- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes Sculpt, an autoregressive urban-wind surrogate whose output parameterization enforces discrete incompressibility and wall impermeability on a staggered grid. A volume vector potential yields divergence-free velocity increments, while a shared scalar potential and harmonic modes constrain boundary values so the same curl readout has zero wall-normal velocity. A multiresolution potential parameterization addresses the scale-dependent gradients induced by the curl.
Critical strengths
- The evaluation is good. It covers reduced-order, convolutional, spectral, and attention baselines, as well as targeted constraint ablations and a post-projection comparator
- The core construction seems to be well motivated. The authors connect the discrete operators directly to the two advertised guarantees rather than relying on soft penalties.
Critical weaknesses
- I am not sure if the statistical analysis is sufficient here in this paper. Reported deviations are over overlapping test rollouts, not independent training runs. It would be better to provide repeated training seeds and paired sequence-level results, especially for the smaller ablation gains.
- “Geometry generalization” is a bit overstated. Held-out layouts and morphology classes test transfer within one procedural, grid-aligned generator.
- Avoiding pressure projection is presented as an efficiency advantage, yet no matched latency, throughput, memory, or parameter comparison is reported. The rollout guarantee also requires an admissible initial field; can the authors clarify how imperfect initial fields would be handled.
Questions for authors
- How far do the held-out layout and morphology results support transfer beyond this grid-aligned procedural generator and fixed periodic domain?
- Is there evidence on measured city layouts or nonperiodic horizontal boundaries? For curved boundaries, cut cells, and other discretizations, what changes would be needed to retain the guarantee?
- How stable are the gains over U-Net and P3D across independent training seeds and held-out sequences, using paired sequence-level comparisons?
- What are matched per-step latency, rollout time, peak memory, parameter count, and training cost relative to U-Net, P3D, and the post-projection baseline?
- Beyond the shared inputs, splits, epochs, and checkpoint rule, how were pushforward training, hyperparameter tuning, and model capacity handled for each baseline? Were capacity or tuning-budget sensitivity checks performed?
7 comments
Author Response to Reviewer TScW (W2 & Q1, W3)
Response to W2 & Q1 (continued):
To Q1: Our experiments provide evidence of geometric transfer at two levels: held-out layouts test generalization to unseen building arrangements, while held-out morphology classes further evaluate transfer to geometric patterns absent from training. These results demonstrate that Sculpt can generalize beyond the specific geometries encountered during training, rather than merely memorizing individual layouts. However, both evaluations remain within the same procedural generation framework, grid-aligned representation, and periodic domain. Transfer to held-out layouts or nonperiodic domains has not yet been evaluated and remains an important direction for future work, as discussed in the Limitations and Future Work section.
References
[1] GeoWind2Plan: Mission-Time 3D Urban Wind Prediction for Energy-Efficient UAV Planning. NeurIPS, 2026.
[2] Generalization of urban wind environment using Fourier neural operator across different wind directions and cities. arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.05499 (2025).
[3] Building a general and data-efficient convolutional neural network-based model for fast urban flow estimation. Building and Environment (2026): 114488.
[4] A convolutional neural network for steady-state flow approximation trained on a small sample size. Atmosphere 14.9 (2023): 1462.
[5] From large-eddy simulations to deep learning: A U-net model for fast urban canopy flow predictions. Sustainable Cities and Society (2025): 107005.
W3: Computational Efficiency and Imperfect Initial Fields
Response to W3:
Thank you for raising these two points. We have incorporated a computational complexity analysis into the revised manuscript to provide a more direct efficiency comparison. Specifically, we use the existing "w/ post-projection" ablation as the reference and evaluate two pressure-Poisson solvers: the original Conjugate Gradient (CG) method [1] and a GPU-based Fast Fourier Transform–preconditioned Conjugate Gradient (FFT-PCG) implementation [2]. Both projection variants share the same trained velocity predictor and introduce no additional trainable parameters. The reported inference costs account for the complete prediction process, including velocity prediction and pressure projection.
