- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes LocusGS, a query-based feed-forward 3DGS method that augments each Gaussian query with an explicit 3D anchor (a center and a radius). The anchor is refined across decoder layers and guides query interaction and cross-view feature aggregation. Each query's Gaussians are then decoded as local offsets around its anchor. Experiments on RE10K and DL3DV show improvements over TokenGS under matched budgets, supported by ablations and visualizations of the learned anchors.
Critical strengths
1. Consistent improvements under matched budgets
- LocusGS improves over TokenGS on both datasets, across different token budgets and numbers of input views. This suggests practical value for query-based feed-forward 3DGS.
2. A reasonable idea, clearly presented
- Giving each query an explicit 3D anchor is an intuitive and reasonable idea. The paper is well written and includes informative visualizations, which makes the method easy to understand and build upon.
Critical weaknesses
1. The motivating observation could be better supported
- The method is motivated by the observation that Gaussians from one latent query "often scatter across distant scene regions" (Abstract; Sec. 2.1.1). This is illustrated with a representative token (Fig. 1).
- However, the TokenGS paper reports that Gaussians from a single token "stay close to each other within a scene" (Sec. 4.5, Fig. 10). It would help to reconcile the two observations.
- The quantitative analysis (Sec. 3.3.3, Table 3) is helpful, but it may not fully support the claim:
- C_centroid is a mean distance pooled over all tokens and Gaussians in a scene. A small fraction of far-away, possibly near-transparent, Gaussians could therefore yield a large value even if most tokens are compact. As a result, the metric does not show how often tokens are dispersed.
- The lower dispersion of LocusGS is largely expected from its anchor-centered decoding (Eq. 9). The comparison alone therefore does not show that dispersion affects rendering quality.
- Why it matters: This observation is the main motivation for the anchor design. Without stronger support, it is unclear what explains the reported gains.
2. The main comparison may not isolate the effect of spatial grounding
- Table 5 shows that each anchor component matters within LocusGS. However, it does not include TokenGS, so it does not quantify the gain over the baseline.
- LocusGS also adds intermediate-layer supervision, which alone accounts for +0.74 dB (Table 4). This is of the same order as the reported gains over TokenGS.
- The TokenGS baseline does not appear to use this supervision. For example, the RE10K TokenGS results in Table 2 are identical to Table 1 of the TokenGS paper, and the TokenGS training objective (its Sec. 3.1) has no intermediate supervision.
- Why it matters: The ablations support the individual components. However, part of the improvement over TokenGS, which is the paper's main claim, may come from the added supervision. It therefore remains unclear how much of the gain is due to spatial grounding.
Questions for authors
- Novelty and positioning.
- The closest design I am aware of is UniQueR (ECCV'26). It also uses learnable queries with explicit 3D positions to decode Gaussians for scene-level feed-forward reconstruction. Could you clarify the key differences from it? Given its timing, I do not count its omission against the paper.
- Object-level methods such as UniGS (ICCV'25) and LeanGaussian (CVPR'25) also treat Gaussians as queries with explicit 3D positions. A brief discussion would help.
- Motivating observation (Weakness 1).
- Could you clarify whether the TokenGS used in Figs. 1 and 5 and Table 3 is the official checkpoint or a re-trained one? Fig. 9 and Table 1 suggest the latter. If it was re-trained, does the official checkpoint show similar dispersion?
- Could you report the distribution of per-token dispersion, weighted by opacity (e.g., the fraction of widely dispersed tokens)? If most tokens turn out to be compact, this would also reconcile Fig. 1 with TokenGS Sec. 4.5.
- Supervision (Weakness 2). Was TokenGS trained with the same intermediate supervision? Results for TokenGS trained with this supervision, in the Table 5 setting, would largely resolve this concern.
- Robustness and transfer. The anchor design relies on exact camera rays and on random initial anchors shared across scenes. Could you:
- evaluate robustness to pose noise using the TokenGS protocol (its Sec. 4.3);
- evaluate cross-dataset transfer (e.g., RE10K→ACID);
- report how far the anchors move from their initialization across layers?
[1] UniQueR: Unified Query-based Feedforward 3D Reconstruction. ECCV 2026.
[2] UniGS: Modeling Unitary 3D Gaussians for Novel View Synthesis from Sparse-view Images. ICCV 2025.
[3] LeanGaussian: Breaking Pixel or Point Cloud Correspondence in Modeling 3D Gaussians. CVPR 2025.
4 comments
Response to Reviewer dRN8 (Part 2 / 3)
Q2.2: Could you report the distribution of per-token dispersion, weighted by opacity (e.g., the fraction of widely dispersed tokens)? If most tokens turn out to be compact, this would also reconcile Fig. 1 with TokenGS Sec. 4.5.
