- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Sobolev Novelty, a term-level projection residual based on function values and derivatives. It relates the metric to coefficient sensitivity and evaluates applications to symbolic search, pretraining-data filtering, and turbulence modeling.
Critical strengths
The metric requires no target derivatives and has clear projection and coefficient-sensitivity interpretations. Experiments cover multiple SR paradigms, and the value-only ablation supports the usefulness of derivative information.
Critical weaknesses
The threshold follows from an adopted tenfold tolerance on squared coefficient sensitivity relative to the orthogonal baseline. Although the derivation is clear, the robustness of the reported qualification-rate gap to this choice is not established. The GP comparison also changes the search procedure through an archive, recombination, and additional structural proposals (Appendix D.1). A matched control without Sobolev guidance would help isolate its contribution. Appendix D.5.2 describes forward-selection variants with and without Sobolev guidance, while distinguishing this implementation from the original LSTM-based DSRRANS search. The correspondence between these variants and the DSRRANS/SN-DSRRANS rows in Table 1 should be explicit.
Questions for authors
- How sensitive is the reported qualification-rate gap to the threshold?
- Can SN-GP be compared with the same search components and budget, but without Sobolev guidance?
- Please confirm which implementations produced the DSRRANS and SN-DSRRANS rows in Table 1.
My weak rejection is mainly due to uncertainty about the source of the reported gains. Controlled comparisons and implementation clarification could change my assessment.