- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors propose X-Splatter, a new feed-forward 4D gaussian prediction framework that reconstructs both static scenes and moving objects. And then X-Splatter can replay the scene along new ego trajectories. To achieve this, the authors introduce Depth Anchoring Fine-tuning for metric depth estimation and Static–Dynamic Decomposition Learning to separate static and dynamic components and learn object motion. And the results show that X-Splatter achieves SOTA performance on the Waymo dataset.
Critical strengths
I think image-based dynamic scene reconstruction is an important research topic that supports many downstream tasks. Using mixing weights to separate static and dynamic contributions and predicting the motion dynamic gaussians is a reasonable design for static-dynamic decomposition. The experimental results in Table 1 and Table 2 show the effectiveness of X-Splatter.
Critical weaknesses
I think the novelty of Depth Anchoring Fine-tuning is limited. It mainly uses LiDAR info to align the teacher model’s relative depth and construct supervision targets. In addition, does X-Splatter in Table 1 use all five cameras as input while being evaluated only on the front camera? Could the authors provide results using only the three front-facing cameras as input, allowing comparison under the same input settings as STORM and DGGT?
I also suggest reporting per-camera metrics for each method across all five cameras to provide a clearer comparison of performance across viewpoints and show more visualization results in five cameras.
Questions for authors
Please refer to the Weaknesses.
Response to Reviewer 2KoH
Thank you for the positive review.
DAF novelty. DAF's contribution is not LiDAR alignment by itself but a recipe that makes a pretrained multi-view backbone metric at one fixed scale, with no per-scene alignment at inference. Table 8 measures its steps, from 5.05 m for the released backbone (even with a global scale fit) to 3.55 m, and Table 7 shows the fixed scale is not a tuned constant.
Inputs in Table 1. Yes: the X-Splatter rows of Table 1 take all five cameras as input and score the front camera, the same as the "5 / 1" rows of Table 2(b). With only the three front cameras, its front-camera PSNR is 29.32 dB instead of 29.66 dB, so the side cameras improve even the front view. Results with only the three front cameras as input are in the general response.
Per-camera metrics and visualizations. Per-camera results for all methods are in the general response: X-Splatter leads on every camera. We add a five-camera qualitative comparison to the appendix of the revised PDF.