- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes NeSyF, a framework combining neural networks and symbolic regression, aiming to simultaneously achieve network dynamics prediction and governance equation discovery. The method first learns the dynamics using a neural network, then recovers the symbolic equations through STLSQ and PySR, and uses these equations to optimize the neural network's predictions. Experiments covering four network topologies, four dynamical systems, and two real-world epidemic datasets demonstrate that the proposed method achieves good performance in long-term prediction and equation recovery.
Critical strengths
1.The paper explores an interesting way to use recovered symbolic equations as feedback for neural dynamics learning, rather than only for post-hoc interpretation. 2.NeSyF achieves strong long-horizon prediction performance across different network topologies and dynamical systems, with improvements over existing baselines.
Critical weaknesses
-
While ablation experiments show that symbolic feedback improves prediction performance, its unique advantages over conventional regularization or knowledge distillation methods remain unclear. Could the authors provide a direct comparison to illustrate the additional benefits inherent in symbolic feedback itself?
-
Appendix B provides a tighter upper bound on the error only when the condition is met, but the paper does not prove or verify whether this condition holds. Could the authors verify this condition using synthetic experiments and report the corresponding errors?
-
Table 2 only reports the results of NeSyF combined with STLSQ and PySR, and the coefficient error of NeSyF under PySR is higher than that of LaGNA (0.1745 vs. 0.0766). Could the authors supplement the results of the combined LLC and LaGNA using the same process?
-
The actual equations in the synthetic experiment closely matched the pre-defined symbol search space, but Table 3 did not directly verify its ability to describe the dynamics of the real epidemic. Could the authors directly use the recovery equations for predictions in unseen time periods to verify whether they truly captured the underlying dynamics?
Questions for authors
See weakness