtering into the generation process itself.
But to the reviewer's point, motifRMSD may not be perfect. We therefore also compare the catalytic triad rotamers of MuGS K=3 serine hydrolase against Lauko's enzyme, finding strong agreement in cosine sim.
We do indeed plan to pursue wet lab validation of our designs, but hope the reviewer agrees that this is beyond the scope of an ML methods paper and that our technical contributions stand their own. We would also like to point back to Fig. 6, where the red vertical line marks all state motif RMSD of Lauko's wet lab validated enzyme (1.59 Å). When we reran RFD1 (same pipeline that produced that Lauko enzyme) and RFD3, neither reached it suggesting that much more sampling was required. MuGS K=3 and K=2 were able to reach this threshold, and these are the designs we plan to test experimentally. We hope this provides sufficient evidence of promise for catalytic activity.
Regarding physics based evals, we have now performed GFN2 xTB calculations on the catalytic active sites of our MuGS K=3 design and Lauko's validated enzyme (both its crystal structure and Boltz refolds). We relaxed the reacting atoms in each state and calculated their potential energies relative to the substrate. While these are not full profiles, we find encouraging agreement between MuGS and Lauko's relative energies.
We also now ran three rep 1 ns apo MD simulations to test whether the catalytic hydrogen bonds remain stable. MuGS K=3 best design retains the His–Asp interaction in 97.7% of frames, comparable to Lauko's validated enzyme (100%), while RFD3's best design loses it entirely. MuGS also shows higher Ser–His occupancy than Lauko (25.9% vs. 13.3%) (Appendix B.5.1, Table 7, Fig. 12). We hope this along with the previous provide convincing physical validation.
We understand the reviewer's concern about benchmark scale, but many of the problems we tackle lack established benchmarks or standard evaluation protocols. Us curating MAME relied on the fortuitous availability of multiple experimental structures capturing different catalytic states of the SAME enzyme (or close homolog). For such structures to exist, experimentalists have often had to trap short lived reaction intermediates and stabilize them for crystallization and solve. Thus, suitable multistate examples are inherently rare, and we had to identify and match these structures across M-CSA and the PDB. Similarly, our reaction free energy experiments required finding well characterized reactions with suitable reference data. We therefore believe these are true steps forward to full scale benchmarks and are substantial contributions in their own right.
Nevertheless, we have greatly expanded our experiments throughout the rebuttal thanks to all the reviewers constructive comments. We have now benchmarked RFD3 across all MAME and the serine hydrolase (shows improvements in single state design do not necessarily translate to multistate compatibility (Fig. 6)). We also evaluated MuGS design novelty against the entire PDB, ran MD and xTB physical simulations, and extended our reaction free energy experiments with a better Hamiltonian for BsCM and even added a second enzyme, DhlA (Appendix Figs. 10–11).
We hope to have addressed the reviewer's concerns, but are happy to answer any more during the remaining week of rebuttal! If all concerns have been addressed, we would appreciate the reviewer's consideration of a higher score.