- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper presents TripleFlow, a training-free video object removal framework that aims to combine source-preserving residual editing with generative background reconstruction.
The authors argue that existing inversion-free residual editing methods can suppress foreground objects but often struggle to reconstruct the occluded background faithfully. To address this limitation, TripleFlow coordinates three coupled flows: a source flow that provides an analytically constructed reference trajectory, a residual flow that performs source-relative editing through velocity differences, and a synthesis flow that accumulates target-conditioned velocities to reconstruct missing background content.
The residual and synthesis estimates are blended at each sampling step, allowing the synthesized content to influence subsequent target predictions. The framework also incorporates a clean first-frame reference, spatial masks, and localized attention control to preserve the unedited scene and guide background completion.
Experiments across five evaluation settings demonstrate improvements in object removal and background reconstruction. The method achieves the highest reported CORE scores across all five settings and improves PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS on the paired PROVE-M and ROSE benchmarks. Additional ablations examine the contributions of different flows and editing controls.
Critical strengths
S1. A well-motivated approach to balancing source preservation and background generation.
The paper addresses an important challenge in training-free video object removal: removing foreground objects while faithfully reconstructing the occluded background.
The proposed combination of residual editing and native generation is conceptually interesting. By maintaining a source-aligned reference and introducing a synthesis state that contributes to the editing trajectory at each sampling step, the method attempts to balance background preservation with generative flexibility.
The reuse of the target velocity for both residual and synthesis updates is also computationally appealing, since the additional synthesis state does not require another backbone evaluation.
S2. Strong quantitative results and convincing background reconstruction examples.
The paper reports improvements across five evaluation settings, including favorable CORE scores and substantial gains in PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS on the paired PROVE-M and ROSE benchmarks.
The qualitative results illustrate challenging object removal scenarios involving camera motion, structured backgrounds, shadows, and reflections. In particular, recovering scene elements such as paintings, bookshelves, and warehouse structures is more demanding than simply filling regions with uniform textures.
The ablation studies also provide useful evidence that the different components contribute to the final performance. These results suggest that the proposed framework has practical potential for high-quality video editing.
Critical weaknesses
The claimed independent role of the synthesis flow is not fully supported by the mathematical formulation and ablation results.
The paper emphasizes that the synthesis flow independently reconstructs the occluded background and continuously provides generative feedback to the residual editing trajectory.
However, both the residual and synthesis updates reuse the same target velocity prediction. As shown in Equation (8), for an interior edited token with A = W = 1, the difference between their clean-space estimates is governed by the discrepancy between the predicted source velocity and the analytical source-path velocity.
In particular, if the source velocity prediction equals the analytical derivative of the source trajectory, the two estimates coincide under the corresponding idealized conditions. This suggests that the distinction between the two flows may be more closely related to source-velocity discrepancy correction than to independent background synthesis.
The ablation results also indicate that removing the synthesis flow leads to relatively modest changes in overall PSNR compared with removing the source or residual flow, although improvements in hole-region reconstruction and object removal remain meaningful.
These observations do not invalidate the proposed approach, but they leave uncertainty about the mechanism responsible for the synthesis flow's contribution.
A more detailed analysis of the source-velocity discrepancy, together with comparisons against simpler alternative update rules, would help establish whether the proposed three-flow coordination provides a distinct advantage beyond modifying the residual update.
Questions for authors
Q1. What is the precise mechanism through which the synthesis flow improves background reconstruction?
According to Equation (8), the difference between the residual and synthesis estimates depends on the discrepancy between the predicted source velocity and the analytical source-path velocity. Since both flows reuse the same target velocity prediction, could the authors clarify in what sense the synthesis flow provides independent background generation?
In particular, have the authors compared TripleFlow with a simpler residual update that directly uses the analytical source-path velocity, or with alternative blending strategies using the same target predictions? Such experiments would help determine whether the observed improvements arise from independent generative feedback or from correcting discrepancies in the source velocity.
Q2. How dependent is the removal of associated effects on explicitly provided and manually corrected masks?
Appendix A.2 indicates that the editing masks include the target object, shadows, and reflections, and that substantial segmentation errors are manually corrected. Since Equation (12) restores the original latent state outside the editing support, it is unclear whether the method can remove associated effects that are not explicitly included in the masks.
Could the authors provide results using object-only masks, automatically generated masks without manual correction, and masks with controlled perturbations? This would help clarify the extent to which the reported associated-effect removal capability comes from the proposed flow mechanism rather than accurate external localization.
Q3. Could the authors clarify the configurations used for efficiency comparisons?
Appendix A.3 indicates that the runtime comparisons involve different hardware, inference configurations, and timing boundaries. Could the authors provide a same-hardware comparison with consistent timing boundaries, or clarify which parts of the reported efficiency advantage can be attributed directly to the proposed method?