- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The idea of this paper is that a lot of the interesting bits of a fluid simulation happens near boundaries, and so a learning system can be designed that has higher "resolution" near boundaries and less "resolution" away from boundaries, to more efficiently capture representations of fluids. In that sense, I believe this paper is indeed about a learning-based representation of a fluid and is on topic for ICLR. The resulting system is demonstrated to be around 20x faster on a GPU, compared to a basic U-Net.
Critical strengths
The core idea of having a network architecture that is adaptive to where the high-frequency details of a problem are is not novel, but in the context of applying that to fluid simulations, I think there is potential novelty, and it seems like a nice idea.
Critical weaknesses
My main issue is the comparison point here is a CNN/U-Net from 2020. There have been many advancements since then - for instance, EddyFormer is about 30x faster than solver-in-the-loop, as well as Universal Physics Transformers, which are also very fast compared to U-Nets. While the authors' baseline comparisons could be valid, I think there is a lack of justification for using an old algorithm as a reference compared to one of these newer techniques out there.
The paper also only considers very low Reynolds number flow (Re <= 500) which by the authors' own admission in the limitations section means we don't really know how well this method applies to more chaotic/turbulent fluid simulations. My guess is that for such simulations, there is more of that high-frequency noise throughout the fluid domain, so the neural boundary technique will not work as well, but that would be interesting to see regardless.
Questions for authors
See above