- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GeoGCD, a method for Generalized Category Discovery (GCD) in histopathological images. Building upon the semi-supervised learning framework of SimGCD, the authors introduce two modules: FDRA and AMPA. FDRA generates channel-gating mechanisms from the high-frequency components of features and integrates fine-grained details with global information via cross-attention. AMPA establishes adaptive classification margins for labeled samples by calculating the cosine similarity between each class prototype and its nearest neighboring prototype. Experiments conducted on the LC25000, BreakHis, and BACH datasets demonstrate that GeoGCD outperforms SimGCD.
Critical strengths
-
The use of high-frequency information in FDRA to modulate raw features is an intriguing concept.
-
AMPA’s approach, determining margins based on the nearest competing class, is a logical strategy for addressing local inter-class confusion.
-
According to the reported metrics, the full model shows improvements in overall, known-class, and novel-class accuracy, suggesting that the combined modules may enhance the balance between these two objectives.
Critical weaknesses
-
The criteria for matching (used in evaluation) are not clearly defined. In Table 1, the results for GeoGCD on the LC25000 dataset are: All=72.6, Seen=76.1, and Novel=97.7; for BreakHis, they are 67.2, 81.9, and 69.0, respectively. In both cases, the "All" (overall) accuracy is lower than the accuracy for each individual subset. The paper mentions the use of Hungarian matching but fails to explain how the matching process is handled across these three metrics. If these metrics are calculated based on the same evaluation set and a single global matching assignment, the overall accuracy should not be lower than the accuracy of both subsets. The authors should provide the grouped results and confusion matrices derived from a consistent global matching.
-
The paper lacks sufficient detail and often reads like a mere list of formulas, making the overall line of reasoning unclear. Furthermore, there is no supplementary material to clarify points left ambiguous in the main text (which, while not strictly mandatory, is problematic given that the main text itself is not sufficiently detailed). The quality of the figures is also mediocre.
-
The current ablation studies only demonstrate that performance changes when the modules are added, they do not establish whether these two core designs are truly indispensable. The paper lacks further analysis to address this gap. Figure 6 reports overall intra-class and inter-class distances, however, it lacks a precise definition of these distances, fails to specify the datasets used, and does not provide a breakdown for "known-known," "known-new," and "new-new" class pairs. Consequently, it is impossible to determine which specific aspects of the geometric structure have improved. Furthermore, the overall performance gains are marginal: the complete model shows improvements of only 0.3, 0.8, and 0.3 percentage points over the baseline. Meanwhile, the addition of FDRA alone causes the overall accuracy to drop from 72.3% to 71.6% on the LC dataset, and from 73.8% to 72.1% on the BACH dataset. While the authors highlight improvements in metrics for new classes, they fail to adequately address the implications of the decline in overall performance.
-
The experimental details are also insufficient. The experimental section merely states that a standard GCD (Generalized Category Discovery) protocol is followed, but it fails to systematically specify the lists of known and new classes for each dataset, the labeling ratios, the sample sizes for each subset, or the methodology for repeating class splits. Moreover, it remains unclear whether the evaluation is conducted on unlabeled data already encountered during training, or on entirely independent samples or patients.
Questions for authors
See "Critical Weaknesses".
And please check the format of citation, there may be something wrong.