- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes LibCorrNet, a neural operator for singularly perturbed and multiscale PDEs. It combines an FNO-based global branch with a corrector branch that evaluates a fixed library of functions on learned coordinates and combines the resulting features through spatially varying neural weights. The same library is reused across separately trained PDE configurations, avoiding the need to prescribe a different analytical corrector for each problem.
Experiments cover boundary, corner, and interior layers, nonlinear reaction--diffusion equations, and Helmholtz problems. The authors report the lowest mean relative error in 19 of 20 main settings using approximately 82K parameters. Additional experiments investigate component ablations, candidate-library selection, perturbation-scale adaptation, a circular domain, and oscillatory forcing.
Critical strengths
-
The architecture offers a practical compromise between generic neural operators and problem-specific analytical enrichment. A fixed candidate library, learned coordinate representation, and adaptive weighting can accommodate different localized structures without redesigning the corrector module for every benchmark. The authors also appropriately acknowledge that intermediate representations are not uniquely identifiable and that the method retains, rather than eliminates, structural prior knowledge.
-
The empirical study covers several PDE families, multiple training budgets, and ten independent runs, with 1,024 held-out test instances per configuration. LibCorrNet achieves the lowest reported mean error in 19 of 20 main settings using fewer parameters than the compared models. The component ablations, circular-domain experiment, and oscillatory-source tests provide useful additional evidence beyond a single favorable benchmark.
Critical weaknesses
-
The central layer-resolution claim is not adequately validated on the evaluation grid. Its spacing is approximately , whereas convection-dominated layers at have width . An enriched reference solver does not remove this evaluation bottleneck. Without layer-adapted sampling, convergence checks, or localized and derivative-based errors, the reported global accuracy may largely reflect agreement away from the thin layers.
-
The benchmark definitions contain material asymptotic inconsistencies. For the stated interior operator , homogeneous solutions satisfy , rather than the Gaussian derivative underlying an error-function transition. Appendix A.0.4 also describes an outflow layer for a reaction--diffusion equation without advection, whereas Table 5 uses profiles. These discrepancies leave the implemented equations and reference correctors unclear.
-
The claimed robustness to excluding the exact analytical corrector is insufficiently demonstrated. Appendix C.4 samples candidates from a pool that still contains exponential and error-function families, but does not identify a controlled exclusion configuration for each target PDE. Comparing random libraries with an Exact baseline does not establish that performance remains robust when the corresponding analytical profile or function family is deliberately unavailable.
-
The ablations do not fully isolate the value of the proposed structural prior. Removing candidate transformations compares against an identity transformation, rather than a matched branch using generic nonlinear features. Moreover, the boundary-layer results without are worse than FNO at every reported training budget, contradicting the broad claim that coordinate learning alone improves performance. More controlled comparisons are needed to attribute the gains to the candidate library.
-
Input-adaptive coordinate learning is only weakly tested by the main benchmarks. The coordinate branch excludes , while and are fixed within the described configurations; its input therefore remains unchanged as forcing samples vary. Several source constructions also depend on only one spatial coordinate. These settings support learning reusable templates within restricted configurations, but provide limited evidence of adaptation to sample-dependent layer locations, scales, or genuinely two-dimensional structures.
-
Essential implementation details are missing despite the method's sensitivity to its internal representation. The manuscript does not clearly specify the dimensionality of , how scalar and two-variable candidates are evaluated on it, the complete weighting-network architecture, or the precise non-positive-domain constraint used for exponentials. The enriched solver's construction and convergence are also insufficiently documented. With code deferred until after review, these omissions materially limit reproducibility.
-
The statistical evidence does not establish the reliability of several reported rankings. Table 9 provides variability only for LibCorrNet on four families, without corresponding baseline statistics or Helmholtz uncertainty. Some differences are extremely small, such as versus for Helmholtz at . Using official default hyperparameters also does not demonstrate comparable tuning effort, leaving the robustness of the 19-of-20 ranking uncertain.
Questions for authors
-
At which spatial locations and with what quadrature are the reported errors evaluated? Can the main conclusions be verified using layer-adapted evaluation points, localized errors, and derivative-sensitive metrics? Please also provide convergence evidence for the enriched reference solver and clarify how predictions are evaluated between the original grid points, where most thin-layer variation occurs.