A2.2: Thank you for this insightful suggestion. We agree that opacity is important when interpreting the spatial distribution of Gaussian groups.
| Method | Unweighted dispersion ↓ | Opacity-weighted dispersion ↓ |
|---|---|---|
| TokenGS | 0.5881 | 0.1603 |
| LocusGS | 0.0433 | 0.0436 |
These results reveal an important distinction: although TokenGS produces spatially scattered Gaussian centers, much of this dispersion is associated with low-opacity Gaussians. Thus, the compact token groups observed in TokenGS Sec.4.5 are not necessarily inconsistent with the scattered 3D centers shown in our Figure 1. Our original unweighted metric captures the distribution of all predicted centers, whereas opacity-weighted dispersion better reflects the concentration of Gaussians with greater rendering contributions.
We further illustrate this phenomenon in Figure 12, where query-colored Gaussian centers are overlaid on reference geometry, with close-up views highlighting off-surface outliers and local Gaussian organization. Together with the opacity-weighted statistics, these visualizations help clarify why scattered 3D centers can coexist with relatively compact token groups when opacity is taken into account. We really appreciate the reviewer for pointing out this important distinction.
Q3: Was TokenGS trained with the same intermediate supervision? Results for TokenGS trained with this supervision, in the Table 5 setting, would largely resolve this concern.
A3: Thank you for raising this important concern. In our original experiments, TokenGS uses only final-layer supervision, whereas LocusGS receives rendering supervision at layers 6 and 12. To make a fair comparison, we additionally trained TokenGS with the same layer-6/12 intermediate supervision under the same 4-view, 256×256 base setting.
| Method | Supervised Layers | PSNR ↑ | SSIM ↑ | LPIPS ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TokenGS | 12 | 21.315 | 0.6517 | 0.4238 |
| TokenGS + intermediate supervision | 6, 12 | 22.878 | 0.7242 | 0.3484 |
| LocusGS | 6, 12 | 24.284 | 0.7843 | 0.2709 |
As shown, intermediate supervision improves TokenGS by 1.563 dB. With supervision matched, LocusGS still achieves a 1.406 dB PSNR gain. This indicates that intermediate supervision explains part, but not all, of the improvement. We appreciate the reviewer for pointing out this important factor. These additional results help disentangle the contribution of intermediate supervision from that of our proposed spatial grounding.
Q4.1: Evaluate robustness to pose noise using the TokenGS protocol.
A4.1: Thank you for this suggestion. Following the pose-noise setting described in TokenGS, we evaluate two-view RE10K reconstruction by applying random-axis rotations of 1°–10° to the non-reference input camera, while keeping the reference and target cameras unchanged. We also include a noise-free baseline.
The accompanying PSNR curves in updated paper (Figure 10) show that both methods degrade as pose noise increases. LocusGS achieves 28.60 dB with clean poses, compared with 26.33 dB for TokenGS. At 1°, the results decrease to 22.93 versus 22.58 dB, and become close at larger perturbations. These results indicate that LocusGS retains competitive reconstruction quality under pose perturbations, but its substantial advantage with accurate poses narrows considerably. We therefore do not claim improved pose-noise robustness: the larger degradation relative to its clean-pose performance highlights the dependence of our explicit geometric guidance on reliable camera parameters. We appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion and include this evaluation and limitation in the revision.
Q4.2: Evaluate cross-dataset transfer (e.g., RE10K→ACID).
A4.2: Thank you for this suggestion. We have conducted an additional RE10K→ACID cross-dataset evaluation, directly applying models trained on RE10K to a fixed subset of ACID test scenes. Both methods use the same two input views and three target views per scene, identical preprocessing at resolution, and the same budget of 65,536 Gaussians.
| Method | PSNR ↑ | SSIM ↑ | LPIPS ↓ | Token-level Gaussian dispersion ↓ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| TokenGS | 26.4362 | 0.7983 | 0.3205 | 5.7741 |
| LocusGS | 28.0567 | 0.8430 | 0.2396 | 0.1878 |
These results suggest that both the reconstruction benefits and the more compact query-associated Gaussian organization transfer to ACID under the evaluated domain shift.
Response to Reviewer dRN8 (Part 3 / 3)
Q4.3: Report how far the anchors move from their initialization across layers?
A4.3: Thank you for this suggestion. We have added a layer-wise displacement analysis for both LocusGS and GlobalSplat augmented with our spatial grounding design. For each decoder stage , we measure
averaged across evaluation scenes, where denotes the learned initialization in the trained checkpoint. Distances are measured in normalized scene coordinates.
Fig. 11 quantitatively shows that anchors move substantially from their initialization in both architectures. In LocusGS, displacement generally increases across 12 decoder layers, with minor fluctuations indicating further spatial readjustment. In GlobalSplat, displacement increases across four refinement rounds, with a smaller change in the final round.
