acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Beyond Homogeneous Gaussian Modeling: Is Cross-Region Geometry Representation the Key to Talking Portrait Generation?

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS) demonstrates strong representation capability and great potential for portrait generation. However, generated portraits still suffer from significant geometric degradation. Specifically, due to the lack of global constraints, the geometric boundary between motion regions and the static background is difficult to maintain, making the boundary prone to deformation or distortion. Furthermore, structural characteristics in the portrait can lead to motion differences across regions, resulting in structural misalignment or discontinuities. We attribute these issues to the homogeneous representation adopted by existing 3DGS-based methods, which treats regions with different motion characteristics in a unified manner and fails to capture their distinct geometric properties. To address this problem, we propose a cross-region geometric representation framework that aims to characterize the geometric relationships among different motion regions for dynamic portrait generation. The proposed framework consists of two core strategies: global motion depth representation (GMDR) and local motion multi-scale representation (LMMR). GMDR constructs a depth representation of global motion regions to describe the spatial hierarchy between the dynamic foreground and static background, thereby alleviating geometric distortions. LMMR exploits multi-scale representations of local motion regions to capture structural variations in portraits, promoting motion coordination and structural integrity across regions in continuous sequences. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed method significantly improves the geometric fidelity of portraits in continuous dynamic sequences and outperforms existing state-of-the-art approaches.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
Video Generation, 3DGS, Multimodality, Representation, Talking Portrait

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_QoC7OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper conditions Gaussian geometry offsets on global foreground/depth features and local multi-scale motion features extracted from video. An audio-input student is illustrated in Appendix C as learning video-derived teacher features. Reported comparisons show improved rendering quality, lip synchronization, and structural stability.

Critical strengths
  • Distinguishing foreground–background interactions from local facial motion addresses a meaningful source of boundary and structural artifacts.
  • The reported appearance, synchronization, and landmark gains support practical value; the audio-student distillation diagram also supplies a plausible route for using video-derived supervision at inference.
Critical weaknesses
  • The audio-conditioned mechanism needs more specification. Appendix C, Figure 7, does show audio entering a student and frames entering a teacher. However, it does not define the audio encoding or how student features replace frame-dependent inputs to the eight modules. How this route relates to the full versus lightweight models in the results is also unclear. This is an incomplete specification, not an absence of any proposed audio-to-feature route.
  • The geometric meaning of depth remains underjustified. Equations 7, 10, and 12 constrain temporal changes and smoothness, but do not identify a geometric depth target or prior. Constant depth/weights can satisfy the first two regularizers. Qualitative depth comparisons in Figure 4 are encouraging, yet the manuscript should explain what anchors depth rather than a generic useful latent feature. This does not establish actual training collapse.
  • Area stability provides weaker geometric coordination than the framing suggests. Equation 21 compares only total binary-mask areas: displaced or differently shaped masks can incur zero loss. The construction and gradient path of generated-frame masks also require clarification.
Questions for authors
  • What is the complete audio-student computation, how are its outputs connected to Gaussian offsets, and which inference route is used for the main full-model results?
  • What geometric supervision/prior anchors depth, and how are generated-frame motion masks differentiated when optimizing Eq. 21?
Reviewer_HHrqOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a cross-region geometric representation framework for audio-driven talking-portrait generation with 3D Gaussian Splatting (3DGS). It combines a Global Motion Depth Representation (GMDR) for foreground–background structure with a Local Motion Multi-Scale Representation (LMMR) for region-specific motion. Their features predict offsets to Gaussian positions, scales, and rotations. The paper reports improvements over six baselines, along with ablations, efficiency experiments, a lightweight model, and a short-video study.

Critical strengths
  • The paper targets an important problem: temporal and cross-region consistency in talking-head generation.
  • The global/local decomposition is intuitively reasonable.
Critical weaknesses

1. The inference-time pipeline is undefined

Section 2 states that inference takes an audio clip as input, yet both modules are defined on video frames: GMDR needs frame differences ∣It−It−1∣|I_t-I_{t-1}| and video-derived motion masks, and LMMR uses a temporal window spanning t−Kt-K to t+Kt+K, including future frames. How GdepthG_{\text{depth}} and GscaleG_{\text{scale}} are obtained at audio-only inference is never explained. The modules might run on ground-truth frames during training, generated frames at test time, audio features, or identity-specific learned features, but the paper does not say which. Equation (120),

{It}t=1T→{Gdepth,Gscale}→ΔG→Gnew,\{I_t\}_{t=1}^{T}\rightarrow \{G_{\text{depth}},G_{\text{scale}}\}\rightarrow \Delta G\rightarrow G_{\text{new}},

does not specify how audio drives this chain, and the claim in Section B.18 that the learned representations provide the conditions for audio-driven generation does not resolve the ambiguity.