\hline \text{Method} & \begin{array}{c}\text{Unseen layouts: }\\\\\text{Train (s/epoch)}\end{array} & \begin{array}{c}\text{Unseen layouts: }\\\\\text{Inference (s/step)}\end{array} & \begin{array}{c}\text{Unseen morphologies: }\\\\\text{Train (s/epoch)}\end{array} & \begin{array}{c}\text{Unseen morphologies: }\\\\\text{Inference (s/step)}\end{array} & \begin{array}{c}\text{Unseen inflows: }\\\\\text{Train (s/epoch)}\end{array} & \begin{array}{c}\text{Unseen inflows: }\\\\\text{Inference (s/step)}\end{array} \\\\ \hline \text{PALM (LES; 16 MPI processes)} & \text{—} & 4.32 & \text{—} & 4.32 & \text{—} & 4.32 \\\\ \text{Dil-ResNet} & 457.93 & 0.08987 & 457.93 & 0.08830 & 577.85 & 0.09110 \\\\ \text{U-Net} & 489.18 & 0.05750 & 489.18 & 0.05634 & 588.68 & 0.05896 \\\\ \text{PCNO} & 349.10 & 0.07809 & 349.10 & 0.07824 & 451.88 & 0.07704 \\\\ \text{clawFNO} & 327.71 & 0.04532 & 327.71 & 0.04721 & 419.23 & 0.04586 \\\\ \text{w/ post-projection (CG)} & \text{-} & 2.93838 & \text{-} & 0.36412 & \text{-} & 2.92871 \\\\ \text{w/ post-projection (FFT-PCG)} & \text{-} & 0.09854 & \text{-} & 0.09470 & \text{-} & 0.09782 \\\\ \text{Sculpt} & 314.9 & 0.0570 & 314.9 & 0.0608 & 396.0 & 0.0596 \\\\ \hline \end{array}$$ **Train** measures one complete training epoch, and **Inference** measures one autoregressive prediction step. Neural timings use an NVIDIA A800 GPU. PALM uses 16 MPI processes, and its entry measures the time required to advance the simulation by one step of frame. Regarding imperfect initial fields, Sculpt's nested potential guarantees that each predicted velocity increment satisfies both discrete constraints. Consequently, the rollout preserves the constraint residuals of the initial state rather than correcting existing violations. In our current setting, predictions start from ground-truth LES frames that satisfy these constraints up to numerical precision. For non-admissible initial states, a possible extension is to apply a compatible pressure projection before rollout, restoring admissibility without requiring repeated projection at subsequent prediction steps. We leave the evaluation of this extension to future work. **References** [1] Hestenes, M. R., and Stiefel, E. Methods of Conjugate Gradients for Solving Linear Systems. Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards, 49(6):409–436, 1952. [2] Storti, M. A., et al. A FFT preconditioning technique for the solution of incompressible flow on GPUs. Computers & Fluids, 74:44–57, 2013.Author Response to Reviewer TScW (Q2, Q3, Q4)
Q2: Real-City Layouts, Nonperiodic Boundaries, and Other Discretizations
Response to Q2:
We have not yet evaluated Sculpt on survey-derived city layouts or domains with nonperiodic horizontal boundaries. Extending Sculpt to nonperiodic domains would require adapting the boundary construction to distinguish impermeable walls from open boundaries and accommodate compatible inlet/outlet conditions.
For curved boundaries, cut cells, and alternative discretizations, preserving the guarantees would require compatible discrete operators that retain the divergence–curl and curl–gradient identities, together with a boundary assembly adapted to the new geometric representation [3, 4]. This also requires consistent treatment of face areas, cell volumes, and normal-flux degrees of freedom. Developing and validating these extensions remains an important direction for future work, as discussed in the Limitations and Future Work section.
Q3: Stability across Training Seeds and Held-Out Sequences
Response to Q3:
We report the completed comparisons across three training runs under the unseen-layout and unseen-morphology settings. MSE values are in units of and are reported as mean ± sample standard deviation across training runs.
