- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FedORS. To address the issue where shared representations and personalized prediction heads cannot recover missing information in the shared representations, it introduces an additional client-specific residual branch to improve the accuracy of PFL. Experimental results demonstrate that FedORS outperforms the baselines compared in this study.
Strengths The motivation behind FedORS is relatively interesting, the theoretical analysis is comprehensive, the writing is logically sound, and the experimental results validate the method’s advantages.
Weaknesses
- The paper lacks ablation experiments. If such experiments were included, they would provide a more intuitive way to observe the effective gains of each mechanism.
- FedORS does not compare itself to the 2026 SOTA PFL methods, which significantly weakens its validity. Additionally, the experimental details provided in the current appendix are insufficient; we hope the authors will provide more detailed experimental information.
- The authors use LPC for client-side class segmentation in the paper. Why not use Pathological data segmentation? Furthermore, the paper describes differences in client-side prediction. Where exactly are these differences manifested? Hope the authors can provide an explanation.
Critical strengths
The motivation behind FedORS is relatively interesting, the theoretical analysis is comprehensive, the writing is logically sound, and the experimental results validate the method’s advantages.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper lacks ablation experiments. If such experiments were included, they would provide a more intuitive way to observe the effective gains of each mechanism.
- FedORS does not compare itself to the 2026 SOTA PFL methods, which significantly weakens its validity. Additionally, the experimental details provided in the current appendix are insufficient; we hope the authors will provide more detailed experimental information.
- The authors use LPC for client-side class segmentation in the paper. Why not use Pathological data segmentation? Furthermore, the paper describes differences in client-side prediction. Where exactly are these differences manifested? Hope the authors can provide an explanation.
Questions for authors
- The paper lacks ablation experiments. If such experiments were included, they would provide a more intuitive way to observe the effective gains of each mechanism.
- FedORS does not compare itself to the 2026 SOTA PFL methods, which significantly weakens its validity. Additionally, the experimental details provided in the current appendix are insufficient; we hope the authors will provide more detailed experimental information.
- The authors use LPC for client-side class segmentation in the paper. Why not use Pathological data segmentation? Furthermore, the paper describes differences in client-side prediction. Where exactly are these differences manifested? Hope the authors can provide an explanation.