- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
InfiniSplat v2 studies Gaussian attribute learning on top of a pretrained geometry model. It uses a frozen DA3 branch for depth and camera prediction and a separate, partially fine-tuned branch for Gaussian attributes. Gaussian centers remain fixed, while training uses scale-aligned ground-truth cameras and target sampling biased toward larger viewing-direction differences. An optional learned refiner updates attributes using input-view rendering gradients. The same model is evaluated on six datasets in pose-conditioned and pose-free settings, with substantial improvements in mean LPIPS and DISTS. The paper also analyzes the relationship between learned opacity and geometric inconsistency.
Critical strengths
-
Substantial perceptual improvements across multiple settings. Table 1 reports clear improvements over the strongest corresponding baselines across six datasets. The feed-forward output reduces mean LPIPS and DISTS by 25.8% and 32.9% in the pose-conditioned setting, with substantial gains also observed without pose inputs. The same trained model supports both settings, and the main improvements do not depend on refinement.
-
A useful design supported by controlled ablations. Table 2 and Appendix B.2 isolate attribute-backbone adaptation, geometry freezing, positional offsets, camera handling, and target-view sampling while retaining the other training settings. In particular, the frozen-attribute-backbone control provides a meaningful matched-training comparison. These experiments support the practical value of preserving the geometric prior while adapting Gaussian attributes.
Critical weaknesses
-
The evaluation protocol is not sufficiently specified to verify the comparisons. The paper does not clearly report the evaluated scene and example counts, exact splits and view-selection procedure, input/rendering/scoring resolutions, or baseline checkpoints and configurations. The source and coverage of the evaluation valid regions also need clarification. The training resolutions in Appendix A.1 and latency resolutions in Table 9 do not establish the settings used for the main comparisons. These omissions limit reproducibility and confidence in the reported margins. The practical cost is also incompletely characterized: Table 9 measures neural-module latency rather than complete reconstruction and refinement time.
-
The analysis supports an effective recipe more strongly than it supports the proposed mechanisms. The geometry and offset ablations demonstrate worse rendering metrics under the chosen training setup, but quantitative geometric errors are needed to substantiate the interpretation that position updates compensate for attribute errors. The large-angle explanation is also under-tested. Equation (5) measures optical-axis differences, which need not correspond to increased parallax or different observation rays for the same surface. Figure 8 shows a mean angle increase from 12.34° to 17.97°, but no evaluation stratified by actual baseline or viewing difficulty is provided. This limits the strength of the paper’s analytical contribution and its claims about extreme viewpoints.
Questions for authors
-
Evaluation clarification: Please specify the evaluated scenes and example counts, context/target sampling, input/rendering/scoring resolutions, baseline checkpoints and configurations, and evaluation-mask construction. Are the different input-view counts evaluated on fixed targets with nested context sets?
-
Evidence for the interpretation: Using the existing evaluation scenes and ablated models, could you report quantitative geometry errors for the full model, w/o G, and w/ O, together with novel-view performance grouped by translation baseline or common-surface viewing-ray angle? This would help distinguish the proposed geometric explanation from other training effects and establish where the sampling strategy provides its gains.
-
Computational cost: Please report complete reconstruction latency, peak memory, Gaussian counts, and the additional cost of the three-step refiner, with comparisons to the main baselines under compatible hardware and resolution settings.