- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper claims CFD needs to maintain representation accuracy in long-term prediction, and current work has limited modeling in both temporal and spatial dimensions, limiting accuracy. So the author proposes FlowGen with FHTK. It uses a transient-state mask that activates only the latest three states. A normalized finite support kernel is used to determine which states contribute to the loss. The proposed method obtains the lowest reported mean in all 48 condition--metric comparisons.
Critical strengths
- Part of the motivation is from physical intuition, which provides a clear background and structure.
- The paper provides all 48 condition-metric comparisons for the evaluation of the method.
Critical weaknesses
- The use of limited history windows has been explored in prior methods, and similar designs can be found for other proposed components. The main contribution appears to lie in integrating these components into a structured framework, but this requires clearer justification and more direct comparisons with simpler alternatives. Moreover, the proposed methods do not consistently outperform simpler baselines in some settings, raising concerns about their effectiveness and necessity.
- Beyond the concerns mentioned above, the experimental evaluation remains insufficient. The ablation studies do not clearly isolate the contributions of individual components or adequately support their claimed benefits. A more detailed analysis of the design choices would be valuable, and the key findings should be included in the main text to better justify the proposed framework.
Questions for authors
- What are the key novel contributions beyond existing methods with similar designs?
- Why is the proposed framework necessary when simpler methods achieve comparable performance?
- Can the authors provide more targeted ablations to isolate and validate the contributions of individual components?