- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies personalized federated learning for photovoltaic panel pollution and damage identification. pFedSolar combines client-side vision adapters, domain adversarial learning, and shared/private text embeddings on a frozen CLIP ViT-B/32 backbone. Only shared text embeddings are aggregated through FedAvg, adapters, private embeddings, and domain discriminators remain local. The author merged two Kaggle data sets to construct four simulated power station clients, reporting average accuracy rates of 92.07% and 93.62% under mild and severe category heterogeneity, respectively, and advocated that the design takes into account both cross-power station knowledge sharing and local adaptation.
Critical strengths
- The application motivation is reasonable. The data sharing restrictions and distribution differences between photovoltaic power plants make personalized federated learning a meaningful scenario with operation and maintenance value.
- The design is practical. Training lightweight modules on frozen CLIP is suitable for current data scale, and only aggregating shared text embeddings reduces communication overhead.
- More experimental analysis. Includes five random seeds, stepwise ablation, sensitivity analysis of two loss coefficients, and confusion matrix.
Critical weaknesses
- According to Section 4.3, Table 1, and Appendix B.3, each client maintains a discriminator (D_k) independently, the discriminator does not participate in aggregation, and communication only involves shared text embeddings. Equation (4) uses the client identity as the domain label, so (D_k) seems to only touch samples with the label constant (k). It only requires constant prediction (k) to reduce the loss and never compares feature distributions across clients; gradient reversal thus fails to provide effective signals for cross-client domain invariant features.
- Section 3.1 states that there are 1,724 images in total, and the total number of categories in Tables 5 and 6 is 1,723.
- Table 5 Site 3: (10+100+60+20+95=285), but the total is written as 325.
- Tables 9 and 10 show that the default configuration results (92.86%/93.04%) are different from the main results (92.07%/93.62%) and are not explained.
Questions for authors
- Please explain the difference in sample count and default configuration results in W5
3 comments
Response to Reviewer CkzW
We thank the reviewer for the careful reading and detailed feedback. Below we address each concern point by point.
On the degenerate domain discriminator (Critical Weakness 1):
We fully agree with the reviewer's accurate observation. The original local discriminator had access only to samples with the same domain label k, which rendered the adversarial objective degenerate — the discriminator simply learned to predict a constant label and provided no meaningful gradient signal for domain-invariant feature learning. We have completely redesigned the domain adversarial learning module to fix this issue.
The key redesign is the introduction of cross-modal pseudo domain samples. Since shared text embeddings from all other clients are already communicated during federated training (for the decoupled text embedding mechanism), they can serve as pseudo domain prototypes for the local discriminator at no extra communication cost. Leveraging CLIP's cross-modal alignment property — visual and text embeddings lie in the same shared embedding space — these text embeddings carry domain-specific semantic information comparable to visual features.
The discriminator now receives two types of inputs: (i) local adapted visual features with domain label k (processed via gradient reversal layer), and (ii) shared text embeddings from all K clients as cross-modal pseudo domain samples with their respective domain labels. With access to all K domain distributions, the discriminator can now perform genuine multi-domain classification, and gradient reversal effectively drives the image adapter toward learning domain-invariant soiling features.
With this redesign, the domain adversarial module now yields a meaningful gain of +4.72% under mild heterogeneity and +9.92% under severe heterogeneity (comparing v2 and v3 in the revised ablation study), compared to the original near-zero contribution. The redesigned module is detailed in Section 4.4 (renamed "Cross-Modal Federated Domain Adversarial Learning").
On the dataset size discrepancy (Critical Weakness 2):
We thank the reviewer for catching this inconsistency. The correct total number of images in our composite dataset is 1,723. The original manuscript had a typo in Section 3.1 stating 1,724 images. We have corrected this in the revised manuscript, and the number is now consistent across the main text and all tables (Tables 5 and 6 both show a total of 1,723).
On the Site 3 sample count error in Table 5 (Critical Weakness 3):
We thank the reviewer for pointing out this arithmetic error. The correct total for Site 3 (Cold) in the mild heterogeneity setting is 285 (10+100+60+20+95), not 325 as originally written. We have corrected this in Table 5 of the revised manuscript.
On the discrepancy between sensitivity analysis and main results (Critical Weakness 4 & Question 1):
The difference is due to the number of random seeds used. The main results in Table 2 report the average accuracy over 5 random seeds (seeds 0, 42, 123, 456, and 789), while the sensitivity analysis in Tables 9 and 10 uses only a single seed (seed=0) to reduce computational cost of the hyperparameter sweep. Since the results vary across seeds (as evidenced by the standard deviations reported in the main tables), the single-seed sensitivity analysis values naturally differ from the five-seed average. The default configuration in the sensitivity analysis (λ_dann=0.1, λ_reg=0.01, seed=0) corresponds to the seed=0 row of the main ablation results, not the five-seed average. We make this distinction clearer by explicitly noting the single-seed nature of the sensitivity analysis in the table captions.
We appreciate the reviewer's thorough and careful review, which has helped us identify and correct several important issues in the manuscript.
Response to Reviewer CkzW's update
Thank you.
update
I have corrected the “Flag For Ethics Review” field, which I had accidentally marked as “Yes.”