I believe the problem class considered in the paper is too simple, the data requirements and the algorithm complexity are too strong compared to the problem difficulty, and that the experimental evaluations are insufficient even for this restricted case. I layout my concerns below.
Proposed equation family is too simple & proposed algorithm is too prior-information dependent.
The family of ODEs considered in this paper is too simple. Nonetheless, if the equation form is not known to the algorithm, this paper would have had more significance. However, the proposed DA-KAN method literally fits the exact ODE family to data, with the slight addition of a learnable KAN modulation on the time dependent weights. This is relying too much on the specifics of the problem and the authors do not provide any clue as to how this approach could be extended to more difficult problems.
Another problem with this known structure of the ground truth ODE family is that it is a linear regression problem for the affine function coefficients. For y(2)+(a0t+b0)y+(a1t+b1)y(1)=0, y(2) is a linear function of a0,b0,a1,b1 - meaning that with multiple trajectories, time samples, and derivative trajectories, this is just an error-in-variables linear regression problem, with no need to train anything.
The data requirements are too strong
The proposed method requires both multiple trajectories and higher order derivative trajectories. The latter is especially problematic because in dynamics identification, the derivative estimation from noisy trajectories is the highly nontrivial part and is something algorithms like weak SINDy try to tackle. This study just provides this information as a slightly noised version of the ground truth (as opposed to derivative noise scaling as 1/Δt per derivative order), making the problem trivial.
Experimental evaluation is insufficient
The only part of the model that is not specified and must be inferred from data is the derivative order n, which is found through iterative fitting. However, experiments are run on n=2,3 only, meaning that this iterative fitting is done only once. Higher derivative orders must be experimented with the properly vet this procedure.
Overall, the paper contains fundamental issues with its problem setup that does not seem fixable with a single revision round.