- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes SimDFKs, a fluid simulation method based on divergence-free kernels (DFKs). By optimizing the parameters of continuous kernels, the method simulates fluid motion while guaranteeing incompressibility by construction. It also improves vortex preservation, simulation accuracy, and representation efficiency.
Critical strengths
-
The paper is well-written, clear, and easy to follow.
-
The paper addresses a meaningful and interesting research problem.
-
The proposed Single-Curl formulation improves upon the previous Double-Curl design and extends DFKs from flow reconstruction to forward simulation. The authors combine it with existing vorticity transport and optimization techniques, and demonstrate its effectiveness through extensive experiments.
Critical weaknesses
-
High computational cost. While SimDFKs shows good accuracy and incompressibility, I am concerned about its practical value. In the Taylor–Green experiment, it is about 15,000 times slower than the Eulerian solver. Could a higher-resolution grid-based solver achieve similar or better accuracy with the same computational budget? I suggest adding a fair accuracy–runtime comparison to better demonstrate the advantages of SimDFKs.
-
Limited evaluation of physical consistency. Although the paper evaluates incompressibility and smoke mass preservation, a more comprehensive analysis of physical consistency, particularly long-term energy and circulation conservation, would further strengthen the work.
-
Concerns about sparse recovery. In Appendix A.6, the 10% observation experiment still uses full reference data for interpolation and normalization. Can the method achieve similar results using only the sparse observations? I suggest adding an experiment without this extra information.
Questions for authors
See Weaknesses.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the positive assessment of the paper's clarity, the single-curl reformulation, and the extension of DFKs to forward simulation. Following the reviewer's suggestions, we added several experiments to better characterize the accuracy–cost trade-off and sparse-recovery setting; these changes are summarized in the Revision Cover Letter above.
Accuracy–runtime trade-off. Using the taylor vortex example, we add a comparison against the Eulerian method with a 1281×1281 MAC-grid, which takes up more computational time than our method. The measured last-frame vorticity MSE (Table 8) and visualized vorticity sequences (Figure 8) show that our method achieves higher accuracy than Eulerian method under same time budget.
Energy and circulation. We do not claim exact energy or circulation conservation, since the optimization and reinitialization steps introduce approximation errors. Our 3D leapfrogging experiment instead provides qualitative evidence of long-term preservation of coherent vortex dynamics through repeated interactions. We have clarified the scope of this claim in the revision.
Sparse recovery. We repeat the experiment without full-reference interpolation or normalization (Table 2). Filtering and normalization use retained observations only, while complete reference fields are reserved for post-recovery evaluation. The revised results still show substantial improvement over independent fitting. After 30 rounds, the four reported errors are 7.786×10−3, 7.477×10−3, 1.715×10−4, and 9.756×10−4, compared with independent-fit errors of 2.137×10−1, 1.589×10−1, 8.151×10−3, and 4.637×10−2. The stricter protocol slightly increases the errors, but the substantial improvement over independent fitting remains, confirming our original conclusion under a more rigorous and transparent evaluation.
We greatly appreciate the reviewer's suggestions, particularly the request for a more direct accuracy–runtime comparison and a stricter sparse-recovery protocol. We hope these additional experiments and clarifications address the reviewer's concerns and provide a more complete and balanced evaluation of SimDFKs. We would be happy to further discuss any remaining questions.