- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GeoForward, a geometry-guided feedforward 3D Gaussian reconstruction framework for autonomous driving scenes. It combines LiDAR-based cross-view projection, learned local feature refinement, VGGT representations, separate depth and Gaussian prediction, and sparse 3D attribute refinement. Experiments on nuScenes and Waymo report strong geometric reconstruction performance.
Critical strengths
The paper addresses an important problem in geometrically consistent feedforward 3D reconstruction, and the use of metric observations to guide cross-view feature alignment is well motivated.
The method achieves encouraging geometric accuracy on multiple driving-scene datasets, and the evaluation includes several reconstruction and cross-view consistency metrics.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited methodological novelty. The central alignment mechanism mainly combines calibrated LiDAR projection with conventional learned local feature refinement. Other components, including VGGT feature fusion, Gaussian prediction, sparse 3D convolution, and temporal composition, largely follow established approaches. The claimed new reconstruction paradigm is therefore not sufficiently distinguished from prior LiDAR-guided multi-view reconstruction methods.
-
Potentially unfair comparisons and insufficient ablations. The proposed method uses sparse LiDAR and calibrated cameras at inference, as well as offline dense metric-depth supervision during training. Several competing methods operate under different input and supervision settings. Moreover, the current ablations do not adequately isolate the contributions of geometric projection, local correspondence refinement, LiDAR-token conditioning, and sparse 3D attribute refinement.
-
Inconsistencies in the reported training methodology. Appendix A.6 explicitly states that the temporal reprojection loss provides no gradient to the model, although the main text presents it as an effective temporal consistency constraint. The checkpoint initialization descriptions for nuScenes and Waymo also require clarification. These issues weaken confidence in the reproducibility and interpretation of the results.
Questions for authors
Can the authors provide input- and supervision-matched comparisons against existing LiDAR-guided reconstruction approaches, along with independent ablations of the major modules?
Why is the temporal reprojection loss included as a training objective when the implementation provides no gradient through this term? What is the exact checkpoint training sequence across nuScenes and Waymo?
Could the authors report results on the complete validation sets and provide inference time, memory consumption, and separate evaluation of dynamic regions? It would also be useful to report rendering quality before the endpoint-specific color calibration.