- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FusedBFN, a zero-shot framework for dual-target molecular generation that reuses a pretrained single-target Bayesian Flow Network and combines target-specific information through a weighted Product of Experts (wPoE). The authors further introduce CompBFN and FusedDiff to compare distribution fusion with transition-kernel composition across Bayesian flow and diffusion frameworks. They also investigate the effects of sampling covariance and pocket alignment on generation performance.
Critical strengths
- The problem is practically relevant, and the proposed setting is well motivated. The scarcity of structural data for dual-target ligands makes training dedicated generative models difficult. Reusing pretrained single-target models without additional training or fine-tuning provides a practical approach to incorporating information from both binding pockets.
- The analysis of probabilistic composition mechanisms offers useful insights. Through FusedBFN, CompBFN, FusedDiff, and CompDiff, the paper examines how distribution fusion and transition-kernel composition behave under different generative frameworks. The equivalence analysis under matched parameter settings, together with controlled experiments on sampling covariance, helps clarify which factors contribute to the observed improvements.
- The experimental evaluation is broad and includes complementary assessments. The benchmark contains 12,917 target pairs. In addition to AutoDock Vina scores, the authors report GNINA-based evaluations, conformational strain energy, steric clashes, and molecular properties. Ablations on alignment strategies, fusion weights, and sampling covariance, together with statistical analyses accounting for repeated targets, provide complementary evidence for the main findings.
Critical weaknesses
1 The handling of incompatible target pairs remains unclear Appendix F.5 analyzes disagreement between the two target-conditioned experts and presents two examples in which retaining moderate sampling noise performs better than deterministic sampling. However, this does not establish whether both pockets admit a feasible ligand. Under specified constraints on molecular size, chemical validity, and binding affinity, could the requirements of the two pockets be sufficiently incompatible that no molecule satisfies both? How would the current method identify and handle such cases? Could fusion still produce compromise molecules that bind poorly to both targets? A controlled evaluation of incompatible cases, together with an analysis of the relationship between expert disagreement and dual-target generation success, would help clarify the method’s applicability.
2 The efficiency advantage over single target generation followed by docking based filtering has not been established Appendix F.11 and Table 21 report generation times of 113.68 seconds for FusedBFN, 57.27 seconds for MolCRAFT, and 1128.40 seconds for DualDiff when generating 10 molecules. These results demonstrate a generation-speed advantage over DualDiff, but they do not establish an advantage over generating candidates for one target and subsequently filtering them using Vina docking scores against the second target. The fixed-sample comparison with single-target models in Table 2 does not replace this comparison. Please compare the two pipelines under an equal computational budget or at the same number of qualifying dual-target candidates, including the costs of probe-ligand generation, pocket alignment, docking, and filtering. This would clarify whether joint generation reduces end-to-end runtime or computational resource requirements.
3 The alignment ablations do not fully address sensitivity to the initial alignment or the search for an optimal alignment Table 5 compares several alignment strategies, and Appendix F.2 shows that probe-ligand selection affects generation performance. Nevertheless, the alignment that maximizes geometric overlap or minimizes probe-ligand registration error may not maximize downstream generation quality. The current method treats alignment as fixed preprocessing and does not search over or update the relative rigid-body transformation between the pockets during generation. Could the authors compare multiple candidate alignments for the same target pair, examine the relationship between registration quality and generation performance, and assess sensitivity to initial rotations, translations, and probe-ligand selection? Can the model itself explore a more suitable alignment based on the generation objective?
4 It remains unclear whether the generated conformation satisfies the steric constraints of both pockets under the original alignment Appendix F.8 reports steric-clash and conformation metrics, but it should be clarified whether these results directly assess the original shared conformation produced during generation. Specifically, if the generated ligand coordinates and the pocket alignment used for generation are preserved, does the ligand exhibit substantial steric clashes with either pocket when each ligand–pocket configuration is evaluated separately? If severe clashes remain, would this indicate that the joint constraints were not adequately satisfied during generation, despite both pockets being provided as conditioning inputs? Independent re-docking can alleviate clashes by changing the ligand’s position or conformation, so favorable docking scores may not directly demonstrate compatibility of the original generated conformation with both pockets. Please report the fraction of original generated conformations exhibiting clashes with each pocket and the fraction passing steric-clash checks for both pockets, alongside the corresponding results after optimization or re-docking.