Unseen layouts
\hline \text{Method} & \text{MSE@1 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@4 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@8 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@16 }\downarrow \\\\ \hline \text{Dil-ResNet} & 1.14 \pm 0.38 & 10.52 \pm 2.73 & 36.53 \pm 6.60 & 105.82 \pm 32.31 \\\\ \text{TFNO} & 14.82 \pm 6.01 & 30.70 \pm 6.10 & 56.85 \pm 12.61 & 109.66 \pm 32.28 \\\\ \text{AFNO} & 10.49 \pm 1.76 & 29.01 \pm 1.24 & 44.00 \pm 1.85 & 63.13 \pm 2.05 \\\\ \text{AViT} & 7.64 \pm 0.25 & 17.88 \pm 0.26 & 33.53 \pm 0.92 & 59.31 \pm 1.32 \\\\ \text{P3D} & 1.08 \pm 0.06 & 6.67 \pm 0.72 & 19.11 \pm 2.10 & 44.52 \pm 1.29 \\\\ \text{U-Net} & 0.54 \pm 0.07 & 3.00 \pm 0.26 & 8.47 \pm 0.51 & 24.40 \pm 1.33 \\\\ \text{PCNO} & 21.11 \pm 0.01 & 34.69 \pm 0.08 & 40.97 \pm 0.25 & 49.48 \pm 0.43 \\\\ \text{clawFNO} & 17.28 \pm 0.18 & 27.33 \pm 0.26 & 33.74 \pm 0.64 & 44.68 \pm 2.01 \\\\ \text{Sculpt} & 0.21 \pm 0.01 & 0.91 \pm 0.15 & 3.35 \pm 0.48 & 14.59 \pm 1.14 \\\\ \hline \end{array}$$ **Unseen morphologies** $$\begin{array}{l|cccc} \hline \text{Method} & \text{MSE@1 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@4 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@8 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@16 }\downarrow \\\\ \hline \text{Dil-ResNet} & 1.76 \pm 0.62 & 15.15 \pm 3.87 & 48.43 \pm 7.86 & 128.20 \pm 36.53 \\\\ \text{TFNO} & 19.10 \pm 7.71 & 41.24 \pm 7.48 & 73.37 \pm 16.26 & 125.24 \pm 33.84 \\\\ \text{AFNO} & 13.96 \pm 2.17 & 38.64 \pm 1.38 & 59.62 \pm 2.04 & 91.07 \pm 4.56 \\\\ \text{AViT} & 10.57 \pm 0.21 & 27.82 \pm 0.80 & 53.25 \pm 1.95 & 88.56 \pm 2.80 \\\\ \text{P3D} & 1.67 \pm 0.09 & 10.10 \pm 0.75 & 28.44 \pm 1.76 & 61.66 \pm 1.44 \\\\ \text{U-Net} & 0.82 \pm 0.10 & 4.91 \pm 0.57 & 13.86 \pm 1.44 & 37.28 \pm 3.52 \\\\ \text{PCNO} & 25.80 \pm 0.01 & 44.61 \pm 0.25 & 54.52 \pm 0.60 & 68.09 \pm 1.08 \\\\ \text{clawFNO} & 21.40 \pm 0.16 & 36.39 \pm 0.14 & 47.06 \pm 0.70 & 64.31 \pm 3.10 \\\\ \text{Sculpt} & 0.30 \pm 0.02 & 1.62 \pm 0.23 & 6.00 \pm 0.60 & 24.34 \pm 0.78 \\\\ \hline \end{array}$$ We will report the complete multi-seed experimental results in the revised manuscript. ------ **Q4: Computational Cost Relative to U-Net, P3D, and Pressure Projection** **Response to Q4:** We have added **Appendix D.4** to the revised manuscript, including complexity analysis and runtime comparisons. The corresponding training cost, inference latency, peak memory, and parameter count comparisons are shown below:
Author Response to Reviewer TScW (W1, W2 & Q1)
We thank the reviewer for the comments. Please find our responses to your concerns below.
W1: Statistical Analysis
Response to W1:
The mean and standard deviation reported in the manuscript summarize predictions across different test sequences and frames. As requested, we report the mean and sample standard deviation across three training seeds for the main experiments under the unseen-layout and unseen-morphology settings, and for the ablation study under the unseen-layout setting. All MSE values are in units of 10−3. We will report the complete experimental results in the revised manuscript.
