- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3(+1)
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3(+1)
- Soundness
- 3(+1)
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GDAvatar, a monocular Gaussian head avatar framework that progressively allocates Gaussian degrees of freedom. It first optimizes personalized canonical geometry using constrained vertex-bound Gaussians, then models dynamic appearance using triangle-bound Gaussians and a geometry-conditioned UV offset branch, and finally constructs a continuous UV representation for appearance editing.
Critical strengths
The motivation and overall pipeline are clear and intuitive. The method achieves consistently strong reconstruction results across the evaluated datasets. The ablations cover most major components and generally support the proposed design.
Critical weaknesses
The methodological novelty appears somewhat limited. The main contribution is the progressive restriction and release of Gaussian degrees of freedom, which is intuitive and effective, but appears closer to a carefully designed staged optimization strategy than a fundamentally new representation or modeling principle.
The central geometry–appearance separation claim is only indirectly validated. Since the evaluated datasets do not provide ground-truth geometry, improved rendering quality does not necessarily demonstrate that the recovered canonical geometry is more accurate or that geometry and dynamic appearance are better disentangled.
The editing capability is mainly demonstrated qualitatively, with limited quantitative evaluation of editing quality, consistency across expressions/poses, or preservation of unedited regions.
Questions for authors
How can the authors verify that progressive optimization actually improves canonical geometry, rather than simply finding a different geometry–appearance decomposition that achieves better rendering quality?
To what extent should progressive DoF allocation be viewed as a general modeling principle rather than a task-specific staged optimization strategy? Is the benefit primarily due to the representation design or simply the optimization schedule?
Why is the canonical geometry completely frozen in Stage B? Would allowing small learning-rate geometry refinement after releasing the appearance DoFs provide a better trade-off?
To my knowledge, some prior works have also explored structured or topology-aware constraints on Gaussian attributes (e.g., TAvatar[1]); would the authors consider citing it?
Can the authors provide quantitative evaluation of the editing capability, especially consistency across different expressions or poses and preservation of regions that are not edited?
[1]Tavatar: Topology-Aware Gaussian Attribute Derivation for Animatable Human Avatars, cvpr, 2026
3 comments
Response to Reviewer xAyJ (Part 2)
Q4: Related Work TAvatar.
Ans: Thank you for pointing out this relevant work. TAvatar analytically derives Gaussian attributes from mesh topology to maintain surface consistency under novel poses. In contrast, our method progressively separates identity-specific geometry from expression-dependent appearance and learns geometry-conditioned Gaussian attribute offsets for fine-grained facial dynamics. We have added TAvatar to the Related Work section.
Q5: Evaluation of Editing Capability.
Ans: Thank you for your suggestion. In Stage C (Editable Gaussian Map Construction), Gaussian attributes are represented by continuous UV attribute maps. Since all frames share the same UV coordinate space, sticker editing maintains consistent facial correspondence across different expressions and poses. Moreover, editing modifies only the selected UV region, leaving attributes outside this region unchanged. As stickers occupy only a small region, the reconstruction quality of unedited regions is expected to remain comparable to the full-face results. In Table 8 of the original manuscript (Page 18), we demonstrated the face reconstruction quality across different expressions and poses compared to GT images; the results indicate that this editable representation maintains high-quality reconstruction.
Thanks for the clarification! The authors have addressed all my concerns. I will maintain my Weak Accept rating.
Response to Reviewer xAyJ (Part 1)
Thank you for your valuable comments. We have addressed the concerns through methodological novelty clarification, quantitative geometry evaluation, geometry freezing ablation and editing consistency clarification.
Q1: Explain on Methodological Novelty.
Ans: Our contribution goes beyond a conventional staged optimization strategy by explicitly separating identity-specific geometry from expression-dependent appearance variations through progressive Gaussian DoF allocation. Unlike conventional staged optimization, which primarily changes when parameters are optimized, our method controls what the representation can model at each stage. Stage A restricts Gaussian DoFs to recover personalized canonical geometry, while Stage B releases dynamic appearance DoFs on the fixed geometric basis.
As shown in Table 4, Joint Optimization, which optimizes geometry and appearance simultaneously without progressive DoF allocation, yields inferior results, demonstrating the benefit of explicitly separating their optimization. Furthermore, GeoRefine, which continues updating geometry in Stage B, also degrades performance, suggesting that geometry changes interfere with learning stable UV-space Gaussian attribute offsets. These findings support progressive DoF allocation as a representation-level modeling principle rather than merely an optimization schedule.
Table4: Ablation study of Progressive DoF Allocation on the INSTA dataset.
\small \begin{array}{lccc} \hline \text{Method} & \text{PSNR}\uparrow & \text{SSIM}\uparrow & \text{LPIPS}\downarrow \\\\ \hline \text{w/ Joint Optimization} & 30.476 & 0.951 & 0.058 \\\\ \text{w/ GeoRefine in Stage B} & 30.892 & 0.956 & 0.052 \\\\ \hline \mathbf{Full\\ Model} & \mathbf{31.431} & \mathbf{0.960} & \mathbf{0.043} \\\\ \hline \end{array} }$$ **Q2. Verify Geometry Quality.** **Ans:** To verify that progressive optimization improves canonical geometry rather than merely rendering quality, we introduce additional geometric evaluations. On INSTA, which lacks ground-truth 3D geometry, we evaluate reconstructed mesh silhouettes using Silhouette IoU and Boundary Chamfer Distance. Our method (0.851↑ / 23.914 px↓) outperforms Template and VHAP as shown in **Table 2** (Page 8). More importantly, on H3DS with ground-truth 3D meshes, our method achieves the best L1-Chamfer Distance and Normal Consistency (0.836×10⁻²↓ / 0.809↑) across 10 subjects, as reported in **Figure 11** and **Table 5** (Page 17) of the supplementary material. These results demonstrate improved geometric accuracy beyond rendering quality. **Table2: Quantitative geometry evaluation on the INSTA dataset.** $${ \small \begin{array}{lcc} \hline \text{Method} & \text{Silhouette IoU}\uparrow & \text{Boundary Chamfer (px)}\downarrow \\\\ \hline \text{Template} & 0.785 & 26.937 \\\\ \text{VHAP} & 0.819 & 24.572 \\\\ \hline \mathbf{Ours} & \mathbf{0.851} & \mathbf{23.914} \\\\ \hline \end{array} }$$ **Table5: Quantitative geometry evaluation on the H3DS dataset.** $${ \small \begin{array}{lcc} \hline \text{Method} & \text{L1-Chamfer}\downarrow & \text{N. C.}\uparrow \\\\ \hline \text{Template} & 0.979\times 10^{-2} & 0.776 \\\\ \text{VHAP} & 0.940\times 10^{-2} & 0.780 \\\\ \hline \mathbf{Ours} & \mathbf{0.836\times 10^{-2}} & \mathbf{0.809} \\\\ \hline \end{array} }$$ **Q3: Geometry Freezing in Stage B.** **Ans:** Freezing canonical geometry in Stage B provides a stable geometric basis for learning UV-space Gaussian attribute offsets. Further geometry refinement would continuously change this basis, interfering with dynamic appearance learning. To validate this choice, we evaluate GeoRefine, which allows continued geometry refinement in Stage B. As shown in **Table 4**, **GeoRefine** (30.892 / 0.956 / 0.052) underperforms our full model (31.431 / 0.960 / 0.043) in PSNR / SSIM / LPIPS. These results indicate that maintaining fixed geometry during Stage B is more beneficial than continued geometry refinement.