-
Does the interior-layer implementation use or ? Please reconcile the implemented equation with the error-function profile and Figure 8. For nonlinear reaction--diffusion, what boundary conditions, solution-selection procedure, and layer scaling were actually used? Do the inconsistencies in Appendix A affect only the exposition, or also reference generation and baseline construction?
-
Which precise experiments remove the analytical corrector associated with each target PDE? Please list the retained candidates, exclusion rules, and number of library-selection seeds. Were entire matching function families excluded, or only individual expressions? Also, does the Exact row represent a controlled LibCorrNet variant or the ComFNO baseline, whose reported values appear identical?
-
Are models trained separately for each fixed configuration, making the learned coordinate map identical across forcing samples? What evidence demonstrates adaptation when layer locations or scales vary within one trained model? Can the library-specific benefit be isolated using a matched residual architecture with generic nonlinear features while preserving the coordinate and weighting modules?
-
Please provide baseline run-to-run variability, paired comparisons where available, and the hyperparameter-selection protocol used for all methods. Could you also specify the coordinate output dimensions, candidate-evaluation rules, weighting-network layers, and exponential constraint? These details would help determine whether the small performance margins and claimed parameter efficiency are reproducible under comparable experimental conditions.
W2 & Q2. Reusability and Required Prior Knowledge
The forcing functions in the nonlinear reaction–diffusion and boundary-layer problems are chosen to satisfy the prescribed periodic boundary conditions. For the interior-layer problem, the compatibility condition (f(0)=0) ensures that the limiting equation remains consistent at the turning point, where (b(0)=0) and (b'(0)>0), and admits the asymptotic corrector profile considered in our paper. In contrast, when (f(0)=0), the limiting problem becomes singular at the turning point and requires a different treatment, such as the lifting-based correction discussed in the existing numerical analysis literature. These conditions characterize the asymptotic structure of the benchmark problems rather than restrictions imposed by LibCorrNet. We clarify this distinction and the periodic boundary conditions in Appendix B of the revised manuscript and will add the corresponding references.
As shown in Table 6, all benchmarks use the same candidate library, architecture, and hyperparameters, following the common input specification ((x,f,b(x),ε)). Models are trained separately for each PDE, but no PDE-specific analytical correctors or stretched coordinates are prescribed. Learned Fourier coordinates and spatial weights adapt the shared candidates to different layer locations and scales.
Table 2 evaluates candidate transformations, while Appendix C.4 examines candidate subsets. We agree that random subsets alone do not establish robustness to removing an entire relevant profile family. Therefore, we conducted controlled experiments excluding the analytical corrector corresponding to each PDE, as well as its entire associated function family. The results have been added to Table 3 of the revised manuscript.
Our claim is reduced dependence on PDE-specific analytical correctors, not elimination of asymptotic prior knowledge or zero-shot transfer. The demonstrated reusability is limited to the elliptic-type PDE benchmarks considered.
W3 & Q3. Layer-Adapted Evaluation and Reference Validation
We agree that the original (52\times52) grid, although consistent with previous studies [1, 2] and ComFNO, cannot adequately resolve (O(\varepsilon)) boundary and corner layers for (\varepsilon=10^{-5}). Uniform resolution with (h=O(\varepsilon)) would require quadratically increasing grid points in 2D, resulting in substantial computational costs. However, the interior-layer problem exhibits a distinguishable transition even for small (\varepsilon) on the original (52\times52) grid, as illustrated by the reference solution in Figure 1 ((https://imgur.com/a/Mq0kxyR)).
We therefore performed additional evaluations for boundary and corner layers using nonuniform grids, adding evaluation points at the (10^{-3}), (10^{-4}), and (10^{-5}) spatial scales near the relevant boundaries. We focused on these problems because the interior-layer and nonlinear reaction–diffusion structures are already distinguishable on the original grid.
Relative errors and maximum absolute errors ((\times10^{-2})); 800 training and 120 test samples.
LibCorrNet achieves the lowest full-domain relative (L^2) errors in both problems and the lowest localized error for boundary layers. For corner layers, its localized error is lower than CNO's and comparable to FNO's. It also achieves the lowest maximum absolute errors in both problems. Figures 8 and 9 ((https://imgur.com/a/Mq0kxyR)) visualize the maximum absolute error at each evaluation point across 120 test samples for the boundary-layer and corner-layer problems, respectively, including magnified views of the thin-layer regions. The experimental results and corresponding visualizations have been added to Section 4.2 of the revised manuscript.