Main experiments — Unseen layouts
\hline \text{Method} & \text{MSE@1 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@4 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@8 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@16 }\downarrow \\\\ \hline \text{Dil-ResNet} & 1.14 \pm 0.38 & 10.52 \pm 2.73 & 36.53 \pm 6.60 & 105.82 \pm 32.31 \\\\ \text{TFNO} & 14.82 \pm 6.01 & 30.70 \pm 6.10 & 56.85 \pm 12.61 & 109.66 \pm 32.28 \\\\ \text{AFNO} & 10.49 \pm 1.76 & 29.01 \pm 1.24 & 44.00 \pm 1.85 & 63.13 \pm 2.05 \\\\ \text{AViT} & 7.64 \pm 0.25 & 17.88 \pm 0.26 & 33.53 \pm 0.92 & 59.31 \pm 1.32 \\\\ \text{P3D} & 1.08 \pm 0.06 & 6.67 \pm 0.72 & 19.11 \pm 2.10 & 44.52 \pm 1.29 \\\\ \text{U-Net} & 0.54 \pm 0.07 & 3.00 \pm 0.26 & 8.47 \pm 0.51 & 24.40 \pm 1.33 \\\\ \text{PCNO} & 21.11 \pm 0.01 & 34.69 \pm 0.08 & 40.97 \pm 0.25 & 49.48 \pm 0.43 \\\\ \text{clawFNO} & 17.28 \pm 0.18 & 27.33 \pm 0.26 & 33.74 \pm 0.64 & 44.68 \pm 2.01 \\\\ \text{Sculpt} & 0.21 \pm 0.01 & 0.91 \pm 0.15 & 3.35 \pm 0.48 & 14.59 \pm 1.14 \\\\ \hline \end{array}$$ **Main experiments — Unseen morphologies** $$\begin{array}{l|cccc} \hline \text{Method} & \text{MSE@1 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@4 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@8 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@16 }\downarrow \\\\ \hline \text{Dil-ResNet} & 1.76 \pm 0.62 & 15.15 \pm 3.87 & 48.43 \pm 7.86 & 128.20 \pm 36.53 \\\\ \text{TFNO} & 19.10 \pm 7.71 & 41.24 \pm 7.48 & 73.37 \pm 16.26 & 125.24 \pm 33.84 \\\\ \text{AFNO} & 13.96 \pm 2.17 & 38.64 \pm 1.38 & 59.62 \pm 2.04 & 91.07 \pm 4.56 \\\\ \text{AViT} & 10.57 \pm 0.21 & 27.82 \pm 0.80 & 53.25 \pm 1.95 & 88.56 \pm 2.80 \\\\ \text{P3D} & 1.67 \pm 0.09 & 10.10 \pm 0.75 & 28.44 \pm 1.76 & 61.66 \pm 1.44 \\\\ \text{U-Net} & 0.82 \pm 0.10 & 4.91 \pm 0.57 & 13.86 \pm 1.44 & 37.28 \pm 3.52 \\\\ \text{PCNO} & 25.80 \pm 0.01 & 44.61 \pm 0.25 & 54.52 \pm 0.60 & 68.09 \pm 1.08 \\\\ \text{clawFNO} & 21.40 \pm 0.16 & 36.39 \pm 0.14 & 47.06 \pm 0.70 & 64.31 \pm 3.10 \\\\ \text{Sculpt} & 0.30 \pm 0.02 & 1.62 \pm 0.23 & 6.00 \pm 0.60 & 24.34 \pm 0.78 \\\\ \hline \end{array}$$ **Ablation study — Unseen layouts** $$\begin{array}{l|cc} \hline \text{Variant} & \text{MSE@1 }\downarrow & \text{MSE@16 }\downarrow \\\\ \hline \text{Sculpt} & 0.21 \pm 0.01 & 14.59 \pm 1.14 \\\\ \text{w/o null-space }\Psi_g & 0.41 \pm 0.02 & 31.17 \pm 0.22 \\\\ \text{w/ soft penalty} & 17.39 \pm 7.12 & 115.26 \pm 13.76 \\\\ \text{w/ post-projection} & 0.36 \pm 0.02 & 25.26 \pm 0.82 \\\\ \text{w/o boundary }G & 0.27 \pm 0.02 & 19.32 \pm 2.50 \\\\ \text{w/o increment }\Delta\mathbf{u} & 11.31 \pm 6.74 & 3349.35 \pm 914.49 \\\\ \text{w/o multi-scale }\mathbf{A} & 0.21 \pm 0.01 & 15.35 \pm 0.75 \\\\ \text{w/o learned fusion} & 0.24 \pm 0.02 & 16.65 \pm 1.67 \\\\ \hline \end{array}$$ These results show that our model’s performance and the gains demonstrated by the ablations are consistent across seeds. ------ **W2 & Q1: Scope of Geometry Generalization** **Response to W2 & Q1:** In urban wind modeling, previous studies [1,2,3] have similarly evaluated generalization using unseen geometries generated within a shared procedural framework. For example, [4] evaluated unseen urban geometries from the same parametric generator, while [5] tested unseen synthetic urban layouts generated under common geometric rules. Consistent with these established evaluation practices, our experiments assess generalization to both unseen layouts and held-out morphology classes. Therefore, we believe geometry generalization appropriately describes the evaluated capability, without implying unrestricted transfer across arbitrary geometric representations or domains.