- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In order to build a general "pattern machine" for IMTS data, HeteroNet is proposed, which introduce a set of modules focusing on addressing irregularity within series. Extensive experiements domenstrate the competitive performance of the proposed method.
Critical strengths
- Extensive experiments: although existing papers mostly focus on classification and forecasting tasks on IMTS, while the true meaning of the rest tasks remain less verified in real-world scenarios, it is undeniable that the experiment is very comprehensive.
Critical weaknesses
- It is questionable whether "pattern machine" is reasonable in terms of IMTS. The word rarely appears in time series researches, and the most closely related method would be TimeMixer++. However, the assumptions in TimeMixer++ hold due to extensive studies for regularly sampled time series, but whether tasks like imputation, temporal point process, and generation have correspoding real-world applications are questionable. For example, for the most widely studied IMTS dataset MIMIC, each IMTS sample represents the clinical records from the patient's ICU stay. In this case, what's the point of generating a fake IMTS series or imputing it? For generation, no real patient actual correspond to that fake series. For imputation, irregularity itself carry sampling density information reflecting the patient's disease progression.
- The contributin of this paper lies in extensive experiment, rather than any technical novelty. Designing a "general pattern machine" in IMTS is not as simple as accounting for irregularity within a dataset, but also irregularity among different datasets that may be caused by different reasons. Furthermore, the method in this paper is mostly a stacking of existing components, and it's unclear why these modules are chosen other than the rest.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
Thank you for the detailed response and the new experiments. Some concerns remain.
Other concerns are resolved.