Questions for authors
The questions were provided in the Critical Weaknesses section.
7 comments
Response to Reviewer 9Gx2 - W2
W2: The efficiency advantage over single target generation followed by docking based filtering has not been established.
A to W2: We thank the reviewer for raising this important concern. To address this, we conduct an additional pipeline-level comparison between (i) single-target generation using MolCRAFT followed by dual-target docking-based filtering and (ii) FusedBFN with the complete probe-preparation, dual-target generation, docking, and filtering procedure. Both pipelines are evaluated on the same set of 1,000 randomly selected target pairs.
For both pipelines, a molecule is considered qualifying if its Vina Dock scores against both targets are better than those of their respective reference ligands. We deduplicate the qualifying molecules within each target pair using canonical isomeric SMILES, preserving stereochemical differences. Both pipelines are evaluated under identical computational resources and runtime settings. Molecule generation is performed on one TITAN Xp GPU per target pair. Docking is performed on 64-core CPU nodes, with 16 CPU cores and 8 GB of memory allocated to each target pair. All remaining stages run on a single CPU core. We report the time required by each stage below.
| Stage | MolCRAFT + Filtering (s) | FusedBFN (s) |
|---|---|---|
| Probe-ligand preparation and pocket alignment | – | 22,551 |
| Molecule generation | 16,091 | 99,270 |
| Vina docking against P-1 | 1,131 | 2,190 |
| Vina docking against P-2 | 4,360 | 1,922 |
| Filtering | 13.78 | 13.83 |
| Total runtime | 21,595.78 | 125,946.83 |
The resulting numbers of unique qualifying molecules and their coverage across target pairs are summarized below.
| Metric | MolCRAFT + Filtering | FusedBFN |
|---|---|---|
| Qualifying molecule rate | 32.96% | 41.78% |
| Runtime per qualifying molecule (s) | 7.66 | 35.22 |
| Proportion with ≥1 qualifying molecule | 71.85% | 79.67% |
| Proportion with ≥3 qualifying molecules | 52.22% | 61.10% |
| Proportion with ≥5 qualifying molecules | 35.05% | 44.51% |
The improvement of FusedBFN is most pronounced under the stricter requirement of ≥5 qualifying molecules per target pair, where coverage increases from 35.05% to 44.51%. FusedBFN requires 35.22 seconds per qualifying molecule, compared with 7.66 seconds for MolCRAFT followed by filtering. However, the results on incompatible target pairs in A to W1 demonstrate that FusedBFN can explore shared feasible regions that the MolCRAFT pipeline fails to identify. Computational efficiency is meaningful only when a method can successfully find valid solutions. Although FusedBFN incurs a higher computational cost, it can generate feasible molecules that single-target pipeline cannot discover. Therefore, FusedBFN offers substantial practical value despite its higher computational cost.
Response to Reviewer 9Gx2 - W3
W3: The alignment ablations do not fully address sensitivity to the initial alignment or the search for an optimal alignment.
A to W3: We thank the reviewer for this suggestion. We clarify that Table 5 already compares different alignment strategies on the same 1,000 target pairs, with Lig-ChemPrior achieving the best generation performance. Surface-RI serves as a practical alternative when a probe ligand is difficult to obtain or when a simpler alignment pipeline is preferred. To examine sensitivity to initial alignment and the relationship between registration quality and generation performance, we conduct additional experiments on 200 target pairs, evaluating variant alignments for each pair while keeping the generation settings unchanged.
Starting from the original chemically weighted alignment, we apply relative rotations of 10° and 20°, relative translations of 2 Å and 4 Å, and an alternative alignment obtained using an unrelated probe ligand. The original alignment achieves the best overall binding performance. Small rotations cause limited degradation, while translation perturbations have a more pronounced effect. Using an unrelated probe ligand further reduces performance. Meanwhile, QED, SA, and Diversity remain relatively stable across these settings. These results demonstrate that FusedBFN tolerates moderate alignment perturbations, although larger deviations and inappropriate probe selection can compromise dual-target binding performance.