Fig. 5 provides complementary visual evidence, showing how GlobalSplat's anchors progressively spread and reorganize toward the scene structure across the four rounds, with Pi3-predicted geometry included as a reference. These results show that the anchors are actively refined by multi-view evidence, rather than remaining near their learned initial positions.
Thank you for your time and effort in reviewing our paper, which helped us significantly strengthen the paper through these additional experiments and analyses. We hope our responses have satisfactorily addressed all of your concerns.
Thank you for the response and the additional experiment. After reading the author's reply, I have decided to maintain my original score. The doubts about the intermediate layer supervision have been largely resolved. Please incorporate the analysis of opacity weighting, the source of checkpoints, and the discussion of related work into the paper.
Response to Reviewer dRN8 (Part 1 / 3)
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the thorough, constructive feedback and for recognizing LocusGS’s consistent gains over TokenGS across datasets and metrics. Your comments prompted several insightful analyses, including opacity-aware Gaussian dispersion analysis, supervision-matched experiments, robustness to camera pose noise and quantitative analysis of progressive anchor refinement.
We hope these clarifications and new experiments fully address your concerns, and we would be grateful if you would consider them in your final assessment. Detailed responses to each of your questions follow below.
Q1.1: Clarify the difference between UniQueR (ECCV'26), UniGS (ICCV'25) and LeanGaussian (CVPR'25) to better position.
A1.1: Thank you for highlighting these closely related works. We agree that explicit 3D queries and Gaussian refinement have been explored previously. The key distinctions are as follows.
UniQueR uses 3D query positions during feature aggregation and predicts a one-shot query deformation after its 12-layer Transformer. In contrast, LocusGS progressively updates anchor positions across decoder layers, allowing refined positions to guide subsequent geometric attention. Moreover, LocusGS learns an adaptive support radius that jointly controls anchor-to-ray attention and local Gaussian decoding.
Interestingly, UniQueR reports a substantial PSNR drop from 20.23 to 12.11 dB with random-only initialization. In our additional experiment in Appendix Sec B.4, initializing LocusGS with Pi3-predicted point maps and FPS yields nearly identical final performance to random learnable anchors. This suggests that LocusGS is less dependent on external geometric initialization in our setting, potentially benefiting from its progressive spatial refinement.
UniGS (ICCV 2025) and LeanGaussian (CVPR 2025). Both methods focus on object-level reconstruction, refining one Gaussian per query through projection-based deformable attention. In contrast, LocusGS represents a local Gaussian group per query, with a learned center and radius jointly guiding feature aggregation and Gaussian generation.
We appreciate the reviewer's suggestions and will clarify these distinctions in the revised manuscript.
Q2.1: Could you clarify whether the TokenGS used in Figs. 1 and 5 and Table 3 is the official checkpoint or a re-trained one? Fig. 9 and Table 1 suggest the latter. If it was re-trained, does the official checkpoint show similar dispersion?
A2.1: Thank you for raising this important question. We apologize for not making the checkpoint sources sufficiently clear in the paper. We would like to clarify that we prioritize using the officially released TokenGS checkpoints whenever available, to ensure a fair comparison and avoid potential differences introduced by our own re-training.
Specifically:
DL3DV quantitative comparisons (e.g., Tables 1 and 3): All reported TokenGS results are obtained by evaluating the official checkpoints under our evaluation protocol. Interestingly, our evaluation produces slightly better results than those reported in the original TokenGS paper. For example, on DL3DV we obtain 23.44 dB PSNR, compared with 23.02 dB reported by TokenGS.
Qualitative comparisons and 3D visualizations: All TokenGS visualizations of Gaussian distributions and spatial structures (e.g., Figs. 1 and 6), as well as qualitative rendering comparisons (e.g., Figs. 4, 8, 9, and 12), are generated using the official checkpoints. Therefore, the observed Gaussian dispersion is not an artifact of our re-training.
RE10K quantitative comparisons (e.g., Table 2): Since official TokenGS checkpoints for RE10K were not available, we re-trained TokenGS following its original training setup.
Training convergence (Fig. 9): To compare convergence behavior fairly, we trained both TokenGS and LocusGS under comparable settings on DL3DV and RE10K. Our re-trained TokenGS models achieve performance close to, although slightly below, the official DL3DV checkpoints, and exhibit stable training behavior. Importantly, the re-trained models show similar Gaussian spatial dispersion to the official checkpoints.
In summary, our observations regarding Gaussian dispersion hold for both the official and re-trained TokenGS models. Re-training is performed only when necessary for datasets without released checkpoints or for controlled training-convergence comparisons.
We will clarify these checkpoint sources and evaluation settings in the revised manuscript to avoid further ambiguity.