2. The base audio-to-Gaussian model is missing

The paper defines

ΔG=Foffset(Gdepth,Gscale)\Delta G = F_{\text{offset}}(G_{\text{depth}},G_{\text{scale}})

and applies it to Gaussian geometry, but the underlying talking-head model is not described. Undocumented components include the audio encoder and audio-to-motion mapping, canonical Gaussian initialization, treatment of head, torso, and background, the association between features and Gaussian primitives, the rendering or photometric loss, and the full end-to-end objective. Equation (116) combines only the GMDR and LMMR losses; no reconstruction, rendering, or audio-synchronization term is given.

3. The geometric claim is not directly validated

Improved geometric fidelity is the headline claim, but the evaluation reports image, lip-sync, landmark, identity, and speed metrics only. There is no quantitative measurement of depth or 3D geometry error, foreground–background boundary quality, temporal warping, flicker, or cross-region correspondence, and the depth maps in Figure 4 have no ground truth. Since the method modifies only centers, scales, and rotations while leaving color and opacity fixed, the paper should also explain how geometry-only offsets produce the reported PSNR gain, and should supply metrics that test the geometric claim directly.

4. The core loss functions are mathematically problematic

Depth consistency. Equation (7) uses 1−∇Zt1-\nabla Z_t even though ∇Zt\nabla Z_t is a two-dimensional vector; the appendix later switches to its magnitude, leaving the main equation inconsistent. The stated intent—lower weights where depth gradients are large—is not clearly realized by the written L1L_1 form. More fundamentally, FdepthF_{\text{depth}} receives no depth supervision or pretrained depth prior, and temporal smoothness alone is satisfied by a temporally constant depth map.

Alignment loss. Equation (21),

Lalignment=∑t∣∥Maskt∥1−∥Maskt−1∥1∣,L_{\text{alignment}} = \sum_t \left|\|Mask_t\|_1-\|Mask_{t-1}\|_1\right|,

penalizes changes in the area of a binary motion mask. It establishes no correspondence between regions; it only keeps their areas similar, and it can penalize legitimate motion such as mouth opening or head rotation. The binary mask is also non-differentiable as written, with no approximation described.

Fusion and notation. Equation (11) describes additive fusion while the text and Equation (60) use concatenation. ϕ\phi denotes both a lightweight feature extractor and a pretrained encoder. Finally, M(depth)=∣Zt−Zt−1∣M(\text{depth})=|Z_t-Z_{t-1}| is a temporal depth-change map, not a depth distribution.

Questions for authors
  1. What exactly is available at inference time? Please provide a complete audio-to-Gaussian computation graph, including whether GMDR and LMMR operate on generated frames, audio features, training frames, or identity-specific learned features.
  2. What are the audio encoder, canonical Gaussian initialization, feature-to-Gaussian association, and the image reconstruction, rendering, and audio-synchronization objectives? Please state the full end-to-end training loss.
  3. Can the authors provide geometry- and temporal-consistency metrics with ground-truth depth or documented proxies, rather than only image-level and lip-sync metrics?
  4. What supervises FdepthF_{\text{depth}} in the absence of depth labels or a pretrained depth prior, and why does the written depth loss not simply admit a constant depth map?
  5. Why does the mask-area loss count as alignment, how is it made differentiable, and how does it avoid penalizing legitimate mouth or head motion?
Reviewer_npU2OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes a 3DGS-based talking portrait framework combining Global Motion Depth Representation (GMDR) and Local Motion Multi-scale Representation (LMMR) to predict Gaussian geometric offsets. It reports improved image fidelity, lip synchronization, and rendering speed, with a distilled lightweight variant reaching 135 FPS.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper addresses practically important boundary distortions and regional motion inconsistencies through complementary global-depth and local multi-scale representations.

  2. The reported results show substantial gains over the evaluated baselines, including PSNR of 33.324 versus 30.816 for GaussianTalker (Table 1), while the distilled variant reports nearly unchanged quality at 135 FPS (Table 3).

Critical weaknesses
  1. The core method is insufficiently specified: GMDR and LMMR require video-frame features, including a centered temporal window, but the audio-only inference path is not defined, depth supervision is unspecified, and Eq. (21) constrains only mask area rather than spatial alignment, with no explanation of differentiability through its binary mask.
  2. How does audio produce the representations needed by GMDR/LMMR at inference, without access to target video frames, and how are these features mapped to individual Gaussian offsets?
  3. What supervision prevents constant-depth solutions, and how does the binary-mask area loss in Eq. (21) provide differentiable gradients and detect equal-area but spatially misaligned regions?
  4. How many identities and test clips underlie Tables 1–2, what are the train/test splits, and can you report direct geometric or boundary-consistency measurements alongside uncertainty estimates?
  5. How does the method compare with TalkingGaussian, which already separates face and mouth motion, and with InsTaG under the same 10-second personalization budget?
Questions for authors

see weakness

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.