| Alignment | P-1 Vina Dock ↓ | P-2 Vina Dock ↓ | Max Vina Dock ↓ | Dual High Aff. ↑ | QED ↑ | SA ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Original | -8.76 | -8.79 | -8.10 | 52.9% | 0.54 | 0.67 |
| Rotation 10° | -8.75 | -8.78 | -8.07 | 52.3% | 0.54 | 0.68 |
| Rotation 20° | -8.66 | -8.76 | -7.98 | 52.0% | 0.54 | 0.68 |
| Translation 2 Å | -8.71 | -8.63 | -7.99 | 53.2% | 0.54 | 0.68 |
| Translation 4 Å | -8.53 | -8.56 | -7.86 | 50.0% | 0.55 | 0.69 |
| Wrong Probe | -8.58 | -8.57 | -7.89 | 49.2% | 0.55 | 0.70 |
We further quantify registration quality using the nearest-neighbor RMSD between the two aligned pockets. We compute the Spearman correlation between RMSD and Max Vina Dock, obtaining a mean correlation of 0.197 (). This suggests that poorer geometric alignment tends to be associated with weaker binding performance. In FusedBFN, the relative transformation is determined during preprocessing and remains fixed throughout sampling. An interesting extension would be to search over candidate relative transformations using a generation-aware objective that jointly considers dual-target binding and molecular quality, which is a promising direction for future work.
Response to Reviewer 9Gx2 - W1
W1: The handling of incompatible target pairs remains unclear.
A to W1: We thank the reviewer for this valuable suggestion. To clarify the applicability of FusedBFN to potentially incompatible target pairs, we conduct two additional analyses: (1) examining the relationship between expert disagreement and dual-target generation performance, and (2) evaluating FusedBFN on challenging target pairs for which single-target generation fails to identify a shared feasible ligand.
Relationship between disagreement and generation performance. We evaluate 1,000 target pairs and compute the coordinate disagreement score Dpairx and categorical conflict score Cpairv, as defined in Appendix F.5. For each target pair, we calculate mean Max Vina Dock and Dual High Affinity (DHA), and examine their relationships with the two disagreement measures using Spearman correlation. Both disagreement measures show statistically significant correlations, indicating that stronger expert disagreement is associated with less favorable binding to the target.
For each target pair p, we further compute Δp=MaxDockp(c=0.25)−MaxDockp(c=0), where MaxDockp denotes the average Max Vine Dock score across generated molecules. A negative Δp indicates better performance with c=0.25. We then calculate Spearman correlations between Δp and two disagreement measures. Both measures exhibit significant negative correlations with Δp. This suggests that moderately increasing the sampling variance can improve generation performance on target pairs with greater expert disagreement.
Performance on potentially incompatible target pairs. To investigate whether FusedBFN can generate feasible dual-target ligands when the two targets are incompatible, we construct a candidate pool L from molecules generated by single-target model MolCRAFT. For each target pair, we define the feasible candidate sets: Fj={m∈L:Ej(m)≤Tj, m is valid and satisfies the molecular size constraint}, where Ej(m) denotes the Vina Dock score of molecule m against target j, and Tj is the Vina Dock score of the corresponding reference ligand. The molecular size constraint is defined using the size range of the reference ligands in the test set. Across all target pairs in the test set, we identify 260 challenging pairs satisfying
$\mathcal F_1\neq\varnothing,\qquad \mathcal F_2\neq\varnothing,\qquad \mathcal F_1\cap\mathcal F_2=\varnothing.$
For these pairs, the candidate pool contains feasible molecules for each target, but no molecule simultaneously satisfies the constraints for both targets. The two conflicting cases in Appendix F.5 are among the 260 pairs. We then evaluate FusedBFN on these 260 pairs under the same chemical validity, molecular size, and binding affinity constraints. A target pair is considered successfully addressed if at least one generated molecule satisfies the constraints for both targets simultaneously. FusedBFN achieves a success rate of 58.85%, demonstrating its ability to discover shared feasible candidates even when the two targets are incompatible under independent single-target generation.
Overall, expert disagreement is associated with reduced dual-target performance, while moderately increasing sampling variance can partially mitigate this effect for pairs with greater disagreement. More importantly, FusedBFN can discover shared feasible candidates for incompatible target pairs, highlighting its broad applicability to challenging dual-target molecular design.