- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the PS-PINN (Physics–Symbolic Physics-Informed Neural Network) framework to recover the governing PDE equation (analytical model) as well as the solution from a noisy data set. The solution is represented in terms of two components as shown in equation (1): the first term is a linear sparse combination of terms selected from a dictionary while the second term, called neural corrector, is used to capture the residual left unmodeled by the first term. Figure 1 provide a general overview of the proposed approach. Overall, the paper is written in a very superficial way. No focus at all. The Abstract and Introduction section (like the majority of sections) are written in a style that makes almost impossible to understand what is the problem definition, the strategy adopted to solve the problem, and the merits of the proposed PS-PINN. The paper fails to bring any major technical contributions. In terms of technical novelty, this paper is very weak--no solid result. This is a clear reject case.
Critical strengths
None. Sorry this is a very superficial paper that fails to bring any notable contribution.
Critical weaknesses
The presentation style is very superficial. The paper is not focused at all. Very superficial writing.
No substantial technical contributions. The authors should be more careful in presenting well known "textbook"-level material as new contributions. What is the purpose of presenting Appendix O, given the fact that all the results in this Appendix are well known on the literature? Please check a textbook in Bayesian statistics that addresses Lasso estimation and you will see these results. This gives the impression of AI generated results generated blindly without checking the literature.
Everything in this paper seems to be argued and presented in a very ad-hoc and superficial manner. The authors are asked to provide more rigorous explanations and formal analytical proofs for their claims. Next I will illustrate only a few of the many statements that are not at all justified and are very weird. These statements should not be made without a rigorous justification.
On p. 5, you state "The symbolic core represents global structure using the prescribed basis functions: periodicity, separability, exponential decay, polynomial and trigonometric shape, and the smooth bulk of the field." What you mean by "the smooth bulk of the field"? How can you ensure the generalizability or scalability of the dictionary in general settings, given the diversity of PDEs dynamics?
On p. 5, a few lines down "The neural corrector is trained to approximate residual features that are not adequately represented by the dictionary, including steep fronts and unresolved details; the curriculum encourages this allocation but does not guarantee spatial localization." None of these claims is justified. It is hard to understand how the "steep fronts and unresolved details" can be captured; not clear why "the curriculum encourages this allocation". The curriculum may not have any knowledge of the regions of high dynamics.
Four lines below eq (6), "Whether the physics term is active, and which Fc it uses, is stated per experiment: the recovered rule of Sec. 4.1, a rule with prescribed terms and estimated coefficients, or the true rule, used to study the solution branch apart from discovery error." ; it is not clear how feasible/reliable are these claims.
Questions for authors
The problem addressed requires substantial technical contributions to make its conclusions generalizable to a larger class of PDEs. A formal analytical framework is needed to justify all the claims made and to offer the necessary mathematical rigor to ensure the validity of claimed results to a larger class of PDEs. The paper needs to be rewritten in much more focused style, easy to understand and with all the claims justified.